NOTE IMDb
6,6/10
15 k
MA NOTE
Après avoir appris via un test ADN qu'elle a de très nombreux demi-frères et demi-sœurs, une femme découvre le terrible secret d'un médecin spécialiste de la fertilité.Après avoir appris via un test ADN qu'elle a de très nombreux demi-frères et demi-sœurs, une femme découvre le terrible secret d'un médecin spécialiste de la fertilité.Après avoir appris via un test ADN qu'elle a de très nombreux demi-frères et demi-sœurs, une femme découvre le terrible secret d'un médecin spécialiste de la fertilité.
- Récompenses
- 1 nomination au total
Robert Colver
- Self - Cline's Former Partner
- (as Dr. Robert Colver)
Jan Shore
- Self - Cline's Former Nurse
- (as Jan Shore RN)
Avis à la une
If not for the misogynistic and bigoted 1, 2, 3, 4 star reviews, I would not have reviewed this documentary myself. This documentary is not overly dramatic. What Dr. Cline did is horrible, and the story needs to be shared. This is not something you can just move on from and continue as if life is normal. It's not okay, it's not normal, and Dr. Cline is NOT a "good Christian man."
There are some rather dumb people reviewing here saying "What's the big deal, you needed insemination from a stranger anyway?" When someone seeks artificial insemination, back then and now, they choose from a pool of donors who've been through health screening. Meaning anyone with a medical condition is forbidden from being a sperm donor.
This imbecile Cline is/was not a healthy man. He has/had auto immune disease. He wouldn't have even gotten through the first hoop of donor screening! So you see, there's a problem here. And this is just ONE of the issues with what he did. He co-created nearly 100 human beings that are now predisposed to becoming ill.
The film needed to be dramatic to get the message through to the public more effectively.
I'm not going to detail the rest of the issues related to his conduct, but this criminal needs an appropriate prison sentence, or be admitted to an asylum. One, to assist his victims to move into closure mode, and two, to set an example for other offenders who wish to violate women in this way.
This imbecile Cline is/was not a healthy man. He has/had auto immune disease. He wouldn't have even gotten through the first hoop of donor screening! So you see, there's a problem here. And this is just ONE of the issues with what he did. He co-created nearly 100 human beings that are now predisposed to becoming ill.
The film needed to be dramatic to get the message through to the public more effectively.
I'm not going to detail the rest of the issues related to his conduct, but this criminal needs an appropriate prison sentence, or be admitted to an asylum. One, to assist his victims to move into closure mode, and two, to set an example for other offenders who wish to violate women in this way.
No federal law?
94 siblings, the result of a cruel and perverted acted by fertility Doctor, Doctor Donald Cline, who used his own semen samples inside his fertility Clinic, his victims unaware of his warped ideas.
This was such a good watch, so sickening, a plot that I've seen on a TV drama, where I can't remember, it seems so extreme, so abhorrent, you wouldn't expect to see it in real life, this is that story.
I have a full admiration for those that spoke, you get the sense of anger and injustice that each felt, and rightly so, Cline's acts were grotesque, once again we see someone trying to justify their acts in the name of religion.
It was arguably a little long, and personally I wasn't too sure about the idea to take it to The Doctor Jones show, that seemed to demean the tragic story somewhat, the look of glee on the faces of the audience members didn't sit right with me.
All in all, a shocking, intriguing watch, 8/10.
94 siblings, the result of a cruel and perverted acted by fertility Doctor, Doctor Donald Cline, who used his own semen samples inside his fertility Clinic, his victims unaware of his warped ideas.
This was such a good watch, so sickening, a plot that I've seen on a TV drama, where I can't remember, it seems so extreme, so abhorrent, you wouldn't expect to see it in real life, this is that story.
I have a full admiration for those that spoke, you get the sense of anger and injustice that each felt, and rightly so, Cline's acts were grotesque, once again we see someone trying to justify their acts in the name of religion.
It was arguably a little long, and personally I wasn't too sure about the idea to take it to The Doctor Jones show, that seemed to demean the tragic story somewhat, the look of glee on the faces of the audience members didn't sit right with me.
All in all, a shocking, intriguing watch, 8/10.
Very good documentary but painful to watch. I got really mad watching this and to learn that Dr. Cline served no jail time just says everything about how flawed the US legal system is. 94 shared siblings and still counting. Damn this doctor has no remorse whatsoever.
A shocking documentary which I didn't think would have been possible had I not watched it.
He broke no laws but just because a law doesn't exist for this type of immoral behaviour doesn't make it any less heinous, not least because he had medical issues himself ruling him out from being a donor.
As a documentary it was 'ok' but a little too long.
7 out of 10. It's worth a watch.
He broke no laws but just because a law doesn't exist for this type of immoral behaviour doesn't make it any less heinous, not least because he had medical issues himself ruling him out from being a donor.
As a documentary it was 'ok' but a little too long.
7 out of 10. It's worth a watch.
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesToutes les informations contiennent des spoilers
- GaffesAngela or Angelia Golden, the child whom Dr Cline ran over while driving through a neighborhood, might have been African-American. Her grandfather, Joe Golden GXQF-QLZ, at FamilySearch, is shown as Black in the 1920 US Census source attached.
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
- How long is Our Father?Alimenté par Alexa
Détails
- Durée1 heure 37 minutes
- Couleur
- Mixage
- Rapport de forme
- 2.0:1
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant
Lacune principale
What was the official certification given to Notre père à tous (2022) in Japan?
Répondre