Un varón

One of the films that opened the Mostra Internacional de São Paulo, "Un varón" ("A Man") marks as the debut of Fabian Hernández behind a feature film. He brings to discussion an important theme which is about a young man's view on masculinity and his confrontation and conformity with society in such a role. What it actually means to be a man is the key question presented here. In current times when the dynamic between male and female are taken to different levels and there isn't the imposition of roles since both genres can do pretty much anything, with some restriction in less modern cultures, the discussion is valid and important - and we must also include the countless other genres that came to acceptance in more recent years which goes way beyond sexuality and behavior. However, even with those themes I did not find Mr. Hernández's film an interesting one in dealing with those. It lacked something.

18-year-old Carlos (Dilan Felipe Ramírez Espitia) lives in a poor Colombia community, most precisely in a youth shelter where he spends his days with other youth like him, avoiding to be at home where things are far complicated for him to deal with a sad mother and his older sister who works as a prostitute (or something like it, the movie isn't much clear about it). He's also there to avoid the typical street violence, where boys can only become a man if they get involved in dangerous situations and don't let anyone mess around with you, respect is earned with the power of your fists or your gun. But eventually, during Christmas and New Year's Eve festivities he decides to reach out to his family and becomes acquainted with a local gang where he has to be "baptized" and prove his manhood whether by facing tough guys or sleeping with a prostitute.

But truth be told: Carlos was not made for such environment. He still has a boyish look, very scrawny and with some feminine features (yet somehow he's always seen as a young man, no one challenges his sexuality or call him as effeminate). While on the outside he tries to impose his macho stance as a tough guy, deep down inside he knows he ain't that guy, he's very sensitive, caring for his family, and it gets to a point where the ritual of a sexual awakening is needed so he can be considered a man, he cannot perform it with the chosen girl - if any of his mates ask, she'll have to tell them he was a very good lover. That's some of the mysteries and contradictions revolving around Carlos and the frail masculinity that needs to impose one facade and hide another.

Memorable sequences aren't good enough to make a film good. This series of random vignettes with a character who barely has good moments in his life and faces danger everywhere while trying to define his own existence and maybe find some validation from the outisde and also within himself. There's a bunch of fine interesting moments here and there but overall the movie finds itself wandering with a confused character who barely has a chance and make a resolute decision about what he really wants in life - I know it's that turning point kind of age, we've all been there trying to figure what we want from life and for ourselves but following this particular character and the situations involved it all went dead and lifeless. Little by little I stop caring about him. The presentation of events is lacking, it just keep developing the character and it doesn't make some resolution on anything.

Some reviewers are praising the film and linking Carlos as a queer culture figure. I'm somewhat fine with that definition since he carries some traits and might identify himself as being one, there are many clues that indicate that. But it's a pity we never see him acting forward with it, he's too repressed with himself to the point we can't see him having some male figure of whom he admires the presence or sexuality, or just some glance towards the alpha male types who surround him either to support him or to threat him.

So if we take into consideration this particular setting the film is disappointing since it doesn't show much hope for Carlos in this sad environment, just reinforces stereotypes about anyone straight, gay, male or female, and we as society while evolving in not creating strong definitions and breaking some conventions feel like we're just witnessing a reality that isn't interesting neither has anything we can learn from.

It just didn't appeal to me as it could. It's not a tragic loss neither a waste of time, but it fails to make us connect with everything that it presents. 5/10.

I'm not going to spoil the movie.

Just might spoil something else, i think it's very hypocritical to cast someone from a different gender to play the part of "The male's. For me it would have been fine, if the movie was about female to male transexuals, but casting one, in a movie that is not only a completely different thematic and focuses on the topic of masculinity, it's a huge misfire.

The other topic touch in the movie is prostitution as a problem. A concept lost in many countries and cultures due to poverty. Just take a look at sex tourism around the world, and you'll see how common it is. Believe me, prostitution in Colombia is not an issue to feel sorry for.

Another thing... Drug use!. Really?. It's Colombia!.

So I think that this movie tries too hard to sell you something based on pity...just a a drug addict and prostitute would do.