Goat

Billed as one of September 2025's most anticipated horror releases, HIM arrives with Jordan Peele attached as producer (though not director), and the hype around it was sky-high. The film follows a legendary football star who refuses to let go of his glory days after winning eight consecutive Super Bowl rings. Obsessed with staying at the top, he'll do anything-even eliminate his successor.

Marlon Wayans turns in a surprisingly dark performance as the villain, blending psychological torment with brutal physicality. He's chilling, unpredictable, and easily one of the film's strongest aspects. Tyriq Withers, on the other hand, cements himself as a rising star. His performance is so magnetic and raw that you can't look away whenever he's onscreen.

The movie starts strong-the first act hooks you instantly, and the second act, while slightly uneven, still delivers enough thrills to keep you strapped in like a roller coaster. Unfortunately, when the third act arrives, the wheels completely fall off. Instead of a powerful finale, the story collapses under bizarre choices, awkward dialogue, and a conclusion that feels more like a parody than a payoff.

The "sacrifice" subplot spirals into incoherence, with biblical references clashing against demonic imagery. Goats appear repeatedly, hammering home the idea of Satan posing as God, but the messaging is muddled. Even Marlon Wayans' chilling line about "Football first, family second, God third" gets lost in the chaos of a finale that devolves into circus-level absurdity.

And then there's the infamous line-"If you let me go, I'll suck your dick"-which comes out of nowhere. With no buildup or subtext to support it, it feels jarringly out of place and distracts from everything the film had worked to build up. Instead of intensifying the tension, it derails it entirely.

The character of Miss White (the pale-haired woman with white eyebrows) is a visual oddity throughout the movie, and when she finally gets acknowledged on-screen, it almost feels like the film is poking fun at itself. By that point, though, the damage is done.

What's most disappointing is that the film's setup-fame, glory, sacrifice, and the cost of never letting go-had real potential. The first two acts prove HIM could have been something special. But the third act derails everything, leaving viewers more confused than satisfied.

Final Verdict: HIM is a missed opportunity-worth watching for Marlon Wayans' chilling villain turn and Tyriq Withers' breakout performance, but the botched ending drags it into disappointment. If you're curious, check it out, but this one can definitely wait until streaming.

Greetings again from the darkness. Here is my PSA (Public Service Announcement): This is not a "Football" movie. If you are expecting FRIDAY NIGHT LIGHTS or ANY GIVEN SUNDAY, you will be disappointed. This is a Psychological Horror film (think BLACK SWAN) featuring a couple of football players, and it's produced by Jordan Peele, he of NOPE and GET OUT fame. Writer-director Justin Tipping (KICKS, 2016) and co-writers (co-creators of "Limetown") Zack Aker and Skip Bronkie serve up few X's and O's, and plenty of commentary on fame and the quest for greatness.

Marlon Wayans is best known for his comedy work, and here he delivers his best dramatic performance since REQUIEM FOR A DREAM (2000). He plays Isaiah White, the ultra-successful quarterback of the fictional San Antonio Saviors. Many consider White the G. O. A. T. (Greatest of All-Time). His issue is that he's aging and is likely at the end of his career. On the other end of the spectrum, we have rising star Cameron Cade (Tyriq Withers, I KNOW WHAT YOU DID LAST SUMMER), the young hotshot who many predict will replace White as the GOAT. Cameron's problem is that a surprise causes possible brain damage, knocking him out of the combine and leaving him undrafted.

Cameron's off-kilter agent (Tim Heidecker) arranges for him to train with White for a week. Having worshipped Isaiah White for most of his life, Cameron jumps at the chance. Upon arriving at White's isolated desert compound, he quickly discovers dreams don't always match reality. White greets him warmly, but we all notice (well, Cameron's a bit slow) that things are a bit off. From a sadist trainer (MMA fighter Maurice Greene) to a sardonic doctor (a funny Jim Jeffries), to a creatively made-up and creepy Mrs. White (Julia Fox), the setting for a horrific week is in place.

White pushes Cameron past the point of decency in training, and the doctor delivers some curious blood transfusions. White preaches to Cameron that this unorthodox approach is what's required for peak performance and greatness. The commitment must be to excellence, not some mushy family-first mentality. Some of the drills are violent, while others turn a bit nuts. This is psychological warfare mixed with physical extremes.

There are some cool x-ray effects, and the music from Bobby Krlic (The Haxan Cloak) adds a nice touch; however, this is about envy and power. The first two acts have some eye-opening moments, but things really fly off the rails in the finale. Brutal violence seems too mild as a description, and the commentary on team ownership expectations seems a bit heavy-handed. We all know billionaires are accustomed to getting what they want. This one is worth seeing for Marlon Wayans' performance, but we find ourselves thinking "what if" through much of the film.

Opens in theaters on September 19, 2025.

DO NOT GO INTO THIS THINKING IT IS A JORDAN PEELE MOVIE!!!! The film looked absolutely stunning. The sound was on the same level and the acting was amazing from the entire cast. This movie had so much going for it that the plot kind of disappointed me. It had so many good ideas and yet it did not dig deep enough into any of them to make them stick. I made the mistake of going into this film thinking it was a classic jordan Peele movie. This is not that. Why it has a similar look and pace of many jordan peele movies it just was not on the same level thematically. It tried to run everyway at once and left every path slightly treaded on, but not fully followed.

Start from the positive - this movie is visually beautiful (although quite a few scenes are extremely dark - will be an annoying watch at home), the score is fantastic and the acting is really, really good, especially Marlon Wayans and Tyriq Withers (and Jim Jeffries, an odd but satisfying choice for his role).

However: nothing really happens. The movie I feel tries to be a lot of things but ends up being a beautifully packaged nothingness- kind of devoid of content in my opinion. It is also NOT horror. There are some horror elements to it, but it is by no means scary. And again, nothing really happens until the last 15 minutes of the movie. I expected a lot more after watching the trailer.

For people who have a hard time with flashes and strobes - there's a strobing scene that I'm not sure there's a warning for!

People aren't giving it a fair shake I don't think. It does have its problems, for one "tense" dramatic scenes feel goofy, whether it be bad directing or writing or acting I can't really tell but that does hurt the movie. However; there also is a lot of good to say, The message is on the nose but its also very worth telling, not many movies will have the guts to do it so I will applaud it for that. The cinematography is amazing, the scenes in the desert look amazing. The plot is a little confusing and I can see how people would think that it's "Fake Deep" or whatever but I can't wait to actually dive into all the symbolism when I can watch it again. On the negative side It's also hard to judge what the characters are about or what they want.