The Colors Within is tender, mostly adorable, and quite modest compared to other Anime films I've seen over the past several years; even compared to other coming of age stories tinged with longing and/or lots of vibes, what's striking about Yamada's direction is how she isn't forcing you into feeling a certain way through an abundance of style. The colors that Totsuko sees are fantastical but lightly so, and once it's established as a sort of "quirk" you can sink into the story of these three sorta-outsider-ish teens that form a band and who either don't fit in (for Totsuko because of her color sights and also because she can't stay on a bus without getting carsick) or just don't like school so they drop out.
It's a movie based more around vibes than a really propulsive narrative, like the major conflict comes about that Totsuko and Kimi hang out overnight in the dorm and have (checks notes) lots of snacks and listen to that one song from the Trainspotting soundtrack (which becomes the basis of one of their three songs they work on and perform in the climax). But these are vibes that are vulnerable, or it's about how young people have so much vulnerability and social awkwardness until opening up, and there's no one here who stands out even as a threat or close to an antagonist.
And sometimes that's... fine, especially if it's a squishy sort of coming of age story that (a semi running theme for this director after A Silent Voice) is about the effort in apologizing; in this case there's also the fact that it's about the art that can come out of that emotional register, and that's kind of cool. Some of it is so pleasant feeling that it may be easy to nod off (or it was for me), and yet that isn't a problem for me either because you click back in to it once Totsuko dances and that big performance climax comes and it all fits.
So, even as this isn't quite a romance, it is about the love that comes with friendship in a sincere way, and I appreciate the total lack of irony and sweetness at its core.
