Finding Michael
- 2023
- 1h 40min
NOTE IMDb
5,9/10
2,2 k
MA NOTE
L'équipe de Spencer Matthews part en direction de l'Everest pour tenter de retrouver son frère Michael, disparu il y a 23 ans.L'équipe de Spencer Matthews part en direction de l'Everest pour tenter de retrouver son frère Michael, disparu il y a 23 ans.L'équipe de Spencer Matthews part en direction de l'Everest pour tenter de retrouver son frère Michael, disparu il y a 23 ans.
Avis à la une
This doc film charts Spencer Matthews' quest to find the body of his brother who dies near the peak of Everest. There's a lot that's beautiful - particularly the footage of the mountain and the story of Michael who seems like a wonderful human. What lets it down is Spencer's lack of emotional depth, as he seems nearly throughout to see this as an exciting &wide-eyed adventure, not a deep, personal experience it ought to be. Moreover, watching Nims bounce across the mountain 'body-hunting' just feels in really bad taste, and disrespectful to all that die there. Left a sour taste, if I'm honest.
I have to agree with many of the other statements made here. I was really looking forward to this film and then I spent the whole film thinking, wow...the Matthew's family must have loads of money to have been able to afford to send Michael up Everest...and then, two decades later, have so much money, Spencer could easily travel to Nepal and pay other people to go trekking for his body. The search must have cost a fortune...
And then, in top of that, so much of the gravitas that could have been in the film was ridiculously edited out, making the blurred bodies a huge distraction of silliness. Whomever thought THAT was a good idea should be fired and never allowed to work in film again.
This film could have been so much more, but it ultimately just came across as a little vapid.
And then, in top of that, so much of the gravitas that could have been in the film was ridiculously edited out, making the blurred bodies a huge distraction of silliness. Whomever thought THAT was a good idea should be fired and never allowed to work in film again.
This film could have been so much more, but it ultimately just came across as a little vapid.
So you go on an expedition to find the body of your brother after 20 years based in a picture and you do not even check with the people which have the most knowledge??
The documentary is just bizarre and completely nonsensical poorly written and with things said which are not accurate ......this is clearly just done for visibility ...the 2 star is only because of some sporadic nice pics of the mountains.
Poorly portrait situations and the whole documentary just is has this vibe of fake or strange ...the narration is also very subjective on things which are not .
All in all a completely waste of time and towards the end stopped listening all together.
The documentary is just bizarre and completely nonsensical poorly written and with things said which are not accurate ......this is clearly just done for visibility ...the 2 star is only because of some sporadic nice pics of the mountains.
Poorly portrait situations and the whole documentary just is has this vibe of fake or strange ...the narration is also very subjective on things which are not .
All in all a completely waste of time and towards the end stopped listening all together.
Who are these that dis on this movie citing safety and privilege? Nobody slammed Conrad Anker when he went to get George Mallory off Everest in 1999, the same year Michael was lost. None of these Sherpas in this documentary looked like they were offended, abused or thought the search was unrealistic, unreasonably dangerous or futile.
It used to be accepted as fact that no one could perform a major rescue effort above 8000 meters, it's just not possible for a climber to carry another human. The vast majority of the climbers who have died above 8000 meters on ANY of the 14 mountains are still there. Kudos to the Sherpas!!
I really liked the side by sides of videos taken decades before along with the current shots of the same locations and material.
Bottom line: It's OK to go look for your brother who met his demise, last week or last century, poor or rich.
It used to be accepted as fact that no one could perform a major rescue effort above 8000 meters, it's just not possible for a climber to carry another human. The vast majority of the climbers who have died above 8000 meters on ANY of the 14 mountains are still there. Kudos to the Sherpas!!
I really liked the side by sides of videos taken decades before along with the current shots of the same locations and material.
Bottom line: It's OK to go look for your brother who met his demise, last week or last century, poor or rich.
I wanted to like this.
I didn't realise the guy who is in the film was in Made in Chelsea. That should serve as a warning if you choose to watch it.
Ultimately this misses the mark which is shame as it should be about the loss of a life on Everest and emotional journey in trying to recover the body. Unfortunately the family lack any emotion and therefore no connection with the viewer. The is no detail as to how Michael lost his life which in later research is due to the family taking legal action against the company that took him there. Very little detail on the actual team making the recovery. The only emotional part is in poor taste with a Sherpa's family near the end.
The part which should have been a good news story just came across as a contrived act pulled together in haste to get some plot and emotion back into the film. It just made me angry and disappointed that I was still watching. You can see the discomfort on the face of Spencer at the situation which was one of the only times he shows some real emotion. Surely realising the same thing.
This really shouldn't have been made. If you want to watch an interesting film about recovering a lost climber. Watch Torn.
I didn't realise the guy who is in the film was in Made in Chelsea. That should serve as a warning if you choose to watch it.
Ultimately this misses the mark which is shame as it should be about the loss of a life on Everest and emotional journey in trying to recover the body. Unfortunately the family lack any emotion and therefore no connection with the viewer. The is no detail as to how Michael lost his life which in later research is due to the family taking legal action against the company that took him there. Very little detail on the actual team making the recovery. The only emotional part is in poor taste with a Sherpa's family near the end.
The part which should have been a good news story just came across as a contrived act pulled together in haste to get some plot and emotion back into the film. It just made me angry and disappointed that I was still watching. You can see the discomfort on the face of Spencer at the situation which was one of the only times he shows some real emotion. Surely realising the same thing.
This really shouldn't have been made. If you want to watch an interesting film about recovering a lost climber. Watch Torn.
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
- How long is Finding Michael?Alimenté par Alexa
Détails
- Durée
- 1h 40min(100 min)
- Couleur
- Mixage
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant