C'est du gâteau! USA: Le grand défi

The producers seem to have decided to take what makes the Great British Baking Show series charming and enjoyable - and do the exact opposite whenever possible. Consequently, the show is not entertaining; it's just dumb. The contestants make fools of themselves and the hosts just keep saying stupid things while they watch the contestants try to out-perform each other for who is the most ridiculous - and of course they are all competing for a big payday because it's not really a baking show at all it's a game show pitting needy contestants against one another. This belongs on Nickelodeon - not Netflix.

I love this show if Netflix would do another season Please consider Bring it back I loved this version much more than the original. Jacque and Nicole have a good chemistry. The other two professional bakers (sorry I don't know their names if I move from this screen I will lose this page again) I enjoyed watching them give instructions. So if Netflix would give this another shot it would be great..i don't know why this website requires so many characters to post a viewer review and comments.. This is a little bit much.. Please reconsider the requirement it deters people from posting.. Thank you.

This is definitely a spinoff of the original show which is totally fine by me. The contestants are likeable (which is rare... usually they can be annoying/ fame hungry) and I enjoy seeing their progress each episode. It's fun to learn from the coaches and a blast to watch the losers get a free shopping spree with the help of Wes. And as always the highlight is Nicole- how she makes me laugh! One star off because I don't get enough of the judges on this version. I don't know what masochist comes up with these cake ideas, but I'm here for it. I hope this show (any version of them) never go away!

I really wanted to like this new version of the show. I don't hate it but it's just not the same. First I don't care for shows where bakers are eliminated each epidode so that has stopped me from watching many competition shows.

I was so happy that Nailed it, the original version didn't eliminate anyone and had new bakers each episode.

I don't like watching so many people bake at once. Three at a time was perfect.

I also don't care for Nicole and Jacque being hidden away for half the show. I love those two and they were half the reason I watched but now they are barely around. I really hope they go back to the old format or something similar.

I honestly prefer the insanity of the original series. But this is a nice idea. I like getting to know the baker's more since it is a weekly elimination format. Everyone has such a wonderful personality. Some of the bakers are way better than the others. So some of the casting is definitely to keep the comic relief and not to win. I love the coaches giving tips. Definitely learning stuff to try out not under the gun of a clock. But with the higher time limit the final products aren't always a complete disaster. Still a mess though. So that's a missing element from the original series. I haven't finished, but so far I haven't belly laughed like I do when watching the original. Plus one star for the prize you get for losing. A really fun way to send people off!