Five Nights at Treasure Island

Serious review. This game fails to even impact the viewer and Andrew does not care about your experience. He uses the same gameplay elements as the original franchise only worse, making them as mundane as possible, and basically completely rewrote the original 2014 version's story so he could fit into original ABD lore, even though Matthew was trying to create his own story with this game to begin with, and even failed with that because there is no storytelling. It prioritizes gameplay over narrative - like with most fan games.

The atmosphere is what I have the most gripes with here. It and everything Andrew does afterwards is clearly based on personal trauma. He designs everything based on that. Not actual horror or a sense of what makes horror actually work as a genre to begin with. It feels more like a projection of hatred than a game designed to scare you - and of course, that's no wonder because he spends most of his life as a developer making jokes instead of socializing or understanding people, so no wonder he can't create something that empathizes with your experience.