aheaney-85787
A rejoint le mars 2019
Bienvenue sur nouveau profil
Nos mises à jour sont toujours en cours de développement. Bien que la version précédente de le profil ne soit plus accessible, nous travaillons activement à des améliorations, et certaines fonctionnalités manquantes seront bientôt de retour ! Restez à l'écoute de leur retour. En attendant, l’analyse des évaluations est toujours disponible sur nos applications iOS et Android, qui se trouvent sur la page de profil. Pour consulter la répartition de vos évaluations par année et par genre, veuillez consulter notre nouveau Guide d'aide.
Badges14
Pour savoir comment gagner des badges, rendez-vous sur page d'aide sur les badges.
Évaluations2,6 k
Note de aheaney-85787
Avis4
Note de aheaney-85787
The 2023 Oscar ceremony was... actually good? What? Yeah, I'm shocked too. Especially after last year's disaster (even if the slap did not happen, the 2022 ceremony was awful!).
Jimmy Kimmel surprisingly did a half-decent job at hosting with minimal filler and a pretty solid opener, even if there still was some cringe jokes in the ceremony, especially the cringeworthy "Malala" moment, but there was a lot less bad jokes than usual.
Not a fan of them presenting a trailer for The Little Mermaid in the middle of the ceremony.
As for the winners, most of them were fantastic! I'm so happy with most of the wins. Especially all but one of Everything Everywhere All at Once's wins, Brendan Fraser (The Whale) winning Actor, Top Gun winning Sound, and Avatar: The Way of Water winning VFX, and Naatu Naatu (from RRR) winning Song. These wins were all phenomenal and monumental!
The wins I'm not happy with are Jamie Lee Curtis' winning Supporting Actress over Kerry Condon (The Banshees of Inisherin), Pinocchio winning Animated Feature over Puss in Boots: The Last Wish, Navalny winning Documentary Feature over... any of the other nominees, and All Quiet on the Western Front winning Production Deisgn and Score over Babylon.
The rest of the wins, including Black Panther: Wakanda Forever winning Costume Design, All Quiet on the Western Front winning Cinematography and International Feature, and The Whale winning Makeup/Hairstyling, were all good wins.
Most of the speeches were great too! Ke Huy Quan, Brendan Fraser, and Michelle Yeoh's speeches were especially fantastic and legitimately uplifting!
Honestly, a good ceremony. One of the very few I've seen. The only one I've seen on par with this is the 2020 ceremony where Parasite swept, and that one did have more cringe in the ceremony (especially the Cats reference... yuck).
Jimmy Kimmel surprisingly did a half-decent job at hosting with minimal filler and a pretty solid opener, even if there still was some cringe jokes in the ceremony, especially the cringeworthy "Malala" moment, but there was a lot less bad jokes than usual.
Not a fan of them presenting a trailer for The Little Mermaid in the middle of the ceremony.
As for the winners, most of them were fantastic! I'm so happy with most of the wins. Especially all but one of Everything Everywhere All at Once's wins, Brendan Fraser (The Whale) winning Actor, Top Gun winning Sound, and Avatar: The Way of Water winning VFX, and Naatu Naatu (from RRR) winning Song. These wins were all phenomenal and monumental!
The wins I'm not happy with are Jamie Lee Curtis' winning Supporting Actress over Kerry Condon (The Banshees of Inisherin), Pinocchio winning Animated Feature over Puss in Boots: The Last Wish, Navalny winning Documentary Feature over... any of the other nominees, and All Quiet on the Western Front winning Production Deisgn and Score over Babylon.
The rest of the wins, including Black Panther: Wakanda Forever winning Costume Design, All Quiet on the Western Front winning Cinematography and International Feature, and The Whale winning Makeup/Hairstyling, were all good wins.
Most of the speeches were great too! Ke Huy Quan, Brendan Fraser, and Michelle Yeoh's speeches were especially fantastic and legitimately uplifting!
Honestly, a good ceremony. One of the very few I've seen. The only one I've seen on par with this is the 2020 ceremony where Parasite swept, and that one did have more cringe in the ceremony (especially the Cats reference... yuck).
Honestly, some of the best winners in all of the Oscars history were in this ceremony.
Parasite sweeping was absolutely deserved, and even to this day, monumental. There was no need for any competition in the categories it won. It also should have won Film Editing over Ford v. Ferrari, in my opinion.
Joaquin Phoenix (Joker) winning Actor, as well as the film winning Score, was absolutely deserved too.
Renee Zellweger (Judy) gave a great performance, but it absolutely should have been Scarlett Jóhannsson (Marriage Story).
Brad Pitt (OUATIH) winning Supporting Actor was a great win, and the film absolutely EARNED that Production Design win.
Laura Dern (Marriage Story) was an okay win, but I would have given it to Florence Pugh (Little Women).
Jojo Rabbit (Taika Waititi) winning Adapted Screenplay was very exciting! Granted, any of the nominees (except the Oscar bait that was The Two Popes) could have won, but still.
Toy Story 4 for Animated Feature is kind of a dumb win, although it is a great film, the winner should have easily been Klaus. Hair Love for Animated Short is actually exciting, though!
American Factory for Documentary Feature is completely undeserved (I don't even think it deserved the nomination), it should have been Honeyland or For Sama.
1917's three wins; Cinematography, Sound Mixing, and Visual Effects were absolutely deserved.
Ford v Ferrari and 1917 splitting the Sound categories was a great choice.
Little Women winning Costume Design was somewhat deserved, but only because the other nominees weren't all that great. If Rocketman wasn't completely snubbed for Costume Design, that should have won over Little Women.
Speaking of Rocketman (which was severely snubbed for several other categories), the Song win was deserved.
Bombshell winning makeup was well-deserved too, even if I dislike the movie.
Still, what keeps this from being a truly great ceremony, besides a few undeserved wins, is the comedy. The academy did their damndest to have the presenters make horrendously unfunny, cringeworthy jokes. Wiig and Rudolph trying too hard to be funny and failing miserably was especially egregious, and so was the entire "Cats" segment. It was embarrassing! Otherwise, this was the best Oscar ceremony in the past 10 years.
Parasite sweeping was absolutely deserved, and even to this day, monumental. There was no need for any competition in the categories it won. It also should have won Film Editing over Ford v. Ferrari, in my opinion.
Joaquin Phoenix (Joker) winning Actor, as well as the film winning Score, was absolutely deserved too.
Renee Zellweger (Judy) gave a great performance, but it absolutely should have been Scarlett Jóhannsson (Marriage Story).
Brad Pitt (OUATIH) winning Supporting Actor was a great win, and the film absolutely EARNED that Production Design win.
Laura Dern (Marriage Story) was an okay win, but I would have given it to Florence Pugh (Little Women).
Jojo Rabbit (Taika Waititi) winning Adapted Screenplay was very exciting! Granted, any of the nominees (except the Oscar bait that was The Two Popes) could have won, but still.
Toy Story 4 for Animated Feature is kind of a dumb win, although it is a great film, the winner should have easily been Klaus. Hair Love for Animated Short is actually exciting, though!
American Factory for Documentary Feature is completely undeserved (I don't even think it deserved the nomination), it should have been Honeyland or For Sama.
1917's three wins; Cinematography, Sound Mixing, and Visual Effects were absolutely deserved.
Ford v Ferrari and 1917 splitting the Sound categories was a great choice.
Little Women winning Costume Design was somewhat deserved, but only because the other nominees weren't all that great. If Rocketman wasn't completely snubbed for Costume Design, that should have won over Little Women.
Speaking of Rocketman (which was severely snubbed for several other categories), the Song win was deserved.
Bombshell winning makeup was well-deserved too, even if I dislike the movie.
Still, what keeps this from being a truly great ceremony, besides a few undeserved wins, is the comedy. The academy did their damndest to have the presenters make horrendously unfunny, cringeworthy jokes. Wiig and Rudolph trying too hard to be funny and failing miserably was especially egregious, and so was the entire "Cats" segment. It was embarrassing! Otherwise, this was the best Oscar ceremony in the past 10 years.
Regardless of Will Smith, this was a disaster. Seriously. Even if what happened with Will Smith didn't happen, this was a disaster of a ceremony.
They cut eight categories for time but added in so much filler it ended up much longer than last year's ceremony anyway.
They pretended they'd perform the popular "We Don't Talk About Bruno" only to turn it into a terrible, obnoxious self-celebratory song parody that disrespected the original cast and the song itself.
The "Top 5" moments, which were so obviously rigged and hijacked, should not have happened, and should never be considered again.
Amy Schumer and Regina Hall gave some of the worst comedy I've seen at the Oscars, ever. Some of the most unfunny and uninteresting comedy I've seen, ever even. Wanda Sykes was okay but she wasn't funny either.
Some of the presenters said some things that bothered me, especially that speech before Animated Feature which was incredibly disrespectful.
CODA winning Best Picture was not a terrible thing, honestly; it was a good movie in my opinion, even if I disagree with the win. That said, it was odd to me since it was the first time in well over 70 years that a film with less than five nominations, no Director nom, and no Film Editing nom, won Best Picture. Of all the movies to break that record, why CODA? Seems like an odd choice. The winner, in my opinion, should have been Dune.
All in all, a disaster of a broadcast. I'm most likely not watching next year's ceremony without a fundamental re-evaluation from the people behind the ceremony.
The extra star is for some of the wins being very well-deserved. Here is what I think of each win:
The six Oscars that went to Dune; Score, Sound, Production Design, Cinematography, Film Editing, and Visual Effects, all of which were absolutely deserved. This was a highlight of the night,
As said before, Dune should have won Best Picture.
Ryusuke Hamaguchi (Drive My Car) should have won Director.
Benedict Cumberbatch (The Power of the Dog) should have won Actor.
Kristen Stewart (Spencer) should have won Actress.
Troy Kotsur (CODA) deserved his win for sure.
Ariana DeBose (West Side Story) absolutely earned that win. Also my favorite acceptance speech of the night!
The Worst Person in the World (Eskil Vogt and Joachim Trier) should have won Original Screenplay.
Dune (Jon Spaihts, Denis Villeneuve, and Eric Roth) should have won Adapted Screenplay.
The Mitchells vs the Machines should have won Animated Feature. Also, the presenters gave an extremely disrespectful jab at the medium of animation!
Drive My Car (Japan) EARNED the obvious win for International Feature.
Flee should have won Documentary Feature.
No comment on the three short film categories, I didn't watch any of the nominees.
"No Time to Die" (from No Time to Die) was a very well-deserved win.
The Eyes of Tammy Faye arguably deserved Makeup and Hairstyling, but Dune could have won as well and I would have been happy.
Cruella was an okay win for Costume Design, but Dune also would have been a good win.
Overall, a terrible ceremony; a disastrous presentation, and even the wins were a mixed bag!
They cut eight categories for time but added in so much filler it ended up much longer than last year's ceremony anyway.
They pretended they'd perform the popular "We Don't Talk About Bruno" only to turn it into a terrible, obnoxious self-celebratory song parody that disrespected the original cast and the song itself.
The "Top 5" moments, which were so obviously rigged and hijacked, should not have happened, and should never be considered again.
Amy Schumer and Regina Hall gave some of the worst comedy I've seen at the Oscars, ever. Some of the most unfunny and uninteresting comedy I've seen, ever even. Wanda Sykes was okay but she wasn't funny either.
Some of the presenters said some things that bothered me, especially that speech before Animated Feature which was incredibly disrespectful.
CODA winning Best Picture was not a terrible thing, honestly; it was a good movie in my opinion, even if I disagree with the win. That said, it was odd to me since it was the first time in well over 70 years that a film with less than five nominations, no Director nom, and no Film Editing nom, won Best Picture. Of all the movies to break that record, why CODA? Seems like an odd choice. The winner, in my opinion, should have been Dune.
All in all, a disaster of a broadcast. I'm most likely not watching next year's ceremony without a fundamental re-evaluation from the people behind the ceremony.
The extra star is for some of the wins being very well-deserved. Here is what I think of each win:
The six Oscars that went to Dune; Score, Sound, Production Design, Cinematography, Film Editing, and Visual Effects, all of which were absolutely deserved. This was a highlight of the night,
As said before, Dune should have won Best Picture.
Ryusuke Hamaguchi (Drive My Car) should have won Director.
Benedict Cumberbatch (The Power of the Dog) should have won Actor.
Kristen Stewart (Spencer) should have won Actress.
Troy Kotsur (CODA) deserved his win for sure.
Ariana DeBose (West Side Story) absolutely earned that win. Also my favorite acceptance speech of the night!
The Worst Person in the World (Eskil Vogt and Joachim Trier) should have won Original Screenplay.
Dune (Jon Spaihts, Denis Villeneuve, and Eric Roth) should have won Adapted Screenplay.
The Mitchells vs the Machines should have won Animated Feature. Also, the presenters gave an extremely disrespectful jab at the medium of animation!
Drive My Car (Japan) EARNED the obvious win for International Feature.
Flee should have won Documentary Feature.
No comment on the three short film categories, I didn't watch any of the nominees.
"No Time to Die" (from No Time to Die) was a very well-deserved win.
The Eyes of Tammy Faye arguably deserved Makeup and Hairstyling, but Dune could have won as well and I would have been happy.
Cruella was an okay win for Costume Design, but Dune also would have been a good win.
Overall, a terrible ceremony; a disastrous presentation, and even the wins were a mixed bag!