The Long Call

I was so excited to hear that this show was based on novel by Ann Cleeve, the author of Vera and Shetland, two of my top10 British detective stories! The second a Vera episode is released, I watch it and about a week later I watched it again. So i was looking forward to this show.

Two main components of a good detective story is that, first, the protagonist is quirky, or tormented, or an alcoholic, crazy, goofy, and/or fish a out of water and second, they are extremely passionate about being a detective, by finding the killer, and justice for the victims. Everything else in their lives is secondary. (Ex Grantchester, Vera, Murder in paradise, Sherlock Holmes, Shetland, etc.).

You won't find either of these components at work here. Half of the 20th century protagonist are gay so that's not "quirky" anymore. And although this actor is eye candy, he looks super bored with his work. In one scene, he looks at the murder board and scratches his chin and ........that's it. That would never fly in a Vera episode. My favorite Vera scenes are when she looks at the murder board, turns around and yells at everybody to get to work and find the answer.

The cult angle was interesting, but many mystery murders find that the murder is related to their past and this makes them even more crazy about finding the answer, but once again I just didn't feel passion with this actor.....and if the protagonist is not passionate about what he does, how can u expect us, the viewer, to be.

If u have nothing is to watch, catch this, the scenery is OK. It seemed like everyone lived in a house with huge windows overlooking the sea??...but you would be better served watching another Vera episode.

Wonderful acting and beautiful scenery. Took a while to get into the story but really enjoyed it.

Anita Dobson is tremendous especially in the closing scenes.

I really, really tried to like this more but the boredom of the direction and script defeated me. The stationary camera fails to keep our eyes interested, despite some of the gorgeous scenery. Then there's a stony Ben Aldridge who fails to capture our empathy.

The makers of the show must've known there were problems: the music is far too intrusive and just as tedious as the dreary dialog. Music this gratuitous is usually used to compensate for an unremarkable script or tepid direction, both of which this series possesses.

There are moments of real plot movement here but they are far too rare. You become involved, then are brought back down by some dull religious or backstory dialog that prompts you to fast forward through the dreary talk.

The Long Call is adapted from the first novel of a new series by Ann Cleeves (Shetland & Vera) so comes from a fine pedigree.

The show follows a gay male detective, (amazingly for the first time on UK TV) Matthew Venn as he returns to a strict evangelical community in Devon to attend his father's funeral before investigating a murder.

It was stylish but the direction was poor technically and trying too hard to be edgy it ended up being distracting. The scene in the first episode between Neil Morrissey and Pearl Mackie was bizzarely shot, you'd think they'd let a passerby have a go behind the camera...

Main problem though was that the lead actor Ben Aldridge was too ineffectual and bland, he spent most of his time standing still and thinking aloud with his hands in his designer trouser pockets. The story would have been better told in fewer episodes or over 90 minutes. The script was ponderous.

New detective shows do need time to bed in - and I do hope they get a second series to try and nail it. The ending was good and satisfying but sadly this series was very much style over substance and too slow. I can't blame the many viewers that abandoned ship.

This is a new crime drama from the reigning queen, Ann Cleeves who has given us "Vera" and "Shetland", Vera is set in Northumberlandshire, Shetland on the islands and now The Long Call (TLC) on the north coast of Devonshire.

The cast for season one includes Ben Aldridge, Juliette Stevenson, Martin Shaw, Neil Morrissey, Alan Williams and many more, they are major actors and expect major parts and the acting is very good. Kudos to the casting director. I hope BAFTA looks at this series for awards.

It is a slow burn, it's not one solved case per episode but one case over four episodes. It's tough to maintain viewer interest and glad they released it over four nights. The creator and producers should look at whether one story over two episodes or one 90 minute episode works best for future seasons.

DI Matthew Venn is not DCI Vera Stanhope (Vera) or DI Jimmy Perez (Shetland), he's younger and university educated and works collaboratively with his team. Venn is new and some have commented that he needs to be stronger, but he was raised in a religious community where members listen a lot as his mother pointed out. DCI Stanhope and DI Perez started out rocky and developed their TV personas.

Some of the younger actors are trying to do a regional or other accent and it's not working, it comes across mumbly and not clear. I was hoping for subtitles to understand some of the dialogue. The Incident Room at the police station is too big, the staff get lost and the sound isn't consistent. In general Ben Aldridge is the easiest to understand.

The other is that British crime dramas get exported to other countries and the British are great for acronyms and they don't realize that the whole world doesn't understand their acronyms. Speaking and understanding English doesn't mean understanding all the police acronyms. Season 6, Episode 1 of the great series "Line of Duty" was full of so many Met Police acronyms that Esquire Magazine (US) put out a translation page. At one point DI Venn tells his staff to check with the FLO in the child death, FLO is a Family Liaison Officer, a police officer assigned to a family.

Matthew's morning swims I saw as an homage to the Italian series "Montalbano", where police Commissioner Salvo Montalbano is often seen swimming each morning in the Mediterranean near his home.

These are minor problems that can be resolved. I hope season 2 is more focused on the crimes and less on the families, Here's hoping it's renewed for many more seasons.