Forbidden Fruit

Mary Maddock is a poor seamstress who works for the wealthy Mrs. Mallory. Mr. Mallory attempts to make a business deal with Nelson Rogers. To entice the young man, Mrs. Mallory invites him to a dinner party, promising him that his partner will be the prettiest girl in town. But when his partner us unable to attend, Mrs. Mallory enlists Mary in the role. Mrs. Mallory and her servants transform Mary into a desirable woman. Rogers falls for her, unaware that Mary is married to a louse. Mary's husband conspires with Giuseppe, the Mallory's butler, to steal some jewels from the Mallory home. During the theft, Mary's husband discovers Mary sleeping at the Mallory's home and assumes she is selling herself. Can Mary extricate herself from this mess?

This is an odd film. I'm sure DeMille was going for melodrama (the title cards are rife with morality). There are some references to Adam and Eve ("forbidden fruit" ... get it? Get it?), but also scenes with Cinderella fantasies (which were pretty bad). But several scenes are comic and the movie borders on farce. Theodore Roberts, as Mr. Mallory, plays his usual cigar-chomping character, and provides some of the comic relief. Rogers makes a pleasant leading man, although his outfit in the Cinderella scenes is way too much.

Ayres is quite beautiful, even before she is "transformed." In what might be an "in" joke, one scene involves the Mallorys, along with Mary and Rogers, watching a play in a theater. The actors onstage are Conrad Nagel and Margaret Loomis, and the play is entitled "Forbidden Fruit."