Churchill in guerra

This is a Netflix documentary so we get that treatment; talking heads and experts and, more unpalatable to me, staged re-enactments with actors on 'probable' scenes. It's high budget cable television.

The prewar portion may be the most informative in how it shapes the famous wartime Winston. Bullish, spectacular escape fueled by drive to tell the story about it in his South African adventure. Doggedly independent as he switches parties.

The wartime Churchill of valiant speeches, Dunkirk, and the Blitz, is well covered in inumerable films and TV. He really was the man of the hour, a bullish man insisting on a story of resistance against all odds. Fancied himself a strategist but bangled Gallipolli, Sicily was a mistake, and storytelling was really his strong suit.

We also do see several of his faults. His prewar defence of empire at all costs. Even in passing, his disastrous indifference to Bengal and the famine. And his ensuing sidelining, post Casablanca, as bigger men on the room took charge of the war.

It is very much a cinematic life he lived. Adept at both re-invention and stubborn independence. And of course a natural storyteller. He could have been a great filmmaker, and I can imagine him a figure like Welles or Hitchcock around set (and vice versa, Welles and Hitchcock may have been great wartime prime mnisters).

It was a matter of the world outside aligning with the man's story of who he views himself to be, to create the sense of destiny, and that was true of both FDR and Hitler.

I'm interested in the real footage of the War and hearing the details of how Churchill lead Britain. I can do totally without the talking heads interrupting and giving completely pointless opinions, especially Boris Johnson and George W. Bush. Who thought that was a good idea?

Neither of those belong in any piece about Churchill.

I could do without any extras making statements about the obvious, it's a distraction and annoying. They should have had one narrator, seldom seen and it would have been much more tolerable. There are better documentaries but I would have found this one interesting if they'd left off the bad acting bits.

"In the war time truth is so precious that she should always be attended by a bodyguard of lies" "In war, resolution. In defeat, defiance. In victory, magnanimity. In peace, Goodwill." "What was gunpowder, trivial. What was the electricity, meaningless. This atomic bomb is the second coming in wrath!"

• Churchill

Before diving into my review of the docuseries Churchill at War, I would like to summarize the key points and highlight a few notable incidents.

Winston Churchill was famous for crossing the floor, changing parties, and taking bold stances. His leadership during World War II was instrumental in stopping Adolf Hitler and Nazi Germany. Churchill's military career was marked by adventures in Cuba, India, Sudan, and South Africa, where he was captured by enemy forces during the Second Boer War.

Churchill's role in World War II was pivotal, particularly during the Greek tragedy, where the British Royal Navy attacked and sank the French Navy. The Eagle Day Attacks on London, also known as the Blitz, began on September 15, 1940, with 57 consecutive nights of bombing, resulting in 20,000 deaths. Churchill, instead of taking shelter, stayed on the roof and watched the destruction.

Churchill's relationship with America was complex, with the country initially staying neutral but eventually providing support through the Lend-Lease Act. Churchill said that America's terms were "flaying them to the bone," but he was able to convince President Franklin D. Roosevelt's advisor, Harry Hopkins, to provide help. The Tom Brook Falls earned Churchill the sympathy he had wanted from FDR.

Roosevelt decided to take the North African route, suggested by Churchill, instead of the direct route to defeat Germany. It is said that to defeat Germany, Britain gave time, America gave money, and Russia gave blood. Even before Albert Einstein envisioned a nuclear bomb, Churchill wrote articles about how a single bomb could devastate an entire city.

Montgomery, a teetotaler, once told Churchill, "I do not smoke and I do not drink, and I'm 100% fit." Churchill, not to be outdone, replied, "I both smoke and drink, and I'm 200% fit!!!"

In 1944, Churchill traveled to Russia to meet with Stalin without any American counterparts. This meeting resulted in the creation of the "naughty document," a verbal agreement between Stalin and Churchill on who would get what after the war. This agreement would have significant implications for post-war Europe.

Churchill also proposed Operation Unthinkable, a plan to use the defeated German army to fight the Russians and stop them from entering Eastern Europe. This plan was never implemented, but it highlights the complex and often contradictory nature of Churchill's leadership during World War II.

Churchill's legacy is also marked by controversy, particularly regarding the Bengal famine. Britain refused to send wheat or rice to India, and Churchill could have prevented the famine by redistributing surplus food from elsewhere. Instead, he stopped the shipment of wheat from Canada to India, prioritizing the interests of those fighting to protect the empire. This decision led to over 3 million deaths in Bengal.

Despite these controversies, Churchill remains a complex and fascinating figure in history. His leadership during World War II, his powerful oratory skills, and his ability to inspire and motivate others continue to be studied and admired by historians and scholars today.

The docuseries Churchill at War is a gripping and thought-provoking portrayal of Winston Churchill's leadership during World War II. It masterfully weaves together archival footage, interviews and dramatized scenes to create an immersive experience.

The series sheds light on Churchill's unwavering resolve, his mastery of language and his unshakeable conviction in the face of overwhelming adversity. It is fascinating to see how he rallied the British people during the darkest days of the war, how his leadership played a crucial role in shaping the course of the conflict...

What struck me most was the nuanced portrayal of Churchill's complexities in this series. While it commendably explores his flaws, controversies, his mistakes - including the Bengal famine and complicated relationships with other world leaders - it surprisingly omits his contradictory stance on India's independence. Despite being a strong advocate for freedom and democracy, Churchill's imperialist upbringing and biased views toward Indian culture and people are not fully examined. Specifically, his perceived view of India as a backward and primitive country is not adequately highlighted, leaving a gap in the narrative.

The production quality of the docuseries is exceptional with crisp and clear visuals that bring the archival footage to life. The interviews featured in the series provide valuable insights from historians and scholars adding depth and context to the narrative. The dramatized scenes are also well-executed, helping to recreate the tension and drama of Churchill's wartime leadership. It is a compelling and informative docuseries that offers a fresh perspective on one of history's most iconic leaders. Definitely a worth watching. Watch Churchill at War, available on Netflix.

I enjoyed with miniseries about the war years of Mr. Churchill, with the first episode about him actually fighting in the Boer War and in WWI and also orchestrating the Gallipoli disaster. Maybe that could have been expanded, but the focus of this documentary was WWII.

The remaining episodes tell in details the rise of Churchill during the darkest hours, his struggle to keep Britain fighting and his attempt to lure President Roosevelt in the fight.

When the US declared war in 1941, Britain and Churchill rejoiced only to realise that they were going to play second fiddle to the rising superpowers of the Soviet Union and US.

The last episode wraps things nicely showing how Churchill did not go gently when he - surprisingly to me - lost the elections in 1945 and how eventually he made a come back and still stands as one of the greatest protagonists of the XX century, no matter what some want you to believe and despite all his defects and mistakes - after all he was human.

Churchill at War is a near perfect documentary about the Winston Churchill and the challenges of his time. Told through video news footage, archives, interviews, and theatrical recreations, this four part series is very well done. There is much we know about Churchill as the man who rose to become the arch-nemesis of Adolf Hitler in World War II and the face of Great Britain. I find many documentaries to be way too long and filled with unnecessary information. Even at four parts that is not the case here. This is as engaging as any motion picture. The actor who plays Churchill does not really look like him but the sound is uncanny.