Charles MacArthur(1895-1956)
- Writer
- Director
- Producer
"Life is a banquet, and most poor suckers out there are starving!" When
Patrick Dennis's fictional Auntie Mame uttered this pithy observation,
she could have been speaking of Charles MacArthur. Charlie never shied
away from the feast, and he certainly never went hungry. Arriving in
November 1895 in Scranton, Pennsylvania, Charlie was the second
youngest of seven children born to stern evangelist William Telfer
MacArthur and Georgiana Welsted MacArthur. His early life was dominated
by his father's ministry, leading the family to travel cross country
wherever the elder MacArthur's calling took them. Charlie spent much of
his time during those years hiding in the bathroom -- the only place
offering even a modicum of privacy for a member of such a large family
-- reading virtually anything he could get his hands on. He developed a
passion for the written word that would last him to his dying day.
Resisting Reverend MacArthur's insistent urging that his son follow him
into the ministry, young Charlie left the family's rural New York home
soon after finishing high school. Heading off to the Midwest, he took a
reporter's job at The Oak Leaves, a suburban Chicago newspaper owned by
two of his older brothers and run by his older sister. His first
professional taste of crafting something for others to read whetted his
appetite for even more. Intently determined to pursue a calling which
for him was as strong as the calling his father had heard, Charlie went
to the City News Bureau of Chicago as the first step in his journey
toward life as a journalist. Though only 19, the irreverent sense of
humor and dislike for mindless authoritarianism for which he would
later be so well known was already quite evident in the application he
filled out for the job. In the space entitled "Tell us in exactly
seventy-five words why you wish to become a reporter," Charlie wrote:
"I want to become a reporter more because I like the work than for any
other reason. I feel that even if I should branch off in another
profession, the experience obtained in getting up on your toes after
news would be valuable. These are my reasons. More words would be
useless." The excitement of working in brash and brawling pre-1920s
Chicago didn't quite satisfy Charlie's hunger for something more,
however, and he soon hooked up with General "Black Jack" Pershing,
galloping off to Mexico to join in the hunt for the infamous Pancho
Villa. When World War I broke out, Charlie joined the Army's 149th
Field Artillery, part of the Rainbow Division. During his time in
France, he and his battery mate shot down a German plane with nothing
more than a machine gun. Later in the war, Charlie sustained a mild
shrapnel wound. In 1919 he penned his only book, A Bug's Eye View of
the War (later republished in 1929 by Harper Collins as War Bugs) about
his unit's adventures and misadventures during some of the most brutal
and bloodiest fighting in history. Returning to Chicago just in time
for Prohibition, the Roaring 20s, and Al Capone, Charlie became one of
Chicago's most well-known and widely read reporters. He authored some
of the most enduring pieces ever printed in the pages of the Chicago
Tribune and Daily News. His style was inventive, charming, and witty.
Readers couldn't get enough. Once, when writing about a dentist accused
of sexually molesting his female patients, Charlie chose the headline
"Dentist Fills Wrong Cavity". He also wrote several short stories, two
of which, "Hang It All" (1921) and "Rope" (1923), were published in
H.L. Mencken's The Smart Set magazine. His star continued to rise, and
he eventually headed off to the greener pastures of New York City. Once
settled in the Big Apple, he began to shift his efforts toward
playwrighting. His first true Broadway success was in 1926 with the
play "Lulu Belle", written in collaboration with
Edward Sheldon. It would later be
remade into a 1948 movie starring
Dorothy Lamour and
George Montgomery. His next
play, "Salvation", written in collaboration with
Sidney Howard, enjoyed a moderate
Broadway run. During the summer of 1927, Charlie and long-time friend
and collaborator, Ben Hecht, rented
the premises of the Nyack Girl's Academy as a haven from which they
could create their own special brand of playwrighting.
Helen Hayes (the future Mrs. Charles
MacArthur) would tell friends of times when she or Rose Hecht would
visit to bring in food or other supplies for their men, and the
building would be positively filled with shouts of laughter and
merriment. The result of this seclusion was the 1928 Broadway debut of
"The Front Page". The phenomenal stage success of "The Front Page"
prompted Charlie to head to Hollywood and screenplay work. Having
already developed such works as
The Girl Said No (1930),
Billy the Kid (1930) and
The Unholy Garden (1931), he
hit the jackpot in 1931, first with the movie version of
The Front Page (1931) (again
collaborating with Ben Hecht), which
won Academy Award nominations for Best Picture, Best Director
(Lewis Milestone), and Best Actor
(Adolphe Menjou), and then, with the
release of
The Sin of Madelon Claudet (1931),
which netted a 1932 Best Actress Oscar for its star,
Helen Hayes. The film also won
awards at that year's Venice Film Festival for both its leading lady
and its director, Edgar Selwyn. Charlie's
screenplay for
Rasputin and the Empress (1932),
the only movie ever to feature siblings
John Barrymore,
Ethel Barrymore and
Lionel Barrymore together in the same
film, gained him his own first Academy Award nomination (in 1934, for
Best Original Story). Even though their efforts had turned mostly to
filmmaking by this point, it was also during this period that Hecht and
MacArthur produced their second smash theatrical effort, "Twentieth
Century", which debuted on Broadway in December 1932, and was later
made into the well-received 1934 movie starring
John Barrymore and
Carole Lombard. Unhappy with the
machinations of Hollywood's fledgling film industry, however, MacArthur
and Hecht decided to set up their own shop in Astoria, New York,
producing, writing, directing, and even making uncredited onscreen
appearances in a series of films such as
The Scoundrel (1935) (poking fun at
themselves by playing downtrodden patrons of a charity flop house) and
Crime Without Passion (1934)
(in which they portrayed -- what else? -- newspaper reporters). Their
work earned much critical acclaim, culminating in the 1936 Best Writing
(Original Story) Academy Award for
The Scoundrel (1935). Their 1939
collaboration to turn Rudyard Kipling's
epic poem into the movie
Gunga Din (1939), starring
Cary Grant,
Victor McLaglen and
Douglas Fairbanks Jr., was
recognized in 1999 by the National Film Registry, and their adaptation
of Emily Brontë's
Wuthering Heights (1939)
garnered the two yet another Academy Award Best Writing (Screenplay)
nomination in 1940. That year also saw the remake of "The Front Page"
into the popular movie,
His Girl Friday (1940), starring
Rosalind Russell and
Cary Grant. The advent of World War II
prompted Charlie to interrupt his writing career and sign on in his
country's service once again. He began his second stint of service
years as a Major in the Chemical Warfare Service, returning home at the
war's conclusion a Lt. Colonel. By now, the father of two children,
Mary and James MacArthur, and
husband to "The First Lady of the American Theatre", Charlie had
amassed a considerable amount of fame in his own right, yet was still
looking for something different. Resuming his theatrical and film work,
he also took on the duties of editing and publishing the foundering
Theatre World magazine, but left after little more than a year,
dissatisfied with the politics and constraints of working in a
corporate atmosphere. The tragic loss of his 19-year-old daughter to
polio in 1949 was a blow from which Charlie would never quite recover.
Though he continued to work on screenplays and movie scripts up until
his death in 1956, some of which enjoyed a modicum of success, he would
never again completely recapture the freewheeling enthusiasm of his
earlier days. When his son grew old enough to begin considering a
career of his own, his father advised, "Do anything you like, son, but
never become a playwright. It's a death worse than fate!" Charles
MacArthur left behind a lasting imprint upon both those who knew him
personally and those who knew him only through his published works.
Supremely disdainful of anything even remotely false or affected,
Charlie nevertheless did follow the path his father wished him to take,
albeit in his own inimical fashion. His words carried a truth and
sincerity few writers have been able to achieve. His unique mix of
subtle irony, gentle sarcasm, and poignant pathos reached as deeply
into his audience at least as well as any fiery sermon from a pulpit
ever could. As Ben Hecht said in the
eulogy he delivered at his friend's memorial service (and later
expanded upon in his 1957 book, "Charlie: The Improbable Life and Times
of Charles MacArthur"), "Charlie was more than a man of talent. He was
himself a great piece of writing. His gaiety, wildness and kindness,
his love for his bride Helen, and his two children, and for his clan of
brothers and sisters -- his wit and his adventures will live a long,
long while".