The Italian

It's a classic story, all but ageless - a tale that surely could have played out countless times in real life. It's also rather simple overall, so 'The Italian' is certainly an instance in which the feature lives or dies on details and presentation. Though perhaps not wholly riveting, it's solidly entertaining, with turns of light comedy and drama of varying severity to keep us invested. Scenes as written are modestly compelling, and all do well to ably realize them with vivid imagery. Director Reginald Barker captures some fine shots, and I appreciate the care put into aspects like filming locations, set design and decoration, hair, makeup, and costume design. Above all, the cast is swell, capably defying the limits of the silent era with strong facial expressions and exaggerated body language. Star George Beban, above all, is great as protagonist Beppo, a hopeless romantic struggling through the trials of a pitiless and at times corrupt city. Beban offers wonderful nuance and physicality, depicting every shifting emotion of the beleaguered immigrant. And his co-stars are equally up to the task, including not least of all Clara Williams as Beppo's wife Annette.

The movie perhaps feels marginally disjointed on account of its structure - an unusual abundance of intertitles, and multiple jumps in time somewhat uncharacteristic of the era. On a more esoteric level, I just don't think 'The Italian' is perfectly successful in telling its story - it's not wholly engaging. While the plot takes a direction I wouldn't have anticipated, the final minutes left me a bit wanting, as there's no particular resolution to the story. In fairness, there's nothing wrong with that: life is messy, fictional lives can be messy, and the somewhat open-ended nature of the conclusion is a tack I generally rather appreciate in cinema - and one that I think is uncommon in the silent era. Still, in this instance, with this specific tale, I'm unsure that the uncertainty looming over the ending serves its best interests.

I've seen many silent films that I think hold up as essential cinematic experiences, and fewer that didn't quite capture my imagination. In my opinion 'The Italian' lands somewhere in the upper middle between those two ends of the spectrum. What flaws I perceive here are purely subjective, true, and mostly come down to being not fully satisfying as a viewer. Still, it's broadly well made and written, with able performances as an anchor. I wouldn't necessarily say this is a movie to go out of your way to see, but it's suitably enjoyable, and well worth your time if you have the opportunity to watch it.

Well made silent melodrama, of some historic import.

The acting is generally quite good and understated for the time, the cinematography has some nice lighting effects, and moving shots (and one amazing close up, where the camera shakes with a character's anger).

On the other hand, the melodramatic story feels blandly predictable, along with having a giant plot hole at its center, and some other annoying, easily avoided contradictions and logic gaps.

Certainly this story -- a struggling Italian immigrant and his bride in the slums of New York, coming to America to fulfill their dreams, but finding disillusionment and despair -- must have resonated with a lot of people at the time. I just wish the story had the subtlety of the acting and images.

A good, solid, important early film.

To get a glimpse of the hardships that faced immigrants 100 years ago in the United States, June 1915's "The Italian" will give you one example of an aspiring and hardworking new arrival in New York City's Lower East Side. The movie follows a shoeshiner (played by actor George Beban) from Italy who soon is impoverished after leaving a gondolier job in his native country. Tragedy strikes when his sick infant son needs an expensive special milk to survive.

Thomas Ince produced this heart-tugging story, which he also co-wrote. Director Reginald Baker, whose studio was based on the West Coast, elected to shoot in the tenement quarter of San Francisco in lieu of the story's Manhattan Lower East Side setting. Baker is credited with giving "The Italian" a unique perspective for his audience by posting his camera in varying positions, combining wide, medium and tight shots (unusual for the time) which highlights the characters' progression throughout their ordeals. Embarking on this cinematic tact, Baker illustrates the actors' psychological reasoning for their actions rather than simply unfolding a straight line plot.

"The Italian" clearly was calling for social reform from the poverty so many deligent working immigrants were facing while attempting to making a living in their new country. The predatory politicians and criminals portrayed in the film make life impossible for those new arrivals. Actor Beban's portrayal of an Italian immigrant shows, as one critic wrote, "America is not a promised land paved with gold but a Darwinian jungle, where dreams meet dead ends."

This was Beban's film debut after spending years on vaudeville and in live theater. Typecast as Italian and French throughout his acting career, Beban was of Croatian/Irish mix. He also directed and wrote for film, but retired in the late 1920's upon his wife's death. He died at 54 in 1928 after being thrown off his horse vacationing at a California dude ranch.

This short American silent feature is a knockout. Made in 1915, it was lost for several decades. It is the story of an Italian immigrant and his wife who see in the United States a land of opportunity and happiness. Everything, instead, works against them. The film makes a very strong impression and has credible performances. The location shooting in the ghettos of the time give it a distinctly neo-realist feeling. It is said that Francis Ford Coppola watched it closely before shooting the Little Italy sequences of "The Godfather, Part II"

This is a very early feature length film made in 1914 with a very good reputation. Most people think of 1915's Birth of a Nation as the first real feature film, but this one predates it. It stars George Beban as Beppo, "The Italian", a man who comes from Italy to America to earn enough money so that he can win the hand of his beloved Annette. Beppo, initially a vigorous and joyful soul, eventually becomes a beaten man due to a series of tragedies he endures in America. Beppo becomes so despondent from tragedy that at one point he even considers murdering an innocent as revenge for the loss of one of his own loved ones. There are several silent films that still exist that talk about the immigrant experience in America, but this one is unique because it shows the immigrant's life in the Old World, along with the natural beauty of the place compared to early twentieth century New York City and its barren appearance.

The Flicker Alley restoration is highly recommended not only for the high quality of the transfer but for its insightful commentary. I normally don't like to plug specific products, but this one is very much worth your time.