Andy Hardy, Cowboy

Though this Hardy Family film is listed as a comedy, it includes a healthy dose of tears, which may be why it gets lesser marks than others in the series. Still, Andy Hardy (Mickey Rooney) brings his brand of teenage silliness to the proceedings.

The family goes out west to visit friends who own a working ranch. They are having problems that Judge Hardy (Lewis Stone) might be able to help with. Daughter Marian (Cecilia Parker) is smitten with a ranch hand, and Andy reluctantly pals around with a spunky cowgirl named Jake, played by Virginia Weidler (who appears in two other films with Rooney).

The show business adage says you should never work with children or animals, but Rooney does both here and, though Virginia is a real scene-stealer, he holds his own. A better film that shows Rooney's western talents is "Girl Crazy" (1943).

Out West with the Hardys (1938)

** 1/2 (out of 4)

Fine entry in the MGM series has Judge Hardy (Lewis Stone) taking the family to a ranch in Arizona where he hopes to help his old friends who have gotten into some trouble with their land and water. Out on the ranch Marian (Cecilia Parker) falls for yet another guy while Andy (Mickey Rooney) must learn the hard way that he's got a lot of learning to do before he can call himself a man. While this fifth entry is certainly a step down from the past couple entries this is still a pretty entertaining film thanks in large part to the terrific cast who have no trouble getting into their parts. Considering this was the third film in the series within 1938 alone you can understand how the product felt somewhat rushed. The movie has a fairly good story overall but at the same time everything seemed a tad bit too rushed and there isn't nearly as many funny moments as some of the earlier entries. I think the best stuff in the movie happen between Andy and the 8-year-old Jake (Virginia Weidler) who starts to have a crush on him. There's a lot of heart between the two as they start off not liking one another but quickly she ends up teaching Andy quite a few things. As you'd expect there's a lot more drama between Judge and Andy as the older, wiser dad must teach his son several lessons about life. As usual Stone and Rooney are downright terrific in their roles so they have no problem pulling off the father-son relationship. Hearing the two of them talk together comes off so real that I could listen to them speak for hours at a time. The supporting cast offers up some strong work with Parker, Ann Rutherford and Fay Holden fitting back into their roles with no trouble. Sara Haden is back as Aunt Milly after being MIA in the previous two films. Weidler is very charming in her role but I later learned she walked away from showbiz at the age of 17 and sadly ended up dying at the age of 42 from a heart attack. While there's no question this is a step down from some of the previous films, OUT WEST WITH THE HARDYS at least has the terrific cast and they make this worth sitting through.

OUT WEST WITH THE HARDYS (Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, 1938), marks the fifth entry to the "Judge Hardy's Family/Andy Hardy" series, following its previous installments of A FAMILY AFFAIR (1937), YOU'RE ONLY YOUNG ONCE (1937), JUDGE HARDY'S CHILDREN (1938) and the immensely popular, LOVE FINDS ANDY HARDY (1938). Featuring the standard cast of Lewis Stone (Judge James K. Hardy), Mickey Rooney (Andrew Hardy), Cecilia Parker (Marian Hardy), Fay Holden (Emily Hardy), this edition also welcomes back Sara Haden as the family's Aunt Milly Forrest, the role recast in two previous installments by Betty Ross Clark. As in many a film series, there would be a matter of time before its title characters would venture out west, and this is it, though not in a sense of cowboys, horses and bar room brawls found in many a western, but another vacation for the family where the father helps with another family's situations.

The story starts off briefly in the courtroom before Judge Hardy (Lewis Stone) receives a telegram from his friend's wife out west who is in need of financial assistance. Later, in the Hardy household, the family is gathered together or dinner before the lights suddenly go out. Son Andy (Mickey Rooney) solves the darkness problem by placing a penny in the fuse box. Situations ensue as Mother Hardy (Fay Holden), upset over her personal problems, feels she needs a rest. To assist his wife, Hardy packs up the family for rest and relaxation out west so Hardy can assist Dora and Bill Northcole's (Nana Bryant and Ralph Morgan) with their troubles. While in Medville, Arizona, Hardy attempts in helping the Northcole's settle their water rights problem with H. R. Bruxton (Thurston Hall), or else they will face eviction from their ranch. Then there's daughter, Marian, who recently had broken up with her boyfriend, Dennis Hunt (Don Castle) back home, becoming romantically involved with Ray Holt (Gordon Jones), a foreman rancher and widower father of an eight-year-old daughter, Jake (Virginia Weidler). Now in love with Ray and contemplating marriage, Marian decides to try out country living by awaking at 5 a.m., and making long preparations of the day starting with breakfast. Jake, however, disapproves of Marian with possibilities of her becoming her new mother, while she has taken a liking to her younger brother, Andy, who rather become involved with a girl closer to his own age. Others in the cast consist of Tom Neal (Aldrich Brown); Anthony Allan (Cliff Thomas); and Gordon Douglas (Mr. Carter). Series regulars Ann Rutherford (Polly Benedict, Andy's girlfriend) and Erville Alderson (Dave, the courtroom bailiff) can be seen in smaller roles.

Though not as successful nor memorable as LOVE FINDS ANDY HARDY, OUT WEST WITH THE HARDYS is standard comedy-drama. Though there are some moments of humor involving Andy trying life as a cowboy, there's also some serious moments involving Andy's accident while riding Jake's Calico horse, resulting to a broken leg, bringing tearful moments involving little Jake. Rooney and Weidler. Who work well together, would team up together again in YOUNG TOM EDISON (1940) and BABES ON BROADWAY (1941).

As with YOU'RE ONLY YOUNG ONCE, where the Hardy's take time away from their hometown of Carvel, OUT WEST WITH THE HARDYS returns to similar material involving Andy's antics and Marian's new romantic interest. A bit slow-moving at 84 minutes, the film is worthy viewing by fans of the series. Never distributed on video cassette but available on DVD, OUT WEST WITH THE HARDYS can be seen from time to time, along with 15 additional episodes in the series, on Turner Classic Movies. Next installment: THE HARDY'S RIDE HIGH (1939) (***)

Andy obnoxious and conceited letter in basketball??

When the story begins, Andy is behaving weirdly....even for Andy. He's quite obnoxious and conceited...and Polly is naturally angry at him. Why is he so fat-headed? Apparently, he just got his high school letter for...basketball(!!!!!). Now I know that basketball players were not as tall in the good old days, but at 5'2", hearing that he's a star basketball player is pretty weird and hard to believe.

In the midst of this, Judge Hardy announces he's taking the family on vacation at a dude ranch. For the judge, it's a working vacation and he's there to try to help the owners in a water rights dispute. Along the way, Andy's sister falls in love with a widower and Andy hangs around with a precocious kid (Virginia Weidler). How all this works out is for you to learn when you see this one.

This is a pretty good installment of the series....not among the best but still quite enjoyable.

This was a fun diversion for the Hardy Family viewer. The Hardy family as the title suggests heads out west. In the west Andy ends up meeting a girl, but for once not a love interest as she is about half his age. The youngster holds her own against Andy as he tries to be a cowboy. These two characters pretty well carry the film. The rest is fairly predictable with the sister meeting a love interest and Judge Hardy trying to help his friend hang onto the ranch through legal maneuvers.