Um Homem Fora de Série

A wonderful, magical fairy tale, and morality play. This is the type of movie that as a new father, I cannot wait until my son is old enough to watch this with me.

I know much has been made about Redford being too old to play Roy Hobbs. But much of the story asks you to believe in incredible things, so to me, this is a minor issue.

Everything about this movie is first rate. The cast which includes Redford, Glenn Close, Kim Basinger, Wilford Brimley and a pair of terrific performances turned in by Robert Duval and Darren McGavin.

It is easy to see that all of the actors trust the material and believe in their characters.

Barry Levinson tells the story in a straight forward style, he doesn't try to build any false suspense or surprise twists. When you watch this movie you know exactly what is going to happen long before it does, but you don't care, because it unfolds intelligently and without pretense.

My two favorite components of this movie are the cinematography by Caleb Deschanel and the beautiful, moving score composed by Randy Newman. I first enjoyed Mr. Deschanel's work on "Being There", and felt Mr. Newman's score for "Ragtime" was the best score of 1981.

"The Natural" is so much more than a baseball movie. It is a story about faith, good and evil, right and wrong, fathers and sons. It is about all that is good in baseball and in life.

10 out of 10

I can only say that I wish I had seen this movie at the theater. I own the video and watch the movie at least twice a year. I cannot imagine anyone but Redford playing Roy Hobbs. The background music is superb. Several years ago I took my family to Cooperstown,NY to visit the Baseball Hall of Fame. The main musical theme was playing as part of a baseball video.

Although the climax of the movie was excellent, I think the scene in Chicago where Glenn Close stood up and Hobbs hit the home run that broke the tower clock was definitely my favorite.

Whenever I feel a little depressed, I know it's time to pop the video in the vcr.

One thing I have noticed about movies with a sporting theme is how certain sports seem to lend themselves to a cinematic treatment more easily than others. I cannot, for example, think of a single memorable film about golf, tennis or even soccer, the world's most popular spectator sport, and only one ("Chariots of Fire") about athletics. On the other hand, there are a number of distinguished films about boxing, and the same is true of baseball. I think the reason is that these two sports often take on a metaphorical significance in the cinema so that the film is about a lot more than the game itself. Boxing is generally used as a metaphor for a wider struggle against the hardships of life, as in "Champion" or the recent "Million Dollar Baby". Baseball, on the other hand, has a similar meaning for Americans to that which cricket has for the English, signifying fair play, sportsmanship and the supposed virtues of the national character.

"The Natural" was one of three great baseball-themed movies made in the eighties, the others being "Eight Men Out" and "Field of Dreams". Both those films dealt with the notorious Chicago Black Sox scandal of 1919, but did so in very different ways. "Eight Men Out" is a relatively straightforward historical drama, while "Field of Dreams" is a surreal fantasy. "The Natural", which only deals with the Black Sox affair by implication, falls somewhere between those extremes.

In 1923 Roy Hobbs, a Nebraska farmer's son and an aspiring young baseball player, is shot and seriously injured by Harriet Bird, an obsessed fan. (Bernard Malamud, who wrote the novel on which the film was based, may have been inspired by the similar real-life shooting of a baseball star named Eddie Waitkus). We never really learn the motive for the crime or what Roy does in the next sixteen years, but we next hear of him in 1939 when, at the advanced age of 36, he has just been signed by the New York Knights, a major-league baseball team. (The Knights are fictitious, but the other teams mentioned in the film, such as the Chicago Cubs, the Philadelphia Phillies and the Pittsburgh Pirates, are real).

The film then follows the ups and downs of Roy's career as his "natural" talent for the game- hence the title- lifts the once-struggling Knights from the bottom of the table until they are contenders for the National League Pennant. (The unexpected success of an underdog is a frequent theme in sports films). It also follows his relationships with two women, the glamorous if oddly named Memo Paris, the beautiful niece of the Knights' elderly manager Pop Fisher, and Iris Gaines, a woman he meets when she comes to watch a Knights game. Memo is also involved with a corrupt gambler named Gus Sands who is trying to bribe some of the Knights players to "throw" crucial games as the Black Sox did in 1919. The Judge, the Knights' equally crooked majority owner, is also conspiring with Gus as part of a plot to obtain Pop Fisher's minority holding and thereby increase his control of the team. As with all good sporting dramas, this one ends on a tense note, with the Knights playing the Pirates in the match that will decide who wins the Pennant. Will Roy hit the runs that will secure victory for his team?

Although the film is considerably more "realistic" than "Field of Dreams", it does contain some mythical elements. There are a number of parallels with the Arthurian Legends. Roy, whose Christian name means "king" in Old French, plays for a team symbolically called the Knights. Pop Fisher's surname recalls the legend of the Fisher King. Perhaps the most prominent mythical element is Roy's bat, "Wonderboy", the film's equivalent of King Arthur's Excalibur. Roy carved this bat himself from a tree on his father's farm which had been struck by lightning.

Robert Redford is one of those actors (the late Charlton Heston is another) who seems fated to be remembered largely for his work in the first half of his career. Although there have been some reasonably good later performances, posterity is likely to remember him for the likes of "Butch and Sundance" or "The Sting" rather than, say, "Indecent Proposal" or "The Last Castle". "The Natural" is, in my view, perhaps his last great film. His next, "Out of Africa", is a good film, but Redford himself was badly miscast, and all the succeeding films of his which I have seen have been to some extent disappointing apart from "An Unfinished Life". Here, however, he is excellent, making Roy a modest, seemingly simple, man, who nevertheless has hidden depths. Among the supporting cast I would single out Wilford Brimley as Pop Fisher, initially sceptical of Roy's talents but who later becomes his mentor and father-figure.

Like many sports films, and nearly all the best ones, "The Natural" uses sport as a metaphor for life. Roy here becomes an all-American hero, a man who shows that it is possible to succeed both in sport and in life if natural talent is combined with decency and strength of character. It confirms my view that Barry Levinson, the maker of films like "Diner", "Tootsie", "Rain Man" and "Good Morning Vietnam", is one of Hollywood's finest directors, capable of making deeply satisfying films about the struggles and triumphs of ordinary people. 8/10.

Despite being an Englishman I played Fast Pitch Softball against USA Service teams over many years so understand Baseball. This is a sports movie constructed in a marvelously entertaining manner fulfilling my boyhood dreams. Redford might be old for the role but I found him both believable and committed to giving enjoyment. Great cast, lovely music, super performances, brilliant fairytale story and a real feel good experience.

Whenever "The Natural" is on TV, I stop what I'm doing and watch it. I don't know why, exactly. I have been a baseball fan since I was a little kid and love the tradition. There is no other sport that has as much history. It's because one can isolate moments in time. Situations develop. Every announcer says things like, "Bottom of the third, men on first and third, Turley on the mound, Simpson is up, he's two for four today. The wind is blowing out to right field, etc." We can make words visual. In this wonderful movie, a man wants a piece of that tradition. He makes a horrible mistake along the way to the big leagues, and now is given one last chance. This is mythical. This is not realistic. To criticize it on the basis of its credibility is unfair. Even to compare it to the book is unfair. They are totally different. What one does with a camera should not be compared to the printed page. Malamud did his thing and now Barry Levinson is doing his. The cinematography is without peer. It is magical all the way through. The lighting as Glenn Close stands up in the stands is mesmerizing. This is more Greek myth than baseball story, but it is a baseball story, with the Ruth like gods and the day-to-day players. Roy Hobbs is like all of us in some ways and we love him for his endurance, patience, and drive. Redford brings him to life with that rugged face moving away from lost youth. It's a fine film.