Gandhi Godse Ek Yudh

Wonderfully written drama with brilliant presentation of different frame of references.

Conversations between the lead characters Gandhi and Godse are very thoughtful. Movie highlights what Gandhi & Godse lacked in their thoughts. If they had worked together, we could have seen completely a different india altogether.

Only negative for the movie it has lot of scope to experiment. Instead of stating known facts director could have shown more about the ideological differences.

Lead actors were brilliant in performance. Though the side characters must improve a lot. Casting and costumes of the national leaders is exceptional.

A brilliant concept

However, the folks behind the movie haven't really done justice to it

It is very "preachy" and sounds like a monologue many a times

The concept was a high potential one: to challenge some views of Gandhiji and really debate and thrash them out. The film makers have simply not done ANY justice to it at all. They could have done a lot more.

For example: there are many controversies surrounding Gandhi ji , and none of these have been done justice to in the move:

* That he appeased a certain community by bending over backwards,

* that he discouraged Netaji Subash Chandra Bose,

* that he wanted people to just surrender and sacrifice not just their lives, but also the lives of their children for the sake of non-violence

* that he got VVIP treatment in jail and was in cahoots with the British

* that he overruled the majority vote that Sardar Patel got and insisted on Nehru becoming the prime minister

* that he had wanted the Congress to be dismantled after India got independence... and a lot more!

Highly mediocre movie, given the points that it could have intelligently addressed. Sad loss of potential .

Nice experiment done by Rajkumar Santoshi in Indian cinema. This what if- Alternate history experiment movie is very thought provoking. This clash of ideologies and the very basis of which idea of India is formed. It is also well balanced and has captured very well what emotions prevailed in our country during that time and the challenges it faced. Also that last scene is just jaw dropping.

The only complaint I have is that they chose to show flaws in Gandhi's ideology on social issues but didn't offer his point of view on his religious bias and appeasement as in he just ignored Godse's counter on that aspect.

The good thing about this movie is that Rajkumar Santoshi will receive flak from both left and right wing. This nuance was much needed in our political discourse which has become too extreme to even listen to the other side.

Gandhi Godse (2023) : Movie Review

Rajkumar Santoshi returns to the silver screen after a nine-year wait with Gandhi Godse: Ek Yudh. In the title, they have called it a war, but it's not a violent war. It's a war of ideologies with no weapons available to use. I happened to see a Marathi play called "Me Nathuram Godse Boltoy," and I was stunned by it. As we know, Godse shot Gandhi and went to jail; hence, he never got the chance to explain his doings and thoughts. The play gave him the stage, and it's all about his ideology with a twist of Gandhi's perception to it. I was expecting a solid, hard-hitting product from Santoshi, but this was too mild and fictional to suit the context people were hoping for. Well, that's one perspective, but Gandhi Godse has a safe outing from another perspective. We live in a social media era where even rat-sized things create Everest-level controversies. Maybe that's why Santoshi chose it. However, cinematic realistic values are too low to keep you immersed as a viewer.

Gandhi Godse starts off with a partition between India and Pakistan in 1947. How it destroyed many lives and our unity are the expected follow-ups. Soon, we meet Nathuram Godse (Chinmay Mandlekar), who is disturbed by Hindu-Muslim riots and assumes Mahatma Gandhi (Dipak Antani) is responsible for the partition and riots. He decides to pluck out the root of it by killing Gandhi and successfully dragging three bullets into him. Up until here, it's a historical drama, but then it becomes a fictional drama that nobody would be interested in. Gandhi survives, and Godse is sent to jail. Soon, Gandhi is also sent to the same jail, and he chooses the same ward where Godse is put in. These two have several conversations and that's 'The Yudh of Ideologies' this film is meant to present.

Gandhi Godse is 110 minutes long and still a terribly slow film. The first half is too boring to hold your attention, and that's what causes you to lose interest in the film. You have to keep the audience awake to let them see your story; you can't expect them to take a nap in the first half and then wake up after the intermission. The screenplay of Gandhi Godse fails-and how. Then the second half has some healthy conversations that define the entire film, but it's too late by then. One of the major flaws appears at the beginning only when you see the scene of Gandhi's survival. From there, it becomes difficult for you to accept the film and go along with it. There is no 'Yudh' between Gandhi and Godse; it's more like Gandhi with Godse and Gandhi vs. Congress. Something just doesn't feel right here, politically or theoretically.

Gandhi Godse is a performance-oriented film, and it scores high grades there. Deepak Antani has played the part of Mahatma Gandhi more than 500 times, and you just have to add one more to the list. He looks like Gandhi, he walks like Gandhi, and he talks like Gandhi, so you feel like you're watching the real Mahatma Gandhi on the big screen. Chinmaya Mandlekar is getting better with every next film, and Nathuram Godse's portrayal in this film proves that. The cute debutant Tanisha Santoshi is decent, but her character is a big misfit in this narrative. The supporting cast had done a fantastic job, and you felt like watching them get more screen time, but that didn't happen unfortunately.

Technical aspects of Gandhi Godse are promising, but not all. The cinematography and art design are both beautiful. It lacks breathtaking frames, though. What you can easily notice are glitches in the editing, right from the first scene of riots. The film suffers badly due to the absence of hard-hitting dialogues. I mean, the verbal war between Gandhi and Godse is supposed to be hard hitting and clap-worthy, but here you hardly get any such lines. "Sarkare hukumat karti hai, desh seva nahi," that one line by Gandhi hits hard, and there are a couple of other one liners in the jail scene that leave you in awe. Rajkumar Santoshi has done comedy, action, and romantic films, and he gets into a new zone with Gandhi Godse, only to see lower results. He is done with those evergreen films like Ghayal, Damini, Andaz Apna Apna, Ghatak, Pukar, and The Legend of Bhagat Singh and is likely not to repeat them, but he is not even going close to them nowadays. The 9-year gap says a lot. He could have done better-a lot better, actually. Overall, Gandhi Godse offers a highly fictionalised battle that can be seen once to know the ideologies of deshbhakts with opposite mindsets.

RATING - 4/10*

You get to hear both of them. Movie does a balanced job to put both ideology forward through their character and dialogues. More importantly movie does give Godse a space(broad and significant) to put forward his thoughts and reasonings which his supporters feel due in history.

It starts with one ideology domination but picks up nicely and smoothly. A love story in between make the movie dry for sometime but it proves to be a plot put to give an important message towards end.

Movie does justice with history may be because it hardly touches much historical events. Movie is not just another recreation of same already known historical events. Its the dialogue and practice of their(both) ideology which leaves the message.

An important and balanced watch to have in this much polarized era.