Sins of the Amish

This two-part documentary just became available streaming on Peacock, running just under two hours total.

It focuses sequentially on several women in several states with substantial Amish communities. Each of these women are either victims of child sexual abuse growing up, or the mother of children who have suffered sexual abuse within the family. Most are victims of their own older brothers but in some cases their own fathers or church leaders.

The documentary seems to suggest that sexual abuse of children is very common in various Amish communities. Whether it is or not more common than the rest of society, the fact that leaders always want to cover it up is distressing. It is a CRIME, it should never be covered up. Maybe if every offender went to jail then it would stop.

The film explains the church attitude that (1) men and boys past puberty have strong sexual desires and (2) if they act on them but later express remorse then they are forgiven with no need for additional action. Further if victims, or the mother of victims, contact the police with a complaint then they will be expelled from the community, excommunicated from the church, while the abuser gets the benefit of the doubt and support from the community. That is just so messed up.

The documentary does also cover some cases where the abuser was reported and how the legal punishment played out but the Amish attitude needs to be changed. If not voluntarily then forceably.

Those interviewed and the producers of the documentary hope this will serve to begin a movement to expose the sins of the Amish, and they compare it to such movements as the Civil Rights movement. Time will tell if it works out that way.

I found this to be a totally absorbing documentary, a glimpse into a culture with its own unique rules, a culture few of us ever have a glimpse of.

This is not a documentary. This is a disgraceful generalization of the Amish and Mennonite community. As a Mennonite, deeply engrained in my community, I can say that this is an unfair and inaccurate representation of us as a people.

We are pacifists. This "documentary" is an unfortunate exploitation of the experiences of a few individuals. It is apparent that no due diligence was done to ensure that the statements of absolution made by "experts" are fact - and not broad generalizations.

It is disrespectful to both the victims and the Amish/Mennonite communities.

This is inflammatory and should be removed from Peacock. It deserves zero stars.

I had read a few articles and memoirs composed by survivors of the Amish cult before watching this series so I wasn't "shocked" by the depravity but I was still disgusted by what these women and children were subjected to. The Amish and other similar communities need to face intervention from the real world to put a stop to the abuse and hold those committing these crimes accountable. Something is seriously wrong with these people - raping your own children and then justifying it with a fake religion is insane.

I hope everyone gets to see this documentary about this Amish community and how women are treated by the Amish Men community. These women and children need to be protected. This is what true conservatives are all about. They're choosing not to support women's rights. I strongly believe this is why Roe v Wade should not be overturned.

I wish and hope all the woman will get protection and help they need. I agree it's not the Amish those horrible stories are everywhere, but to just bring awareness to the community and hope that will bring a conviction to many. Such a tragedy, my hears goes for those and all girls/woman who witnessed and experienced those devastating moments.