Le pupille

This Christmas, I watched the 37-minute film Le pupille (The Pupil) on Disney+. It's one of the 15 films shortlisted for the Academy Awards early next year in the Live Action Short Film category. Set during wartime Italy, the film features little orphan girls living in a boarding school run by nuns, as they go about their routines on Christmas Eve leading to Christmas Day. There's a little bit of a musical number. But instead of singing "It's A Hard-Knock Life", the orphans act as a Greek chorus, opening and later closing the film, singing the summary of the plot as well as the denouement. The film contains themes of youth defiance against cruelty, injustice and totalitarianism encapsulated in a funny, bittersweet but not too saccharin-sweet story that is as heartwarming as it is profound.

At the center is the wide-eyed little girl Serafina (played by Melissa Falasconi, who received an Honorable Mention as Best Actor from the Philadelphia Film Festival), who brazenly stands up against the dictatorial Mother Superior, Fioralba (played by Alba Rohrwacher, the director's sister). The trigger for the main conflict is a humongous red cake which is given by someone for the orphans but the Mother Superior has other ideas for it.

The film's rebellion theme reminds us of Roald Dahl's Matilda and a past Oscar-winning short film titled Mindenki (Sing). But writer-director Alice Rohrwacher - a past winner at Cannes with 4 features films in her IMDb filmography - infuses Le pupille with so much tongue-in-cheek humor that keeps it from being too tense but still delivers the point precisely. Co-produced by, among others, the legendary Alfonso Cuarón, Le pupille is a wonderful, brilliant, entertaining and fulfilling short film. I look forward to seeing it listed in the Oscar nominations, to be announced on 24 January 2023.

"Le Pupille" is a beautifully crafted short film that delves into the cynicism of Catholic Church morals during the era in which it's set. While the general description refers to a Catholic boarding school, it's important to note that the setting is actually a Catholic orphanage, which adds depth to the story. The film's attention to detail, its satirical undertones, and the innocent yet sharp portrayal of the young girls offer a poignant commentary on institutional hypocrisy and the resilience of youthful spirit. A truly delightful and thought-provoking watch indeed.

P. S: Yes it is slow, watch and have the patience to not use your phone.

I did not like it. Although, the shooting style made my "not bad" reaction to the film. The production design was very good. The kids were very realistic. It was like a documentary. I was sad while watching the movie. It's still a matter of religion. We watch people who take their childhood away by imposing their ignorant narratives on children by naming them evil and bad. Alba Rohrwacher played so well that you hate the character. The nun who did not want to give the cake to the girls because she wanted to flatter the biship. However, after seeing religious and ignorant people in a movie, I got angry, as always. I hope one day everyone will understand the truth and investigate their religion. As a short film, it wasn't bad. Also, the singing scenes were very good.

Noel Murray of the Los Angeles Times wrote, "This captivating and surprisingly suspenseful film shares with Rohrwacher's other work a wry sense of humor and a deep understanding of how people can be horribly evil, sometimes in the name of truth."

I'm leaving him a bit here because the tone created in the movie is definitely not original.

Firstly; Alfonso Cuaron is in the producer's chair of the movie, and the movie is almost a copy of A Little Princess, a re-make of Cuaron's 1995 movie.

Come on, I understand that those who haven't seen that movie can't see this obvious resemblance, but I don't understand how the big academy has let this happen.

Summary

An adorable Christmas story, never sappy or sentimental, where the Dickensian meets the ineffably Italian. A medium-length film in which Alice Rohrwacher admirably combines humor, irony, tenderness, musicals, pictorials, and comics to once again deal with power, religion, and micropolitics.

Review

The story takes place in a Catholic religious boarding school for girls during Christmas Eve and Christmas. We are in Italy, during World War II.

Based on a letter that the Italian writer Elsa Morante wrote to a friend, Le pupille is a wonderful Christmas story. The director Alice Rohrwacher, in less than 40 minutes, offers us a sensitive, humorous and deep story about that boarding school, with a relentless mother superior (Alba Rohrwacher, most just) and the preparations for her living nativity scene so that the convent raises funds in that such a difficult time.

One of the offerings that one of the aristocrats of the place will make (a devastated and funny Valeria Bruni-Tedeschi) will generate an unexpected conflict in the convent. It is in this conflict where Rohrwacher ends up introducing his usual and acute (never obvious or pamphleteering) treatment of power, religion and micropolitics. The economy of resources and the originality with which the filmmaker expresses the conflicts and accumulated tension is remarkable, and she does it purely on film, combining the pictorial, humor, irony, musicals, and comics. As light as intense.

The film is adorable (like its childish cast), but never sappy, combining the Dickensian, the ineffably Italian and that fair tone suitable for all audiences but not childish, in line with the best and most classic exponents of the Disney universe.