Tabby McTat

Literally the worst thing I have ever watched. How this was ever made and people thought was a good production shows how low the standard has dropped.

This was listed as 'the thing to watch this Christmas'. Which is right if the thing you like to watch is weird looking cats which sing 'miaow, miaow, miaow' in a creepy human voice over and over alongside a repetitive song.

When you think of the Christmas classics such as 'The Snowman' this is embarrassing, actually it is just embarrassing. I haven't felt as compelled to write a review for some time.

Is this really the best they could come up with to treat TV licence payers to?

The longest 25 minutes I have ever wasted.

My kid loves each of the Julia Donaldson cartoon adaptations (other than he's for some reason terrified of the Smeds and the Smoos!). The animation quality is better as each one is released.

This one is quite a heartfelt story, and they've captured the behaviours of the kittens very well I felt. A good number of the user reviews for this obviously don't realise this is an adaptation of a Julia Donaldson book - a kids book. It's not a cinematic masterpiece, but that's not really what you're looking for with a 30 minute kid friendly cartoon. It's ideal to give your toddler a chill out time, and I enjoy watching them too.

A very gentle family friendly short that's well suited to Christmas viewing.

The animation is effectively done, with one exception: Tabby McTat is eating cat food from a bowl and yet the contents of the bowl never change and we never see food actually going into his mouth. The behaviour of Tabby McTat at times seems more canine than feline; I did wonder if Tabby McTat was a cat because "cat" generates more useful rhymes (for example "flat") than "dog" does. The "owners" of the black cat seem perhaps a little too accommodating. And while I'm sure the story is not intended to have any connection to Christmas, the ending was somewhat reminiscent of "the Christmas story".

There's no sign of Luke Treadaway nor of "Bob" in this similar tale of a busker and his cat in London. Luckily for the narrator, the cat's name rhymes with loads of other words as we tell a tale of them being robbed; 'Fred" giving chase and breaking his leg; them becoming separated, "Tabby" wasting no time falling in love and then - well don't we hope they all reunite? It's perhaps a bit long and there's no getting away from the repetitive "cat, sat, mat, that, hat, chat" rhyming dialogue but that said, the animation is quite engaging and the story one of affection and loyalty, tinged with a touch of mischief. It's not exactly Aardman, but it's still enjoyable enough for half an hour - especially if you're a cat-lover.

I've two small boys at home so naturally the Julia Donaldson adaptations have formed an essential part of our television experience for a few years now. I've seen all the JD animations, more times than I care to remember.

This though has only been watched once and a half. My children were bored, my wife was bored and by crikey I was bored.

The animation was as good as always but the story was really, really lazy. It was derivative like most children's stories which is expected and forgivable but it was also really dull. I never care for the characters in the JD stories (they're short stories for kids) this time though I disliked them. I honestly wish Fred had broken his neck in the fall to save me from the last fifteen minutes of this.