The Boxcar Children - Surprise Island

Okay. I feel bad because I actually enjoyed the first movie and was fond of the books as a child. Aside from which, it's a kid's film so I hate to pick on it. But I'm sorry, this sequel feels incredibly downgraded in every aspect.

The story was fine. The voice acting was awful. I don't know if it was the new director that was brought in or the fact that three-fourths of the Alden children were recast, but the delivery and inflections in every line and reaction were so off. Even Joey King, an otherwise fine actress and the only child to reprise her role from the first film (she plays Jessie), also seemed to have some problems delivering her dialogue effectively. To top it off, the actor playing new character Joe spoke with the inflections of a child born in the Nineties (as opposed to a kid living in the postwar Forties). His language wasn't dated as such, but he definitely sounds more like a product of his time, than Joe's time.

Where a major issue lies with me is the character of Benny. I don't recall the original actor being nearly this obnoxious with the role, but in this one the recast actor shouts literally. Every. Single. Word. I half expected everyone to tell him to STFU, although some characters did acknowledge his outright annoying behavior. And yes, the character of Benny is supposed to be rambunctious and spunky, but not to the point where he's this obnoxious. The story and the film are supposed to have a quiet, timeless feel to it, as with the first film, and here we have this kid shouting every single one of his lines and disrupting what are otherwise charming, pleasant, atmospheric scenes.

The animation looks worse too. While the animation in the first was nothing special, the animation in this one is even more horrendous! Just awkward and ugly from beginning to end.

I gave this a slightly higher score because despite these issues, it is still a harmless film that can be enjoyed by young kids and it is a nice story about the Alden kids' summer trip to the family island and introducing new friends and characters. But do not expect much more than that from this movie. If you can keep this in mind and not hold it to such a high standard, you may actually enjoy this sequel a bit.

All of the actors nailed it. The animation is the best and it looks so realistic. I didn't care what the people say but this movie is just so amazing. I highly recommend it just like the first movie. Please see this sequel when it comes on DVD in case if you forgot to see it in theaters.

This movie is wonderfully different from most films made for children. Its more of a drama and has only a few moments of action and no stupid jokes.

The kids spend the summer on a small island and discover the simple pleasures of exploring nature, using their imaginations and enjoying there own independence.

Along the way they discover a family secret and the importance of second chances.

I think my kids are fascinated by this film (they have watched it repeatedly) because its so different from most of what is available out there. I love the film because that characters have a whole summer of fun without any cell phones or computers!

In fairness I never saw the first one. I am not judging this based on the animation style, but just the content. If you want a generally wholesome story about kids who love each other having adventures, this is a good movie.

Is it the most compelling story ever written? No, but it's quite good for children under 10. Good family values, pleasant and calming soundtrack.

My kids, 6,4,2 love it. My oldest has read the book and thought it was a good adaptation. The children's adventures and general joy for and thirst for love and life is just plain heartwarming.

Deserves much better than the ratings it gets.

A wonderful movie that is great for the family and gives the feel of reading through the classic children's book. I hope they continue this series.