The Challenge of the Immortals matches were the Gentleman's Club (represented by team captain Chuck Taylor (Dustin Howard) and Orange Cassidy, the other members were Drew Gulak and the Swamp Monster) vs. Battle Hive (represented by team captain Amasis (Desean Pratt) and Worker Ant (Nelson Ortiz), the other members were Fire Ant and "Smooth Sailin'" Ashley Remington); Die Bruderschaft des Kreuzes (represented by team captain Jakob Hammermeier, the other members were Pinkie Sanchez and Soldier Ant, since Nøkken had left after King of Trios with no explanation) vs. the Snake Pit (represented by Argus, the other members were team captain Ophidian, Shynron and Eddie Kingston); the Arcane Horde (represented by Oleg the Usurper (Josh Thorman), the other members were the Batiri [Obariyon and Kodama], since team captain UltraMantis Black had been forced into retirement due to leg injuries) vs. the Snake Pit (represented by Eddie Kingston (Edward Moore)); and Crown and Court (represented by team captain Princess Kimberlee (Kimberly Frankele) and Los Ice Creams [Ice Cream Jr. and El Hijo del Ice Cream], the other member was Jervis Cottonbelly) vs. the Wrecking Crew (represented by team captain Max Smashmaster (Sebastian Reese), Blaster McMassive (Thomas Stintsman) and Flex Rumblecrunch (Sean Burke), the other member was Jaka).
The "Mr. Touchdown" Mark Angelosetti vs. Frightmare (Stephen Delicato), Shynron (Aerial Van Go) vs. the Proletariat Boar of Moldova, Dasher's Dugout vs. Battleborn, and the Silver Ant-Juan Francisco de Coronado (Joe Padilla) matches were the only ones that were not part of the Challenge of the Immortals tournament.
The encore match was Silver Ant vs. Juan Francisco de Coronado.
Dasher's Dugout (team captain Dasher Hatfield, Heidi Lovelace (Dori Elizabeth Prange) and Icarus (Ronald Grams)), w/"Mr. Touchdown" Mark Angelosetti) defeated Battleborn (Kevin Condron, "Juke Joint" Lucas Calhoun and Missile Assault Man (R.B. Banks)) because of Angelosetti's loaded elbow pad. During the match, Icarus tried to pick up the Estonian Thunderfrog's Hammer of Peace and failed, meaning he was no longer worthy to wield the Hammer. Angelosetti's cheating would ultimately lead to Dasher surrendering Dasher's Dugout's COTI points.