A Hole in the Head

Tony Manetta (Frank Sinatra) hitchhiked to make it big in Florida with his two best friends, Jerry Marks and Mendy. Jerry became a rich promoter while Mendy ended up driving a cab. Tony is still trying to make it big with his girlfriend Shirl (Carolyn Jones) and his young son. He needs rent money. In desperation, he calls his estranged brother Mario Manetta (Edward G. Robinson) who insists on setting him up with Eloise Rogers (Eleanor Parker).

This is based on a play and directed by Frank Capra. It has the great "High Hopes" song which won an Oscar. It's also notable for being a colored Capra film. He would soon retire early from filmmaking. The cinematic world is changing in many ways and he's missing the train. As for this movie, the story is a darker one although Capra still leaves his mark. I have to say that Tony does not deserve either women. He is the worst when it comes to the fairer sex. I like the steady decline with Tony's journey. That's why I don't like the ending. I don't know how the play ends. I don't like this ending. If Capra is willing to do a sad ending, I can see him continuing to work and adding another chapter to his legacy. I like this movie except the ending.

I had never seen this movie before renting it the other night and was surprised to see it was directed by Frank Capra. Once I watched it, I wasn't surprised anymore. This was a wonderful film driven by characters rather than plot devices and an example of vintage Capra.

The performances are what make the film. Frank Sinatra was great as a self-centered dreamer with a new idea every minute and some method of working the system. The guy's a heel but he still manages to keep our sympathy. Edward G. Robinson is hilarious as his much-put-upon brother who is constantly making social gaffes and never figures out how to sit in that rocking chair! Despite the fact that his character is a comic figure, there are some scenes of real poignancy between him and Sinatra. The ever reliable Thelma Ritter is also very funny as Robinson's caring and weepy wife. Eleanor Parker! Wow! I never saw her look so good. There wasn't enough of her in this film but perhaps that's when you know a character succeeds, when you wish to see more of them. Her gentle elegance was a perfect contrast to Carolyn Jones' character's unabashed self-absorption. And Eddie Hodges was perfect as the boy old beyond his years who stubbornly loves his father no matter what.

And the ending is happy (Hey, it's a Capra film!)without resorting to any schmaltzy plot devices.

It was well worth my time.

Read all my reviews at www.midnitcafe.blogspot.com

I received A Hole in the Head for my birthday in a Frank Sinatra double pack with the original Manchurian Candidate. I had put off watching it because it did not seem like a movie I would particularly enjoy. But in my quest to watch and review all of my movies, I had no choice but to put it in the player. Of course the fact that my wife wanted to watch it prompted me a little further even to the point of watching it out of alphabetical order.

Frank Capra is the great godfather of sentimental movies. Many of these are deservedly hailed by fans and critics. From Mr Smith Goes to Washington to It's a Wonderful Life Capra made movies about the little guys fighting the system and coming out on top. These movies are sentimental enough to be dubbed "Capracorn" by the system, but are handled with masterful hands that rise above the schmaltz created by so many others. Besides little guys he also flooded his movies with eccentric characters standing out in a world full or normal folk. Arsenic and Old Lace and You Can't Take it With You are standouts of this form. Sadly, A Hole in the Head tries to mix both of these Capra types and fails on both accounts.

The film is the second to last picture ever made by Capra and was the beginning of an attempted comeback from a few years break from making Hollywood pictures. But instead of a comeback this film serves only to remind us of what Capra used to be. Frank Sinatra plays a down on his luck big dreamer who is about to be evicted from his hotel business in Miami, Florida. He calls up his brother, Edward G Robinson and sister-in-law Thelma Ritter for help pretending his son is sick. Robinson and wife quickly head down from New York to see what's going on. Hilarity and sentimentality ensue. Swinging Sinatra butts heads with button down Robinson until a quick ending and easy solution are found.

The performances of the stars are fine. At this point in their careers Sinatra and Robinson are essentially playing themselves. Although Sinatra is more up and coming to the declining Robinson. There are some good jokes and the simple story is fair enough as it is. Capra fills Sinatra's hotel with an odd collection of eccentrics that seem to have no other purpose but to fill up some time and tell a few jokes. The ending of the movie seems tied on and creates changes to some characters without any real provocation. The cheese factor is high even for a Capra film and it's not subdued by any superb performances. The drama is not elevated above the schlock you would see in a made for TV movie.

The stand out of the film is Sinatra and son singing the classic "High Hopes." Being a fan of Sinatra more as a singer than actor this amusing break in the middle of the picture helped keep my hopes up for a decent picture. Those hopes were not shattered, nor were they completely fulfilled. For beginners of "Capracorn" you should pick out some of his earlier, superior films. But for a lonely night in need of some corny sentiment, this is some fluffy candy that just might fill.

More reviews at www.midnitcafe.blogspot.com

This is film is a rare commodity as a Hollywood product - a wonderful "little" film. By little, I mean unpretentious. Perhaps this is because Frank Capra had a talent for telling inspirational, uplifting or "message" stories without seeming to preach. We all know the Ralph Cramden character - the botched hero with "high hopes". This is Frank Sinatra's Tony Maneta. Unlike Jimmy Stewart's George Bailey in Capra's "It's a Wonderful Life," Tony Maneta isn't beset by problems circumstantial so much as personal. Yet, whether the antagonist is an ungrateful world or a character flaw, Capra and playwright/screenwriter Arnold Schulman recognize the abiding nobility of the human spirit's determination to overcome the odds.

I love the setting in "Hole in the Head". It's a treat to see South Miami Beach during a period when formerly glamorous hotels had gone to seed, knowing that they would one day rise again. I don't think anyone would have given them a chance at the time of the story, just like Tony Maneta's prospects. But "Hole in the Head" makes us want to believe, that just by surviving, like South Beach, Tony will one day triumph.

By the way, there's a wonderful performance by the underappreciated Eddie Hodges, whose minor billing is unjustified, considering his character's major part in the story.

Adaptation of Arnold Schulman's play about feckless Miami Beach widower with a young son who needs a fast loan to save his ramshackle hotel, considering the idea of marrying into money with a shy (but beautiful) young widow. Slick, but not very moving comedy-drama won an Oscar for the memorable tune "High Hopes", but--with Frank Sinatra, Edward G. Robinson, and Eleanor Parker in the cast--it should have been much better. The youngster is played by sharp, yet Hollywood-smart Eddie Hodges, who is decent with the kind of lines concocted for him. Frank Capra directed, weakly. Some good scenes, but it runs too long and has too few jokes. **1/2 from ****