3 reviews
This Romanian drama, adapted from Caesar Petrescu's short story "Fram, the Polar Bear," may evoke mixed feelings, but it undeniably offers a vivid portrayal of circus life in the beginning of the 20th century. The cinematography is striking, blending elements of Italian classicism with the Russian film tradition, and I particularly appreciated the lighting choices in the nighttime scenes.
As an art historian, I recall Tudor Caranfil's remarks in his "Dictionary of Romanian Films" about "Saltimbancii": "The Buffone circus returns to Iasi, where little Geo, the owner's son, dreams of becoming an Arctic explorer like Nansen. Despite his mother's hopes for him to become a doctor, fate leads him to the circus after her passing, where the symbol of eternal frost is embodied by a white bear." This straightforward summary overlooks the harsh realities faced by circus performers during that era. Tragedy, injury, or simply losing their appeal could spell disaster for them, yet they persevered. The film conveys a powerful message: never give up, keep fighting, and victory will come at the end. If you're not winning, it's not the end!
I find it perplexing that some negative reviews come from those influenced by a more sensitive perspective. Perhaps my fond memories of attending circuses every few months during my childhood shape my view. They were joyful family experiences! It's ironic to see accusations of "child abuse" and "animal abuse" from individuals who often support prolonged proxy wars funded by their governments, while simultaneously criticizing those who oppose such conflicts. Maybe it's time to address the broader issue of "abuse of humanity" rather than focusing on just one aspect.
Elisabeta Bostan did a good job and I am ready for the sequels... yes, they exist!
As an art historian, I recall Tudor Caranfil's remarks in his "Dictionary of Romanian Films" about "Saltimbancii": "The Buffone circus returns to Iasi, where little Geo, the owner's son, dreams of becoming an Arctic explorer like Nansen. Despite his mother's hopes for him to become a doctor, fate leads him to the circus after her passing, where the symbol of eternal frost is embodied by a white bear." This straightforward summary overlooks the harsh realities faced by circus performers during that era. Tragedy, injury, or simply losing their appeal could spell disaster for them, yet they persevered. The film conveys a powerful message: never give up, keep fighting, and victory will come at the end. If you're not winning, it's not the end!
I find it perplexing that some negative reviews come from those influenced by a more sensitive perspective. Perhaps my fond memories of attending circuses every few months during my childhood shape my view. They were joyful family experiences! It's ironic to see accusations of "child abuse" and "animal abuse" from individuals who often support prolonged proxy wars funded by their governments, while simultaneously criticizing those who oppose such conflicts. Maybe it's time to address the broader issue of "abuse of humanity" rather than focusing on just one aspect.
Elisabeta Bostan did a good job and I am ready for the sequels... yes, they exist!
A film about circus world. About the nuances of a Moldavian city. About sacrifices, lights, show and the flavors of past. A polar bear. And a family. In the circle of a gray, strange act. It is a sensitive definition of past and small values. About courage and daily fights. And the cast is collection of great actors. Gina Patrichi as lost-ed mother, Carmen Galin in the role of axis , bridge, hart and voice, Octavian Cotescu as actor, in basic form. And Iași. As the skin of feelings and pains.It is a page of my childhood. So, the words are only drops of ink. Pieces of a chimeric time machine. In the Comunist period, a movie like this was a kind of window. Today, a strange album with the as photos.
for me it is more than a movie. it is a huge window to the colors of childhood. and this did it special. for actors and songs and the white bear. for Iași in an old age and for the flavor of circus. and, sure, for applause. it is one of the most impressive films of my childhood. for the dramatic story and for the chemistry who grows up as show. for atmosphere and for the useful lesson about the difference between appearances and deep reality. for a form of magic who is far to be easy to define because it is not exactly joy or balloons or fireworks. a delicate picture of a town and a family. or, only, one of the demonstrations of great art from Elisabeta Bostan.
- Kirpianuscus
- Mar 25, 2017
- Permalink