(in credits order) complete, awaiting verification
- Bill Irwin(segment "Subway Car from Hell")
- Paul Lazar(segment "Subway Car from Hell")
- Andre B. Blake(segment "Subway Car from Hell")
- Robert W. Castle(segment "Subway Car from Hell")
- Joe Toutebon(segment "Subway Car from Hell") (as Joseph Toutebon)
- Denis Leary(segment "The Red Shoes")
- Christine Lahti(segment "The Red Shoes")
- N'Bushe Wright(segment "The Red Shoes")
- Kevin Corrigan(segment "The Red Shoes")
- O.L. Duke(segment "The Red Shoes")
- John C. Vennema(segment "The Red Shoes")
- Steve Zahn(segment "The 5:24")
- Jerry Stiller(segment "The 5:24")
- Bonnie Hunt(segment "Fern's Heart of Darkness")
- Mekhi Phifer(segment "Fern's Heart of Darkness")
- José Ramón Rosario(segment "Fern's Heart of Darkness")
- Nancy Ticotin(segment "Fern's Heart of Darkness")
- John Ford Noonan(segment "Fern's Heart of Darkness")
- Lili Taylor(segment "The Listeners")
- Michael Rapaport(segment "The Listeners")
- Mercedes Ruehl(segment "Underground")
- Peter Sarsgaard(segment "Underground") (as Peter Scarsgaard)
- Jeremy Jordan(segment "Underground")
- Sarita Choudhury(segment "Honey-Getter")
- Nicole Ari Parker(segment "Honey-Getter")
- Ajay Naidu(segment "Honey-Getter")
- Danny Hoch(segment "Honey-Getter")
- Steven Randazzo(segment "Honey-Getter")
- Sam Rockwell(segment "Sax Cantor Riff")
- Kavi Ramachandran(segment "Sax Cantor Riff") (as Kavitha Ramachandran)
- Bruklin Harris(segment "Sax Cantor Riff")
- Taral Hicks(segment "Sax Cantor Riff")
- Daniel Rous(segment "Sax Cantor Riff") (as Dan Rous)
- Will Hare(segment "Sax Cantor Riff")
- Rosie Perez(segment "Love on the A Train")
- Michael McGlone(segment "Love on the A Train") (as Mike McGlone)
- Gretchen Mol(segment "Love on the A Train")
- Gregory Hines(segment "Manhattan Miracle")
- Anne Heche(segment "Manhattan Miracle")
- George T. Odom(segment "Manhattan Miracle") (as George Odom)
Rest of cast listed alphabetically
- John D. Bair(uncredited)
- Mark Robert Gordon(segment "Underground") (uncredited)
- Adrian Lee(uncredited)
- Steve Nuke(segment "Love on the A Train") (uncredited)
