A year after first encountering Lineria and Capsella, Wilfred, Bacon, Chesterfield, and Kilmare have been through many Witch Hunting adventures, but they still not very good at it. Soon they encounter a group of witches in the woods, a prank calling serial killer (Chris Harmon), a mischievous shop owner (Pete Borden) who harbors a deadly secret and a cup of magical tomato soup served to them by Chesterfield (Dave R. Watkins). Wilfred and Bacon manage to capture a warlock (Steve Warren) who gives them Lineria and Capsella's current residence. They set off after the witches but soon find themselves in way over their heads.
The evil witches Lineria and Capsella capture Witch Hunters Wilfred and Bacon, put Wilfred under a love spell, and proceed to torture Bacon. Candy, a mischievous girl who has information about a new witch, visits Chesterfield and Kilmare at the headquarters. The new witch turns out to be Barracuda's girlfriend, Connie. Before Kilmare arrives for Connie, Barracuda's Uncle McClure shows up with an antique trunk with a treasure map inside of it. When Kilmare shows up looking for Connie, he fights off Barracuda with a shocking device while Connie pours her newest potion into her fish bowl, which later turns her beta fish into a giant monster.
Lineria and Capsella dump Wilfred and Bacon in the woods. When Wilfred awakes he finds the witches have put a spell on Bacon that causes him to attack Wilfred when Wilfred snaps his fingers. A mysterious old man from another dimension, Walter Turnkpike (Dave R. Watkins) who is protected by a Russian Bee (Michael D Friedman), summons Lineria and Capsella for a séance to contact Randolph Carne.