Manchester Passion

This was a performance created by the BBC's unit that had already created the wonderful Flashmob Opera programmes which took existing opera arias, changing the words of them, and melding them into a whole story from the distinctive parts.

The Manchester Passion was broadcast live on the BBC's digital platform only channel BBC3.

The streets of central Manchester were the stage for the performance with TV cameras following the performers as they moved round the City Centre. A large crowd were present in Albert Square in front of the Town Hall where Keith Allen "hosted" the event.

The music of (mainly) Manchester provided the filling for the story using the themes and lyrics of the songs to tell the story of Jesus's betrayal, execution and resurrection.

The whole event was magnificent and at certain poignant moments, very moving. At the time varying religious groupings, both Christian and non-Christian expressed favourable opinions on the event.

I cannot understand why the BBC does not release a DVD of the event as it really deserves a much wider audience.

The BBC tried to repeat the success of the Manchester event by doing a "Liverpool Nativity", but whilst watchable, it never reached the quality of the previous one.

As Jesus approaches Albert Square in the centre of Manchester, an 8-meter cross makes it way from the other side of town to meet him and present him with his fate. Meanwhile in Albert Square itself, Keith Allen tells a large audience and a live television audience about the journey of Jesus, all the time cutting away to follow the story as it progresses on the streets.

Managing to sound terrible to the same degree as it sounds fascinating, this film interested me just because it was something different and comparatively daring. Not only was it a retelling of the story of Jesus but it also uses songs from famous Manchester bands to tell it. Obviously not feeling that was enough of a risk, the filmmakers also decided to actually set it on the streets of Manchester – oh, and to do it live as well. In regards the sheer ambition of the project, it is worthy and it manages to pull it off. We didn't have any w*nkers deciding to try and mess it up, security was good and the whole thing had not a single noticeable technical hitch. The crowd appear into it and the support from the people of Manchester was commendable.

However this is not the same as the film itself being successful because it is quite a mixed bag. The use of songs of Manchester origin is a bit of a gimmick that never 100% works; some of them fit really well, some of them don't but the overriding effect they have is to rob the story of its emotional impact. It is a strange thing but although catchy and unusual, the songs being performed live mean that the focus is on getting them in tune rather than bringing out the pain or sorrow that should be inherent in them. To their credit the cast try hard. Morfitt makes a good turn of Jesus and manages to inject heart into his character, even if he never makes it his own totally. Booth is actually pretty good and sings with emotion, while Bailey does well in his one main scene. Denise Johnson (Mary) has a good voice but is too remote from the action and her parts just feel like singing, rather than her being a character in the story. Personally I'm not a big Keith Allen fan but he does an OK job of presenting even if he is just a bit of a bloke the whole time (although he can't sing for toffee – a fact I unfortunately learnt during Wonderwall, which was the song I had been waiting for).

The actual presentation is mostly quite clever but, the bbc being the bbc, they can't help to throw in liberal ideas (which I don't actually mind, because I agree with them) but they do so in an obvious way. So the comments about wrongful arrest on trumped up charges are thrown in clunkily and having Jesus in an orange jump suit is just too obvious for words. However, despite this, the film is still worth a look regardless of how mixed it is, because it is an interesting idea and the sort of thing that belongs on a publicly funded television channel; commercial channels would never touch such a film because they can't afford to alienate their viewers, but BBC3 has no such problem and, although I understand the concerns some have about this, it is a strength of the channel that it can afford to take risks and I wish it did this sort of thing more often than it churns out uninspired sitcoms and soaps.

what were Tim booth and, particularly Kieth Allen, thinking? ignore the previous comment! this truly was a tragic affair. it was embarrassing to watch and i cringed all the way thru. i'm sure you can see Kieth Allen thinking, 'what was i on when i agreed to do this'. I think its one of those things that possibly looks good on paper, but when brought to life is not exactly what you hoped it would be.

it just doesn't work on any level except comedic! to attach classic songs to this garbage is in itself blasphemis! avoid at all costs - close your eyes and just pretend it never happened..... ahhhhhhhhh....that's better.