User reviews

Okay, let me start off by saying that, on the whole, I don't like anime very much. I've enjoyed a couple of the oft-cited "classic" series, but regard the medium as a whole in exactly the same way that I do American television: namely, that a good 90-95% of it is utter tripe, with the remainder falling anywhere from "watchable" to "decent." This being the case, it's no wonder that I don't like the self-deprecating anime parodies out there. I don't get most of the jokes, and the medium itself enforces a certain style of humor that doesn't appeal to me at all - loud, hyperactive, lowbrow, and completely over the top.

So, when I started watching this series at the behest of a friend, I was primed for disappointment after the first couple of episodes. I figured that the characters were supposed to represent cliché characters from shopworn story outlines, and that their actions were supposed to be similarly satirical. I could kind of see where it was coming from, but didn't think that it was all that clever - lots of "wacky, fun-filled high-school shenanigans and goings-on, only now we're being ironic about it." At about the third episode, my opinion drastically changed.

It was at that point that the strengths of this series started to manifest themselves. The quirks of the non-chronological episode order, its snarky sense of self-awareness, and, above all, clever humor with (gasp) a well-executed straight man.

In what I consider to be a rarity in any medium, this show presents well-thought out, witty interactions between diametrically opposed characters. Protagonist Kyon's perpetual sense of vaguely annoyed resignation provides the perfect foil to the actions of title character Haruhi's generic "anime-like" exploits. It's a break from formula, and it works incredibly well.

Based on that strong foundation, the series further succeeds with a truly phenomenal level of attention to detail. As previously stated, the episodes air out of chronological order. I considered this to be a gimmick at first, but it works surprisingly well. The chronological sequence of events makes sense logically, but the aired order of the episodes more closely follows the traditional structure of Aristotelian drama. The order chosen leaves no narrative gaps that cannot be filled by simple inference (but while it is possible to guess what happened in an unaired "preceding" episode, one still feels compelled to watch exactly how those events unfold), and superb planning prevents any plot holes or contradictions. I watched this series a second time immediately upon completing it the first time, and I was amazed at how well even seemingly inconsequential events were all tied together.

The last point is indicative of the extreme attention to detail in every area of the series. While the stock "anime" character designs grate a bit, the background art is exquisite, realistically rendered based upon actual photographic references. Animation quality is also excellent at important points. For example there is a musical performance late on in the series in which the characters are shown actually playing a song - this may sound trivial, but the subconscious effect of watching (film-quality) animation which actually corresponds to the soundtrack is incredible.

In short, I love this series for some reason. By its very nature it is something that I generally dislike, but its execution is so unique and well-carried out that I can't help it.

Good animation, nice character design, and a light-hearted story make Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuutsu enjoyable to watch.

After my first viewing, I thought that this anime was pretty good, but but was much better on for a second watch.

This is because it is done out of chronological order, and once you re watch it in correct order you notice connections you didn't see before. (OR it may be that you see a second meaning to some events you didn't notice before) You may want to read the original novels (not manga) by Tanigawa Nagaru before/after seeing this. The anime is very good at visualizing every detail in the stories it shows.

However, there are some short stories from the book that are not animated, but are referenced to.(bamboo w/ wishes attached shown in episode 14) Overall, this anime is actually very good once after brief analyzation of the plot (reading the book improves upon it as well). It is a nice break from the shounen-jump anime that seem to be taking over.

At first sight this is yet another highschool anime with lots of excuses for 'fanservice', but there is a lot more going on. The 'fanservice' is part of the plot, the main character is a tired cynic (unusual), and most importantly there is a clever plot that ties all the episodes together, and that poses some interesting questions. The episodes are deliberately non-chronological, and it is certainly worth watching the series again in chronological order.

The series is worth watching carefully, because there are a lot of casual hints in there that foreshadow and explain things, plus a good number of in-jokes about other series, anime and other.

Suzumiya Haruhi no yûutsu (The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya) might at a first glance make you think that this is just another animated school comedy/drama. Well, it's not! The setting just happen to be a school environment. This is a comedy alright, but a very smart one with a lot of sarcasm. And the characters does have a psychological sublimeness which is almost in the same class that can be found in the works of Ingmar Bergman. The episodes is aired, as it seems, out of order, i.e. the pilot is in fact episode 11. This makes it possible to present small clues to upcoming episodes. The show is an adaption of Nagaru Tanigawa's popular novel series about Haruhi Suzumiya.

What about the story then? Like in all the episodes does the story revolves Haruhi Suzumiya, who tries to ease her own boredom by embarking in adventures. Haruhi her self has no interest in ordinary humans, and actively searches for aliens, time travelers and espers (persons with supernatural forces). To find this sort of people she has formed a club which she calls the SOS-Brigade (Save the world by Overloading it with fun: Haruhi Suzumiyas Brigade). Except for Haruhi, the other members of the SOS-brigade is Kyon. He is the real protagonist of the show. It's trough his point of view that we follow the story. He just happen to sit in front in class when Haruhi came up with the idea to form the SOS-Brigade. He is quite sceptical to most club activities and tags along just to ensure that Haruhi don't go to much to the extremes, and he is the only one in the class that Haruhi likes to talk with. Another member is Yuki Nagato, which is the "indispensable silent member" and is also the only remaining member of the Literature club, which room the SOS-Brigade has occupied in the quest for a free club room. She doesn't mind that the SOS-Brigade uses her clubroom, as long as she can sit in a corner and read her books. She also participate in the brigades activities. Mikuru Asahina was "voluntarily arrested" by Haruhi because the club needed a Lolita-like mascot for anything suspicious to happen. She often act as the clubs maid. The last member is the always smiling Itsuki Koizumi, who happens to be the "mysterious transfer student" (meaning he transfered two months in to the semester which Haruhi finds to qualifies as mysterious).

Haruhi thinks that all members but Kyon are some random picked people in school, but the do indeed have their own interest in her.

Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu is a very high-rated anime in almost every review page you'll find on the web. So I really wanted to know why, and I was anything but disappointed.

If you can get past the very bizarre (but rather funny) first episode, you'll find yourself in a very entertaining and much strange world. A very well drawn, perfectly animated world, that is.

I can't tell much of the story without spoiling it, so I'll just say that it's a high school comedy... and yet it's not. I can't really say what it's about, really.

Seriously, I'm a HUGE anime fan, and I've got around 50 full series, and I'm not kidding when I say that, even though I haven't finished watching Haruhi Suzumiya, it is actually standing in a very high rank in my personal collection. I fell in love at first sight with this one, and I assure you that, at the very least, you won't be indifferent to its irresistible charm. Trust me, I don't go around giving a 10 to every thing that I watch.

A 2006 online poll of Japan's top 100 favorite animated television series of all time, conducted by TV Asahi, placed this series in fourth place. That tells you everything you need to know. So go and watch it.;) I won't comment on the story, simply because I don't want to ruin anything. I only urge you to keep watching after you saw the first episode. The Animation is really good and above TV average. The best thing about this series is, that there is finally something new. I mean it's not groundbreaking but still it offers a fresh new idea and likable characters. You won't regret entering Suzumiya Haruhi's world.

and the best thing a movie is coming soon

I tend to fall in and out of love with anime, as the more you watch the more you notice a lot of shows are just poor copies of the few gems or rehashes of old formulas. But every once in a while one of the true gems comes along and it's originality just blows you away. Haruhi is truly one of those shows. Many anime series are originally manga and sometimes the translation into an animated show is rather poorly done and doesn't utilize the benefits animation has over static drawings. Haruhi is actually based on a series of light novels and fires on all cylinders, beautiful animation, great voice acting, great music and a complete and well paced story. Watch it you won't be disappointed, and I'd suggest watching it in broadcast order it works so much better that way.

Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya is based on somewhat pat formula by now of Japanese school drama anime. The formula somewhat goes like this:

1. The main protagonist comes from world outside the normal society, and has super powers.

2. There's a very beautiful and sexy girl in a supporting role.

3. A normal character is in there who shares the main role in the story.

4. Unusual things happens in an usual social settings.

5. Sometimes the story is about the main protagonist, and the normal character that connects to the existence or destruction of the world.

6. Absolutely no effort is spent by anyone to gain all the magical powers. They just have it.

7. Usually, people outside of this tight nit group is not aware of their super powers, and goes on with their daily lives.

So there you have it. Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi is made along these lines which became the success formula for comics and anime in Japan. Even though it follows a pat formula, the series is superbly crafted and the episodes are always set in an interesting back drop within the normal social settings which always morphs into unusual circumstances surrounding Haruhi Suzumiya. Each player in the story brings some unusual insight into the daily life that usually we are not aware of. The philosophical twist of their insights are what makes this series extra entertaining. The visuals are first rate, and done beautifully.

The crazy ideas Haruhi always seem to come up with along with complicated settings of the story may give you headache from time to time. It's further complicated by the fact that the episodes are played out of sequence which further adds to the confusion. When I watched the episodes in the chronological sequence, some of the plots finally made sense. I recommend you do the same. It's much more entertaining to watch the series this way. Google

List_of_The_Melancholy_of_Haruhi_Suzumiya_episodes

for the correct sequence of all the episodes. And oh, you might notice the headache while you're watching this like I did. Let me know if you had it too.

"I believe that just imitating is boring" – Theme Song Lyrics

The definition of 'melancholy' is a prolonged state of mental depression but the funny thing about this series' title (The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya) is that this anime is anything but depressing. It's engaging, intelligent, and promising; in fact, it's nothing like the other school-oriented series that share the same genre. Sure, the early episodes of Haruhi Suzumiya have a dangerous obsession with fan- service but there's a unique charm to this series that helps it remain interesting. One of the most crucial aspects in making this series consistently enchanting is the show's titular character: Haruhi Suzumiya.

More often than not, the female lead character in an anime is a one-dimensional cardboard cutout, an attractive walking stereotype who wears skimpy clothes, who cries on-cue, who is naturally shy, and who only exists to please the male main character. For someone who has seen this character type over and over and over, Haruhi is a breath of fresh air. More than a few people who have watched this series complain that Haruhi is a selfish, scheming control freak, and that's true but I'd rather see Haruhi in a series over the army of mindless robots that have invaded the anime world. From the beginning, this series is about Haruhi's endless pursuit for the spectacular and how the people in her life are affected by it. In the series' theme song, Haruhi is listed as the "Ultra Director", and that's a fitting title for the character that lords over the essence of The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya. Haruhi is a character with multiple occupations; she's a baseball star, a club president, a skilled detective, a film director, a passionate photographer, a world-class manipulator, a God-like deity, and one very talented singer (In what's easily one of the highlights of the series, Haruhi performs a song at the school festival that she barely practiced "God Knows", and she simply tears it to shreds). Like the show itself, Haruhi proves to be nothing less than unique.

One of my favorite things about this show is its music, a great jazzy soundtrack that can be repetitive but never comes across as dull (in serious, dramatic scenes, epic music is inserted and it fits like a glove). I've seen plenty of titles with great animation; however, The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya tops them all in this department, its sharp, beautifully drawn animation serving as visual eye-candy for the audience. Not only is the animation great but the series also displays a creative flair with it too. During the second episode of a two- part mystery, the show uses a grainy live-action segment shaded in red in one scene and a simplistic sketch in another. What I love most about Haruhi Suzumiya is its appreciation of various genres and its change of setting. In episode 1, Haruhi provides a summary of moe (a key element in the school genre) to one of the main characters. In the 1st episode of the two-part mystery, the detective genre and its nuances are fully explained. The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya isn't just a school-oriented series with a touch of mystery. In one episode, the focus is on a baseball tournament. In another, it's about a nerdy computer game (Battleship in space!) that Haruhi and her gang venture into. More often than not, the series transforms into a sci-fi/ philosophical drama, and it's what Haruhi Suzumiya is best at.

This series is a likable one but, unfortunately, it's one with flaws aplenty and the characterization is among its most noticeable faults. The only exceptions are Haruhi (of course) and Kyon, my favorite character. He's an average joe who serves as Haruhi's voice of reason (who she rarely listens to); he mostly voices his opinion with witty sarcasm and often breaks the fourth wall. There's an actual purpose to Haruhi and Kyon being present in the show's plot, unlike the other characters. Yuki Nagato is that one bespectacled female that you seemingly must have in order for an anime to be an anime, the quiet, purple-haired alien who talks in a dull, dry, uninspiring monotone (Getting rid of her glasses is the only change Yuki undergoes in the series). Mikuru is the walking stereotype that I mentioned in the Haruhi paragraph, a warm-hearted, docile, time traveler who's in this show purely for fan-service purposes. Perhaps the most disappointing character of the bunch is Koizumi, an easygoing ESPer who serves as damage control when Haruhi's God-like powers become a problem. For me, he's a fairly interesting character because, every now and then, you could see he's hiding something underneath that permanent smile of his (like the Mole scene during the final moments of the two-part mystery). Unfortunately, The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya never shines the spotlight on Koizumi, which would've made the series a lot better overall, and the other characters (besides Haruhi and Kyon) received the same treatment.

Whatever flaws I found in Haruhi Suzumiya were highlighted by the thoroughly unsatisfying last episode, which (kinda) wrapped up the series in a nice way but failed to resolve the plot's issues. The opening and the wildly popular ending theme aren't all that great. The character designs all appear very similar, especially the females. By themselves, these flaws aren't that big of a deal but, when combined together with the issue mentioned in the previous paragraph, the show overall comes across as a problem. This is a good-but-not-great parody of the school genre with a few truly memorable moments (the classic episode 6, the two-part mystery, and the aforementioned "God Knows" song) but, somewhere along the way, it lost its charm and was unjustly handed a mediocre finale. The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, in the end, was disappointing but at least it stands heads-and-shoulders above the legion of run-of-the- mill school series… and Angel Beats.

I honestly felt exhausted after watching this because like, Haruhi is a character that you bloody can't stand for one minute. She reminds me of some people I know for real and they are a lot worse as she is lol! However despite her being an annoying brat, Kyon was the most likeable character in this series. I really liked Crispin Freeman's narration as well as being the character!

Although I really felt the series could've done better by keeping Haruhi becoming less of an annoying character. That's why I'm giving it a 6/10 rating....

The show started out really excellently. Then it kept interest while you are waiting for the mystery to be solved. Then you are still waiting for the mystery to be solved, as the show just keeps stalling. Then you are still waiting. Then you are still waiting. Then you are still waiting. Finally it becomes obvious the show has no mystery. It just wants to show the daily lives of a group of high schoolers. It's cliche as hell also. Almost every episode, Ive seen in other animes. ABout the time of the repeating summer episode, (which lasts 8 episodes, repeating themselves in a groundhog day type fashion, with only slight variations in dialougue, same animation) I said screw this. It's obvious the show is going nowhere, and quit watching.

Anyways, the show had potential but never delivered on it. I gave the 5 I gave because it was pretty entertaining anyways. But ultimately it felt like it was drug out infinitely, since the entire series could have been done in just a few episodes. The entire rest of the series is filler. One of the few animes I stopped watching half way through. And so angry I wasted my time.

This show is great. Not only is "Haruhai Suzumiya" a very well written anime show, it also reflects things like Philosophy, Science Fiction and a little religion. It's hilarious at some points and "cute" (for lack of a better term) at others. Actually this may be effect to my lack of experience with Japanese anime shows, but it is one of the best of its genre I have seen.

I mainly have to give credit to the writers. I haven't seen such brilliant scopes of imagination in a television show since the original Star Trek. I hope the writers continue to add strange new characters and give more insight on the already great characters that have been added.

9/10

On the surface TMHS appears to be yet another generic high school drama; but surprisingly hidden away underneath is immense amounts of depth, originality and eccentricities that will not only render it unforgettable to the viewer, but also makes it indisputably one of the best animes that the medium has produced in the last few years.

We see the world through the eyes of Kyon, who on his first day of High School meets Haruhi Suzumiya, a girl that boldly claims to the rest of the class she has no interest in 'normal humans' and to top it off casually invites any aliens, time travellers, sliders or espers to meet up with her. Kyon stares in disbelief, wondering if shes joking or has a few screws loose. However defying his gut instincts he begins talking to her. In doing so it soon becomes apparent she isn't some ordinary high schooler. Not to long after, she creates her own aptly named 'SOS Brigade' school club, and drags Kyon amongst other highly unfortunate people to attend.

Nothing in this anime conforms to the usual standard conventions, Kyon the protagonist is an overly cynical pessimist, and contributes a witty narration to the show. A far-cry from the usual 2D male leading characters that tends to populate the medium. The episodes themselves are not chronological,and forces the viewer to think about the events unfolding and how they relate to prior instances. This is a stroke of genius; the effect is like a jig-saw puzzle, as a new piece is layed we get more of a sense of the bigger picture. Previous scenes are now given entire new meanings, and the realization of them are profoundly satisfying. This does mean however that it feels dis-jointed (its anything but), a very cleverly written script has bypassed this problem and ensured that it flows smoothly from start to finish.

The story itself is strikingly original, but I won't delve further than the simple bare-bones plot outline I gave earlier, as it will no doubt spoil it for you. However what I will mention is the plot incorporates a vast array of genres, ranging from comedy to sci-fi. How they managed to accomplish this in the space of fourteen episodes is beyond me, and no doubt a huge achievement in itself.

TMHS is a true gem, which has such diversity and depth that it will appeal to pretty much anyone with an interest in anime. Watch it, rather unusually this is something that lives up to the enormous hype that it has received- and even exceeds it.

Is there anything that compares to Haurhi in modern Japanese animation? Honestly, no. It's such a brilliantly constructed deconstruction of not only Anime, but fiction in general that hits every single note just right. It's a journey, though we rarely travel beyond the school's grounds. Does it have faults? Yes, but only in the most tertiary, unimportant departments. There's no point focusing on them, just as there's no point in delving into the positives. If you like anime, you are essentially required to give this show a viewing, just like Evangelion ten years before.

If you read this review, even if you've already seen the show, please, if you ever cared about me, this random anonymous person on the internet, just please

WATCH THIS IN THE ORIGINAL BROADCAST ORDER.

You can find a guide on Wikipedia. This isn't personal preference or an appeal to tradition, it was deliberately designed to be viewed in that order. Pay attention, use your brain, and I promise you the experience is 10x more rewarding.

A very strange and interesting show. Some parts I really did enjoy and some not so much. Some characters seem to have a lot of depth while other are shallow. I can imagine this being really great when it was released, I probably would have liked it more as a teenager.

Review Date: 2013

Haruhi Suzumiya = 7.8 "Uniquely Delightful"

animation was great, art was ok, soundtrack was mediocre but lovable, story was pretty great, the narrative was great, characters were good, and it was very yet inexplicably original.

The series was consistently fun and charming, telling a relatively unique supernatural/highschool story with metaphysical themes about perception and God with a silly and stretched yet truly intriguing premise, tying it all together in a way that I find hard to describe. A phenomenal series that currently holds the place of my second favorite anime, if we pretend season 2 never happened. I'd give it an 8, but season 2 was a piece of sh**, and I mean sh**. With the exception of season 2, it's more than likely I will be rewatching this series over and over again. Pure happiness.

This show really challenged my patience, and I typically consider myself to be a really patient viewer. I forced myself to watch all 9 seasons of The Flash, so I'm no stranger to toughing it out through slogs. I did like quite a bit about this show when it was first starting, and after finishing it that opinion still holds true. Some of the character moments can be really fun, and when they are acting likeable I found myself really enjoying the show. Unfortunately that is not most of the time, as I though the main character Haruhi was unbearable about 80% of the time. Her treatment of her "friends", particularly Mikuru Asahira, is abysmal and even disgusting at times, and I personally didn't enjoy watching those interactions. The show doesn't do a good job of explaining why she acts this way either, basically saying that she can do whatever she wants and everyone just has to go along with it. Am I supposed to just accept and like that explanation?

I realize there is a movie that follows this show that may explain Haruhi more, but I won't give this show credit for that if that is the case. When I'm watching a show, I should not be expected to watch or read anything outside of that show to explain what's going on. You can have extra media like that to enhance the original content, but it cannot cover up for it. I also thought there was way too much narration. Often what was being said wasn't entirely important, and sometimes it was difficult to tell when Kyon was speaking to someone or just narrating/thinking to himself. It was done to such a degree that I'm positive that as a viewer I have a stronger connection to and understanding of Kyon than anyone else in the main cast does, and I know that was not the intention.

And of course I have to mention the Endless Eight episodes, which for those who haven't seen the show yet is the same episode shown eight times in a row with the slightest of differences. I don't give any merit to those differences, and I cannot believe this show got away with doing this. That was just about the laziest way to fill an 8 episode slot I have ever seen. As horribly written the final seasons of The Flash were, at least each episode was uniquely written. I don't think there's a justification anyone could give that could make me forgive this. If you are going to watch this show, I implore you to only watch Endless Eight I and Endless Eight VIII. The tiny differences in each episode are not important and do not justify watching each one. Please save yourself the time.

There was more with the show that bothered me, but what I have mentioned were the main things. I do not recommend this show at all; I think it just has far too much wrong with it. I do plan on watching the movie, as well as the Nagato spinoff show just because I'm a completionist.