Olivia and Sarah are hoping to make a routine stop to retrieve Sarah's favorite sweatshirt from her ex-boyfriend's house. But when Jeff shows no interest in complying with this reasonable request, they are forced to go head-to-head with the one of Chicago's most despicable exes. Jeff takes the sweatshirt as his hostage, leaving Olivia no choice but to negotiate the terms of the hoodie's release.
—Jonah Saesan