Beans

Set against the backdrop of the Oka crisis, Beans is a respectful Mohawk teenager applying to go to an exclusive private school. She tries to find her way with new friends as the external situation heats up around her.

It's a compelling coming of age story and a compelling true history story. It's the marrying of the two that the film does struggle from time to time. It feels like the movie is trying to hit all the points of the crisis. Each incident is specifically linked to the real world footage. I don't know if this is based on a real person. I do sense a writer connecting the dots of the story. Beans is a compelling character and she has quite a personal journey. This is a compelling film.

Based on a true events from the life of director/co-writer Tracey Deer: in the summer of 1990, the town of Oka, Quebec has allowed an expansion of a golf course to be built on sacred burial grounds of the First Nations Mohawk people. Tekehentakhwa aka Beans (played by Kiawentiio Tarbell) is a pre-teen Mohawk whose coming-of-age is greatly tainted by the battle of her people against nearby locals and the police.

This film is a very welcome account of one of the worst periods in recent Canadian history. The fact that it is personal makes it even more welcome.

Deer shows great skill especially in filming some very grueling battle/conflict scenes. The personal stories, though, have a somewhat mixed result. Scenes of Beans' emulation of a pair of older neighbourhood siblings (a rough girl and her attractive brother, also rough) are sometimes unconvincing and uncomfortable. But the scenes of her family (parents and a younger sister) are always deeply moving. They cover life's usual growing pains that are exacerbated by the conflict and the exposure of a wicked prejudice. And they are highlighted by the solid performance of Rainbow Dickerson who plays Beans' mother, Lily. Lily is the central force of the family and in her community especially in a scene when she gathers other women in a bold, courageous act that prevents a disaster. Dickerson has all that it takes in her portrayal of this major character and life-force.

The use of historical news footage of the conflict is very powerful. So is the mention of the fact that some locals were in economic hardship as a result of the blockades while not using this an excuse for terrible actions. This is also a very timely film considering recent discoveries of past horrors involving Canadian residential schools and the cruel treatment of the late Joyce Echaquan at a Quebec hospital.

Relevant and powerful. - dbamateurcritic.

I stopped watching about 2/3 through. The mom, in an overwrought scene, had shortly before driven through the gauntlet of stone-throwing, white yahoos while the police (SQ?) merely watched. But what made me throw in the towel was the way the filmmaker chose to develop the "friendship" between Beans and her rougher peers. That didn't work for me at all. I'm assuming those youthful relationships and the incipient awakening of the heroine from a protected innocence was meant as a metaphor for First Nations society, but I don't know.

The lack of nuance in the storytelling and a lack of historical footage that captured the racism encountered in the course of daily life off-reserve, during the blockade prevented me from feeling what I had hoped for.

It is a REALLY good movie.

The child/adolescence point of view is well worked, and, although Beans, her family and other characters did not exist, the Oka situation was real, and was one of the many ugly (to say the list) faces of Canada/Quebec.

But, please, keep in mind that the Oka trouble took place in 1990, and the Mohawks involved hadn't politics, money and other ideologies in mind.

They just wanted their sacred ground to be respected.

Exactly the opposite of some groups nowadays.

So, if have stomach to see some ugly scenes of violence and discrimination against peacefull people, watch it.

This is an interesting movie as it blends a few things together while being set during a real life event. Apparently in 1990 there was almost a war between 2 tribes and the province of quebec. Never heard of it until now, but it is real.

Beans which is the nickname for the main character (because her name is not pronounceable - running joke of the movie) navigates this period with her family as she tries to sort her social life and future school priorities. It is part coming of age movie, part canadian WACO documentary, part adventure movie, part drama.

It blends it all well. There is some usage of original footage of the actual confrontations and then they filmed some parts fresh to show the stand offs. It is impossible to merge the two seamlessly so the original archive footage stands out awkwardly, but does add a nice touch to the realism i would say. I know what they were trying to do and I appreciate the effort. Overall it works.

The acting is good from everybody, i just wish the parents were more involved. It seems they rushed through their scenes quite obviously and it makes the father mother rapport dry and unconvincing, especially in light of what is going on.

The movie does have a few darker scenes which i was surprised they went with, and i don't want to spoil what they are - but obviously they went for realism and it worked. It gives the movie a more serious tone for sure but perhaps could have gone deeper into it. It really needed another 30 minutes of runtime to polish all the scenes they put in. Scenes were great as i said they covered a lot of topics and issues, just feels really rushed on all corners.

7\10 the war you never heard of.