Episode list

Catarina gets a bump on the head, and remembers her past life. Now realizing her role in the setup, she plans to avoid all the routes that lead to doom, starting with helping her stepbrother Keith and her fiance Geordo.

Catarina befriends her rival Mary and her fiance's brother Alan.

Catarina befriends Sophia Ascart, a fan of romance novels, and her handsome brother Nicol.

Catarina enters a magical academy.

Catarina visits the home of her nemesis, Maria Campbell, to see what she is like.

Everyone enjoys their summer vacation.

Sophia has a dream about Atsuko Sasaki, Catarina's friend in the real world who was saddened by her sudden death. As part of their practical exams, everyone is tasked with entering a dangerous dungeon for a magic stone, with Catarina on a team with Geordo, Keith, and Sophia. During the chaos of one of the dungeon's traps, which Catarina sets off by accident, Catarina ends up falling down into a hidden passage, where she unknowingly finds the magic stone while harvesting mushrooms. Guided by Nicol's wind magic, Sophia comes to Catarina's rescue when she almost falls off a cliff-side, upon which they are both saved by a mysterious whirlwind. As the rest of the group joins them, Maria notices a dark presence clinging to Catarina.

While studying in the library, Catarina and several others get sucked inside a magic book. Mary and Maria find that the only way to free them is to let one of them fulfill their desires within the book world, but Mary is unable to let them play out to the end since they all involve everyone hitting on Catarina. Realizing that none of the stories have involved Catarina's desire, the two let a scenario play out in which Catarina gets to eat sweets, a desire that proves too much for the book to contain, freeing everyone as a result.

As Catarina and the girls hold a slumber party to celebrate passing their exams, her maid Anne Shelley notices everyone's feelings towards Catarina that she herself is oblivious of. A flashback reveals how Anne, the daughter of Baron and his maid, was scarred in a fire that took her mother's life and was deemed unfit for marriage by her father. Upon joining the Claes family, she originally tried to act as merely a tool until Catarina's personality changed following her accident, after which she learned to be herself. When Anne's father tried to marry Anne off, Catarina stood up to him and convinced him to call the marriage off and let Anne stay by Catarina's side. On another day, Geordo has high expectations upon receiving a fancy invitation from Catarina, only to discover she had invited everyone to help harvest her crops. When winter arrives, Catarina is confronted by someone who claims she will expose her evil deeds.

Mimicking the judgment event from the game where she is subjugated for her crimes, Catarina is accused of bullying Maria, but Maria and the others vouch for her innocence (and slightly insulting her). Although Catarina is relieved that she has evaded a major doom flag, Maria goes missing after investigating a dark aura coming off the instigators. Three days later, Geordo discovers that the list of "evidence" the instigators used against Catarina wasn't actually written by them, and that they themselves have no memory of why they accused her. He suspects that they were being manipulated by dark magic, with Maria's ability to detect leading to her capture. Recalling what she remembered about a hidden character from the game who possessed dark magic, Catarina soon realizes that the true culprit is student council president Sirius Dieke, who declares his hatred towards Catarina and traps her with his dark magic. But as she succumbs to the spell, she notices that his face seems more sad than hateful.

A young school girl wakes up to find that she is late for school. Today, she is meeting with her best friend to talk about her quest to conquer the dark-hearted Prince Geordo Stuart.

Sirius, whose real name is revealed to be Raphael Walt, explains how Marchioness Dieke, mother of the real Sirius who was sick, had a mage kill his mother to acquire dark magic and transfer Sirius' memories into his body, before murdering him to keep him quiet. Gaining dark magic alongside Sirius' memories while retaining his own, Raphael swore to get revenge on the one who killed his mother. Reminded of his mother's kindness thanks to Catarina's help, Raphael learns that the true dark magic was the mage that possessed him following his death and finally manages to drive him out. Afterwards, Raphael leaves the school to atone for his sins while Marchioness Dieke is brought to justice. At the 2nd year graduation party, the setting of the final event of the game where Maria is supposed to confess to one of the romance interests, Catarina finds herself greeted with what she believes to be a friendship ending, remaining oblivious that she's actually the focus of a reverse harem ending. With Raphael joining the Department of Magic and becoming another one of Catarina's admirers, Catarina looks forward to a life that goes beyond what is covered in Fortune Lover.