The Juche Idea

Basically Juche is the concept from the Dear Leader which details how propaganda films must be structured, for maximum effectiveness and artistic value. He wrote a series of guidelines which remain today. The premise of the film is supposed to be a bunch of commune-types get together to make modern day film using these guidelines.

I just didn't get this one. I did enjoy other films about the DPRK, such as Kimjongilia. Learning about their culture and oppression is fascinating. I recently watched another DPRK Borat-style documentary, Red Chapel, which follows the adventures of a real Dutch film maker and his two handicapped friends that put on a comedy show in Pyongyang. Hard to believe that one really happened, but it did. Red Chapel, while hard to watch at times, at least made more sense. But, this one was hard to follow. Was it a mockumentary? Was it a student film that some senior made at RIT? I am still honestly not sure.

"Creativity is an attribute of social man who transforms the world and shapes his destiny purposefully and consciously. By virtue of his creativity, man transforms nature and society to be more useful and beneficial to him by changing the old and creating the new." It doesn't sound too controversial. The artist can consciously or unconsciously influence the world, for good or bad. It may be to uphold or challenge social norms, such as marriage and family values. Or it may be more political, to give moral support to the troops or propound a specific ideology. When combined with a culture of censorship, whether legally-enforced or effected by market and cultural hubris, the effect is greatly multiplied.

Extreme cases of Marxist or Nazi propaganda are offensive to Western sensibilities, but the issue is rarely discussed in depth unless forced upon us.

Take the repressive regime of North Korea. The quotation at the beginning of this review is part of the official ideology called Juche (pronounced choo-CHAY). Reading the philosophy of Juche, one cannot but be impressed by its noble purpose. Its infusion of moral goodness into the arts. It's wondrous leadership potential. So how is North Korea seemingly so inescapably f*cked up? Jim Finn's awkwardly placed film is unsettling by its approach as well as its subject matter. It seems to be a documentary about a media studies student completing a residency in North Korea. How did she get there? Her background is mixed. Having spent her formative years in South Korea, and time in America before settling in Japan. Her work on arts projects and video has enabled her to secure a place in a North Korean establishment where she learns to make films in accordance with Juche.

Her own political views are very mixed. The US is "always invading or threatening to invade someone." She finds some good ideas, from a technical point of view, in Juche Theory, but struggles to implement them to her tutor's standards. She must try harder to make films that "speak to the workers" and not to an "artistic elite." Her underlying objective is to learn about and then give a true idea of Juche and its role in the development of cinematic ideas.

The North Korean academics are equally interested in her work in 'capitalist' countries. What's it like, making a film there? Like building your own boat on a bay, she says. People are very helpful and contribute timber and advice. But when it's launched no-one notices cos they're all watching the cruise ship spread its bilge. About Kim Jong Il (who is apparently a film fanatic, not just a despot), she explains that, in the West, "of course, he's stereotyped – with some basis in reality." But even as I was appreciating the remarkable insight into a closed kingdom, I still had doubts. How did all this filming get in – and then get out again? Who exactly was this student? It felt as if I had missed an essential first five minutes.

But I hadn't. The film is a re-creation, or serious mockumentary, with original footage produced entirely within the USA. Added to the confusing mix are avant-garde techniques and language lesson videos ('English as a Capitalist Language' and 'English as a Socialist Language'). Does this reduce its value? Perhaps not. Clips of mass celebration dances are from official North Korean sources. The quotations from Juche, frequently appearing on the screen, are authentic. Travelogue it ain't. Off-beat study of an off-beat cinematic closed circuit it certainly is.

In the mid 60's, Kim Jong Il adapted his father's Juche philosophy to propaganda, film and art. Translated as self-reliance, Juche is like a mixture of Confucian and authoritarian Stalinist pseudo-socialism. Excellence in film themes and stories is judged partly on how well they portray Juche, since this is unquestioningly accepted as the most enlightened approach. For instance, "conflicts should always be settled in accordance with the law of class struggle." Or, "There are no negative people in socialist society." Its high-minded (if rather arrogant) approach reminds me a little of the Hays Code (censorship guidelines) that governed US film-making from 1934 to 1968. Except that the moral code of Juche seems to be universally respected within North Korea (And it does also look very much more philosophically coherent than the rather patchwork Hays Code). Certain precepts seem almost to contain a Judeo-Christian crossover: "A negative person must always be led to repent of his mistake and take the right road." It would be easy to become enraptured of Juche Idea, even if it is a bit restrictive. Examples of good poetry and good cinema seem to suggest that it works. The sad reality is that, like communism, it sounds great but is a disaster in practice. The concentration on 'message' eventually makes for sameness in even the most colourful of creations.

One of the most dramatic state clips is of 'Flesh Ring in Sea of Blood.' (Sea of Blood is a North Korean expression for capitalist aggression.) My overall feeling was that North Korea is not as unsophisticated as we might think. That we tend to trivialise or stereotype it just as it stereotypes us. The film seems to be a very worthwhile project that at least scratches the surface. Yet it also gets a bit monotonous and its ambiguous 'documentary' status niggled me throughout. It is also an unusual and chic example of how elegant ideology bears no resemblance to the reality upon which it has inflicted itself.

When the end credits roll (including, notably, a shout out to Pauline Oliveros and her collaborator as purveyors of "Capitalist Music") it becomes evident that one has been watching a mockumentary, not a proper doc. All the scenes in the "artists' collective" and the "science fiction film" were shot in Rochester! Frankly, I resent wasting my time watching this comedy masquerading as a documentary, when my prior knowledge of the essentially tragic subject of the state of the arts in North Korea and its context - gained simply from watching the far more serious and easily far superior work "Kimjongilia" - goes well beyond anything offered by The Juche Idea. Watch that film, you'll immediately grasp that to depict the HK media in a harsh light, no lampooning/exaggeration on the part of a madcap auteur is necessary.

The films' lowest points are certainly these idiotic English language lessons on tape presenting dialog cutting between 2 ineptly matched shots featuring a heavily accented Korean speaker and an utterly zombie-like Russian 'actor', about as articulate in English as the Frankenstein monster. This is satire? It strikes me as pretty lame, not terribly funny and certainly not worth trotting out at intervals some 3 or 4 times. Or, or...was this entracte of language tapes one of the sections of real "found footage"? One can't be sure once the 'mixed bag' nature of the film's sources is revealed at the very end. This brings us to the most critical question of all: at this point, who the hell cares?!

The fictional artist in residence upon whom the film centers, with her experimental-toned-down-to-slightly-expressionistic bent, would hardly find support in NK. And it rather bothered me that her intelligence as a character seems pretty pronounced but then she produces laughably unintelligent attempts at Juche film and poetry. Not that such people don't exist, in droves, my dear. East, west, north, south shoot the artist holding forth, shoot the art: instant comedy/satire will result in discouraging quantities... Why fake this?

So, I have to give this film a really low rating since I presume Mr. Finn isn't going to follow this up with mockery of art in the west, which is the only way "The Juche Idea" might... come to achieving any context justifying its existence, as far as I'm concerned.

SKIP THIS AND WATCH "KIMGJONGILIA" which is a far more significant film. You'll get plenty "hilarity" at the expense of 'the Juche thing', but set off, not with strained attempts to amp up the laff riot aspect, but rather with sobering material about real peoples' miserable experiences and the day to day political backdrop of this tragic Kingdom of Kim Jong deifying Kitsch. All "the Juche idea" really adds to this is some exposure of a number of predictable, not terribly fascinating soundbites from the "film theory" writings of Kim Jong Il.