Harry is forced out of his auto repair shop by some mysterious, unnatural force that invades his space. After countless loops through Winterbourne he is struck with his inevitable fate.
Gerard is horribly smitten with Sarah, the girl next door, but racks his brain trying to work up the courage to say hello. One day after her dog escapes onto his yard, Gerard is given the perfect opportunity.
The town's new Reverend visits the cemetery to find that it has been damaged and disheveled. The groundskeeper reassures him in order to maintain a grim secret.
Olivia is a photographer who is unable to appreciate the beauty in the world the way she once did. She begins to feel as though she is being followed. Rather than letting fear consume her, she decides to embrace it.
Marie appoints her loving husband Richard to invite the neighbours over for dinner. When the evening arrives and Marie's signature lasagna is on the table, it is no wonder why the neighbours are unsettled.
Ella visits her aunt Catherine, a hoarder and stubborn recluse, to try and persuade her from her troublesome way of living. Ella quickly learns that the situation is far beyond either of their control.
In the season finale, Reverend Taylor prays alone in his church, but is interrupted by a dreadfully persistent visitor and a deep-rooted, lingering question.
