Review by timothycormack

I'm a fan of the books, and I love the various characters in Three Pines. This series has not given us any backstory, any character for the residents. Hell, most of them haven't even been named as of the fourth episode. Gabri and Olivier are even miscast as each other! The thing that makes this series of books wonderful is the deep interaction and relationships of the various characters. The murders are almost secondary to the character development.

This series has potential, though. Alfred Molina is great, and I'm enjoying the portrayal of Jean-Guy and Isabelle. I just hope to see some character growth from the others. Clara, Peter, Myrna, Olivier and Gabri need some screen time, too. And dialogue. And, you know, names that are said out loud.

The relationship between Gamache and Jean-Guy is essential. We've barely touched on the Gamache/Isabelle dynamic, and Clara (sweet, wonderful Clara) hasn't had enough screen time to have a chance, yet.

I'll keep watching, because I love these people. I hope the writing gets better, and soon. (and maybe stick a little closer to the books that inspired the series? I mean, they're good for a reason.)