The first story in Creepy Valentine titled Nginep, tells of a student named Igra (Chicco Kurniawan) who goes to stay at his friend's boarding house, Vicko (Hifzane Bob), because he comes home too late after playing futsal.
tells the story of Leia (Maeva Schilinger), a novice climber who climbs the mountain with her four friends, namely Jaka (Haniv Hawakin), Antia (Aina Nisa), Ramie (Rekaldi), and Tussa (Nagra Pakusadewo).
Leia woke up in a tent belonging to a man she didn't know. Even though they were suspicious, in the end the two of them became acquainted. The man named Irsad, a senior climber who volunteered to save lost climbers.
tells the story of a couple named Lolita and Tristan who want to celebrate Valentine's Day together. Lolita, who had planned a romantic dinner with Tristan, was surprised when Tristan took her away long before dinner.
In the second part, Lolita is still waiting for Tristan to come home from the workshop, hoping that his car can take them back to Jakarta. The quiet and tense atmosphere of the villa made him uncomfortable
tells the story of Fadil, a man who had just been dumped by his lover, Kiara. Fadil, who feels shocked and sad, loses his zest for life and continues to be haunted by the memory of Kiara.
In the second part, Creepy Valentine: Disturbed shows the character of Fadil who is terrorized by an old grandmother. Since defecating in the forest, he kept seeing the creepy figure everywhere, even on the television screen.