From Hilde, with Love

Not watching this! I actually recommend watching this, so no pun intended as always. We can only imagine how it must have been - although you do have countries where .... well there is one form of dictatorship or another ... if you feel I attacked the country you are living in - well that is on you. As in don't blame me for what you perceive to be your truth or what you feel to be true - my words are kept to a minimum. Just saying.

And I am not tip toeing around anything for any specific reason - as in I don't expect to get the treatment our main character is getting here. I'd hope that does not happen - to anybody ... but again we have seen things happening lately .. so there is a crazy world out there.

Which makes this an important watch I assume ... and powerful ... even if not easy to watch! What would you do? Not easy to answer.

This is a movie to love but, at the same time, it's one that's very hard for any reasonably sensitive person to watch. I thought that Liv Lisa Fries in the lead role as Hilde Coppi was really quite excellent. I hadn't seen her in any other productions before this one and I was prompted to look at other work she's done and which I might also value.

"From Hilde, With Love", original German title "In Liebe, Eure Hilde" reminded me very much of another German movie "Sophie Scholl: The Final Days" which starred another remarkably good German actress named Julia Jentsch. Obviously the theme of both movies is very similar and the denouement identical. I'm sure I was not alone in thinking and hoping that the resolution of Hilde's case might have been different to Sophie's. Alas, no.

This movie, like Sophie Scholl, reinforces, if that were necessary, just how terrifying life must have been under the rule of the Nazis, where any action at all that might be construed as harmful to "the State" could lead to suffering and worse.

"From Hilde, With Love" is a quite excellent movie and one which I might try to watch again at some time although that will be difficult for me.

8 out of 10 from me.

JMV.

I found this a really riving watch. I have a history with radical movements, and I found a lot of similarities in terms of the way the group dynamics played out with the resistance members. What was really surprising is the tactful way that the 'ordinary life' of many of the average or upper-middle class Germans faced, with the exception of the war hanging over everybody's head.

The portrayal of some of the more sympathetic members of the German state apparatus was really well done as well. They respected a number of her wishes (despite initially bleating out that things were just 'the rules'), and responded well to the perfectly reasonable requests of the characters.

The ending was jarring in a good way, and left me sat in my seat in the cinema even after the credits had finished. Very moving and inspiring, despite being considered 'not a date night film' by the people sat behind me.

Who would expect a film set in 1942 Nazi Germany about a group of resistance fighters to be cheerful? But this film, based on true events, is compelling if at times confronting. Hilde is a young, pregnant woman who with her husband is caught with an illegal radio transmitter and is eventually sentenced to death. Through flashbacks the film tells the story of the couple meeting and the attempts at resistance they and their friends undertake. Oddly, these flashbacks do move around in time, mostly but not always moving further back, but it's always clear where the viewer is. Once caught, Hilde's prison experience is at times confronting, but I really appreciated that most of the prison staff are not presented one dimensionally but with touches of humanity as well. As noted in the details in IMDB, the film concludes with a few words from her son, born in prison and now 80. Overall, the acting, the cinematography and the editing are properly subservient to the storytelling so that only in retrospect does one realise how effective they are.

The film tells a story of a group of young, reasonably well off and naive people, who fought the NAZI by trying to help USSR. However, as said by Hilde's son Hans, a German historian, after the war, many Nazi officers who participated in the torture and killing of those fighters were never prosecuted but joined the West German military, while his parents and other continued to be treated as traitors till 2008. That makes you wonder whether they were heroes fighting for freedom, or victims in the geopolitical conflicts played by the people in power.

In the film, all of the people in Nazi machines, the secret police , the prison guards, the hospital staff, the judges, were humane, kind and sympathetic. I am not sure how well this reflects the historical truth. Prison systems across the world were cruel in those days. Was Hilde just lucky to be treated humanely, or was it the filmmaker's desire of not hurting this beautiful soul, on the big screen?

Looking at the conflicts today that are killing so many people in the name of glorious goals, I wonder whether humans are really capable of learning. This film tells such a story that makes some of us think and see the wars differently.