Episode list

When Ann Beaton is murdered in Orwell Rear in 1859, a shock runs through the small community. A jury of twelve local men is formed to formally determine what happened and the local coroner also discovers some crucial evidence as he performs an autopsy.

After Ann Beaton's body is discovered, an investigator is sent to Orwell Rear to interview members of the community and identify a suspect. A search is commenced for evidence and arrests are made. The original investigation documents from J.R. Bourke are dramatized by actors.

There are multiple accounts of the only recorded witch burning on Prince Edward Island in 1721. The investigation starts with a version written by Helen Jean Champion in 1939 in her book "Over on the Island". Each version reveals layers of legend and surprising details from the 18th and 19th centuries.

When Mary Tuplin is murdered in 1887, it creates a media sensation on Prince Edward Island. Few murder cases in Island history have been surrounded by as much sensationalism. The investigation, arrest and trial are all brought to life in dramatized scenes taken directly from the newspaper reporting of the day.

Yeo House was built by James Yeo, who at that time was the wealthiest man on Prince Edward Island. Today the house is a museum and host to dozens of stories of haunting and unexplained paranormal events. One of those stories have to do with a toy called, Wheelie, discovered in the walls of the house.

Prince Edward Island has seen many ships go down over the last few centuries around its coastline. A storyteller relates the tale of the doomed Fairy Queen from 1853. A story of an Acadian ghost on Point Prim is also told as well as tales of the phantom ship of the Northumberland Strait.