Halls of Stone

The fifth episode of the second season of *The Rings of Power* was absolutely incredible. And I say that as someone who has been a fan of Tolkien's work for a long time, who grew up immersed in the richness of Middle Earth. Yes, I recognize the series' mistakes and flaws - because, like any fan, I'm demanding. But it's undeniable that this episode brought something great. The creation of the Rings of Men was approached in a profound and visually spectacular way, as few could do.

Now, what really bothers me is the number of people who keep complaining that the series "doesn't follow the books". Really? Since when did the movies do that? *The Rings of Power never promised to be an exact copy of Tolkien's works, and for anyone who knows anything about adaptations, that's obvious. If you want something faithful to the books, then go and re-read them. What the series is doing is taking the essence of Tolkien and transforming it into something visually and narratively great.

The second season, for me, is far superior to the first. I'm the first to admit that the series had problems at the beginning, but what we're seeing now is a clear evolution. This fifth episode was a masterpiece in every sense: the dialog, the narrative, the visuals. Of course, there are things I wish were different - like any fan, I have my preferences. But to say that the series is bad, as some do? That's short-sighted.

I'm extremely curious to see how this season will end. If it continues at this pace, the finale has everything it takes to be epic. Anyone who can't see the greatness of this episode, or of the whole series, is probably stuck with unrealistic expectations and can't appreciate an adaptation for what it is.

This episode shows what the show could have been if it had ditched the ridiculous Harfoot storyline. Once it can focus on the stories of Elvendom, Sauron and Numenor - the epic stories - it unfolds its full potential. I really wish the showrunners had not intertwined so many different storylines instead of concentrating on a few like they did in this episode. I feel like they felt the fans would miss the Hobbits too much, so they included the abomination that is the Harfoots. Its a shame because the set design and acting are amazing and my biggest fear is going back to the Harfoots and pseudo-Gandalf in the next episode.

This is the frist episode that truly felt like a Lord of the Rings adaptation to me. I liked season 1 and season 2 so far but that Episode just raised the bar. The tention througout is brilliantly crafted. Saurons decieving is masterfully written.

The structure of this episode is way better than before and it focuses on the main themes in this season. The lack of a certain storyline does help this matter a lot.

It resonates with the charchters and you will actually feel for them. A task the show was lacking a bit as of now. For me by far the best episode of the whole series. If the continue like that for this season and the coming ones. My god we are in for a ride.

Halls of Stone is a marked improvement on the previous episode, with some stunning sequences and captivating scenes, but can't quite fully escape the weaker points of the Rings of Power.

It was always going to be a challenge to condense source material which takes place over hundreds of years into a short timescale, and I would have preferred the show to take place over a much longer timescale to give us a much stronger feeling of the immortality of elves and differing lifetimes of Dwarves and men (including those from Numenor), but this episode does a much better job of condensing events in a coherent way than Rings of Power has done previously.

There's far fewer line lifts from elsewhere given to characters here and fewer out of place Easter eggs. I appreciated that. There's a stronger feeling of it's own identity here, and I think the show is stronger for it.

This episode really gave the series some momentum going forward now with some of the action and thrill of the characters becoming more serious to the reality of what's happening with the rings. Took a season and a half to get us here but fingers crossed the show kicks on now and shows its true potential.

Hoping that the remainder of the season will show some clever decisions from our lead characters in order to work together to fight against Sauron and not to be mislead over and over (Calabrimbor).. hoping the High King will listen to his council and send Aid to the ones who will need the help of the elves.