Dial S for Santa

These movies are a particular guilty pleasure for me. There are few that I haven't seen. The stories vary only a little but I always manage to enjoy the comfort in that, while doing various Christmas tasks or just enjoying a fire.

Unfortunately I found this one painful, not due to the story but the acting of the main character. I haven't seen her in other films. She definitely needs more experience and training before taking on a leading role like this. She was very stiff and not at all like the usual calibre for this type of film. I usually at least manage to feel some connection to, or affection for the main character but this actress' monotone and flat delivery made this impossible.

Insurance investigator Lana Lawton (Sarah Dugdale) returns home to visit her mom who owns a Christmas store on main street. Someone broke in. There has been a spree of small robberies. Policeman Nick Fallon (Julian Haig) is on the case where few crimes are committed. The store has hired Kris Kringle to be the store Santa, but Lana tells her nephew that he's not the real Santa.

The town needs to be smaller. This needs to be one street of small stores. Otherwise, I like the premise and the mysteries. This is Hallmark's Christmas in July. The investigation stalls around the middle and so does the movie. I do like the Santa suspicion. She could do more like comically stalking Santa. On the other hand, I don't like her talking down on her mom. I really don't like her sex-shaming her mom. Writers need to stop doing that even if the character learns a lesson. She is a fine lead although the guy needs a bit more time at the beginning. Finally, I have an issue with the final act. This is mostly fine.

I've watched a lot of Christmas movies and this one was hard to watch and I held out hope for the end but it never got better. Sarah was simply unbelievable. There were no feelings or emotions developed. Not realistic at all and by the end there was no feel good emotions connected to the story. The best acting was by the robber and the friends back at the office. Ugh!!! Even the relationship between mom and the new man was void of feelings. The engagement ring scene was completely unbelievable. Mom's reaction to her daughter ruining a monumental event was flat. Maybe the script wasn't good enough. Not sure. But the development of the characters left a lot to be desired. Especially applicable with Lana.... No real believability.

Lana Lawton (Sarah Dugdale) is the most unlikable lead character in any Christmas-themed movie I have ever seen, including Scrooge or the Grinch.

I'm amazed she hasn't been fired as an investigator. She is driven to become 'Lead Investigator' but lacks any basic skill at investigation. Yes, she likes to snoop, but she jumps to conclusions without any proof at all and seems to think that her first thought is Gospel.

OK, the idea is that she is an curmudgeonly idiot who finds redemption, but any lead character has to have *some* redeeming characteristics to start with or we just don't care what happens to them.

The other characters are all likable and believable, which just makes Lana seem even more odious.

I rarely take the time to review a Hallmark movie - they are lighthearted entertainment so my expectations are not too high but they are usually pretty reliable. However, the main character Lana (played by Sarah Dugdale) ruins what would otherwise be a decent movie. Her acting is so terrible...like really really terrible. I really hope Hallmark doesn't hire her again. It is sad to hear they are getting rid of some of the older actresses that can actually act in favor of young actresses like this one that ruin their movies. Her voice is like nails on a chalkboard. I couldn't even make it to the end because of her.