Nicole gets a new roommate--her estranged father Hank, who tells us in no uncertain terms that he looks to be Nicole's own age on account of his Benjamin Button's Disease. Tiffany has qualms.
Nicole and Hank learn the true meaning of Christmas and Hannukah as they celebrate with Chelsea, Nicole's mother and Hank's ex-wife, and Nicole's old roommate, Tiffany, as well as a mystery guest.
When his dating life takes a turn for the worse, Nicole encourages Hank to accept the things he cannot change. Instead, Hank gets a procedure where they break his legs and set them several inches apart so that he can finally be five-foot-nine.