Review by IKC-4

The Sinners is a 2020 Canadian indie thriller directed by Courtney Paige. The film centers on seven high school girls, each embodying one of the seven deadly sins, who form a secret club. Their bond unravels when a murder investigation begins to expose their dark secrets, leading to a suspenseful exploration of guilt, jealousy, and retribution.

Critics have offered mixed reviews. Jennie Kermode of Eye for Film praised the film, stating, "The Sinners plays the part so well that you'd be forgiven for thinking it was just more of the usual, but this is Courtney Paige's film, and she's taking it somewhere very different." Conversely, Mae Abdulbaki of Screen Rant criticized the film, noting that sin and religion "clumsily hold together a story with not much to say."

The film's aesthetic has drawn comparisons to The Craft, blending elements of teen slasher and crime thriller genres. However, some reviewers have pointed out tonal inconsistencies, with moments that feel surreal juxtaposed against scenes reminiscent of high-school dramas like Riverdale. Despite these critiques, The Sinners has been recognized for its bold approach to themes of sexuality, religion, and revenge.

In summary, The Sinners offers a unique take on the thriller genre, with its blend of horror elements and teen drama. While it may not resonate with all viewers, it presents an intriguing narrative for those interested in exploring its themes.