A little girl and a young woman go missing years apart and one man, Hadden Clark, is connected to both; in prison, Clark confesses gruesome details of a murderous life after he starts to believe his new cellmate is Jesus Christ.
A six-year-old girl vanishes without a trace from her backyard; fifteen years later, a man confesses gruesome details of a murderous life after he starts to believe his new cellmate, a convicted murderer, is Jesus Christ.
A young woman vanishes into thin air after returning home from college; as detectives investigate, they uncover evidence of a brutal crime, revealing a suspect with connections to a previous case.
Jack keeps playing the role of Jesus for Hadden, who spills more of his brutal life story through words, writings and cryptic artwork; Jack brings in the FBI, they uncover decades of crimes from Hadden and his serial killing family.
Detectives conduct an intense interrogation; Hadden's admissions take a toll on Jesus; the Clark family history of brutality and childhood abuse comes to light, which takes a shocking turn.
Jesus crime comes to light; investigators work with Jesus to pull more information out of Hadden, leading them to other potential crimes, including a unsolved murder; Hadden reveals his surprising partner in crime.
Detectives take Hadden and Jesus on road trips to hunt for bodies and clues, hoping to keep Hadden in jail for good; news of Jesus' fate surfaces; Hadden taunts investigators with the breadth of his cold cases.
