Secret Level

I've always had mixed feelings about anthology series. There's something frustrating about getting invested in an episode only to realize that's all there is to it. You might think the upside is that an anthology won't drag on endlessly, and, well, you'd be right! But still, I find myself craving that deeper connection that longer series offer.

When I heard that "Secret Level" was an anthology based on existing video game IPs, I thought it might be a decent change of pace. I'm a gamer, after all, so I figured I'd feel at home in these familiar universes. And for the most part, I was right - Season 1 of "Secret Level" does a commendable job with its stories, and I found quite a few episodes that really stood out.

The first episode that grabbed my attention featured none other than Arnold Schwarzenegger, who finds himself trapped on an island called Eternia, reliving his demise over and over again. It's a playful twist on the classic "Groundhog Day" concept and has more than a nod to 1950s cinema like "Jason and the Argonauts." I didn't realize which game IP it was based on, but honestly, I didn't even care. Arnold's humor shone through, and the 15-20 minute runtime felt just right. The animation was fantastic too- I could have mistaken it for a high-quality CGI feature.

Another standout was the episode tied to the upcoming game "Exodus." Picture "Interstellar" mixed with rebels in space, and you'll get the idea. The emotional core of this one revolves around a father searching for his daughter over many years, and it left a lasting impact on me. I genuinely can't wait for the game to drop! The voice acting, especially Michael Beach as the father, elevated this episode and added depth to the storyline.

Then there was the segment based on "Armored Core." I've never played it, but wow, I was impressed! It had the makings of a captivating series or movie. Keanu Reeves, typically more stoic, brought out genuine emotion in this role. I couldn't help but feel a nostalgic vibe reminiscent of Renny Harlin or Shane Black films, even if those directors are tangentially related to mechs. The atmosphere was gritty and snowy, adding to the experience.

While a few episodes didn't quite hit the mark for me-like those based on "Sifu" and "Mega Man"-they weren't terrible. They just felt too rushed, particularly "Mega Man." At around five minutes, I expected a punchy story, but it ended feeling more like a tease rather than a satisfying sip of water after a long run.

The finale felt a bit strange, as it seemed to showcase a mix of Sony's IPs, but it also exuded a vibe of uncertainty on how to wrap things up. It was enjoyable, just lacking a smooth conclusion.

Overall, I found "Secret Level" to be a delightful watch. It's the kind of show you can enjoy without needing to dedicate all your attention to it since each episode is a self-contained story. Plus, none of them were outright boring. I give it a solid 8/10 - a fun ride for gamers and casual viewers alike!

A couple of cool episodes aside, Secret Level feels like a monument to mediocrity. The writing is painfully mid, dragging the whole show down despite the undeniably impressive visuals-though even those feel like reheated leftovers from a decade of superior video game cinematics. Honestly, what is this show trying to do or say that hasn't been done (and done better) by video game marketing in the past 10+ years?

The lineup of titles is baffling. Where are the big names? The absence of heavy hitters screams one thing: developers wanted no part of this trainwreck or were waiting to see if Season 1 could stick the landing. Spoiler alert-it didn't.

Short-form storytelling seems to completely elude the creators. What should have been tight, impactful, and memorable comes across as disjointed and uninspired. Variety called it an "uninspired snooze," and for once, Variety wasn't being harsh enough.

Secret Level is proof that flashy visuals can't hide a lack of vision, heart, or originality!

A lot of wasted potential, that's how I would define what happened with "Secret Level", I could also say that it was "Love, death and Robots" but bad.

This Amazon bet, which although it turned out fantastic (record viewing and confirmed a second season), did not seem to me to have lived up to expectations.

It bets only on one type of animation, it hardly experiments and we are only left with hyperrealism, which although it works for some chapters, it is not the solution to everything. Although the comparison with the Netflix series can be annoying, I think it is a great point of support when we evaluate "Secret Level" in general.

Another thing that was not right was dividing the episodes into two batches, with a first part that is far superior to the second in terms of quality and variety. Ending with a totally malicious Play Station advertisement.

When one thinks about the possibilities, the limits are infinite, however, in practice, only 4-5 chapters are rescued at most. Warhammer 40000 is the best episode without a doubt and I suppose I breathe a sigh of relief thinking about the series that Henry Cavill will star in in the future. It looks great, it's impressive, just a few minutes are enough to be inside the franchise.

Unreal Tournament was another episode that I liked, in that fight of the machines for survival against the corporation that wants to destroy them. It gives a little more in terms of the philosophical concept of the machines and their feeling.

The Pac-Man episode, although predictable, I also liked, it experiments with animation and is extremely dark, one of the few in that sense.

Honor of Kings, which has nothing to do with the LOL plagiarism game but has a very interesting background and concept. At the same time, it is the only episode of the second batch that is very good.

I hope that the next season is much better than this one and that great intellectual properties are included and that classics like Megaman are respected, which was a shame here.

Short stories within the setting of video games. Or very loosely based on the setting of the games. Very different games, ranging from Pac-Man to Warhammer 40.000. Even Concord, where I assume the creators have been cursing themselves when seeing what that game ended up being.

It's mainly meh stories about mostly mediocre-at-best games I often have hardly even heard about. The visuals are great though. But except for one or two out outliers there is little substance. I am sure the cutscenes for most of those game were better. Let's not compare this to anthology shows like Black Mirror or Love Death and Robots.

Still. It's made by people that seem to be gamers.

I was really disappointed when I saw critics say this show was just mid. I've watched it and all I can say is most of the critics are wrong. I really enjoyed this show! The episodes could have been longer, that's my only gripe honestly. If you love video games, definitely check this show out. It's a quick watch too. Now I want to go play some of these games again after seeing their episodes. I would imagine the whole point of Secret Level is to attract new players, and in that regard, I think they succeeded. There was heart in a lot of the episodes too, which I also really liked. Hopefully this show does well enough to warrant a season 2. If they do make a season 2, the only thing I think they need to improve upon is the length of the episodes. I really, really wished they were all at least 20 minutes. Overall though, I'm thankful we got this show because video games mean a lot to a lot of people, myself included. Thank you to all of the people who worked hard to bring us this show. You guys rock!