BunzLO

Curiosity Stream's 'The True Story of Pirates' captivates with visually stunning recreations and genuine locations, immersing viewers in the rich tapestry of pirate lore. The documentary seamlessly blends historical narratives with personal accounts and expert insights on weaponry, elevating the depth of the storytelling. However, notable shortcomings arise in its rushed treatment of crucial events, such as the story of William Kidd.

A distinctive yet divisive feature is the documentary's emphasis on on-land archaeology and extended negotiations with Madagascar natives. While offering a unique perspective, these segments may be perceived as diverging from the primary narrative.

Despite these aspects, the documentary earns a solid 8 for its aesthetic appeal and comprehensive historical study. The inclusion of on-land archaeology and negotiations, while divisive, adds a unique layer to the narrative. Although it faces challenges in seamlessly connecting visuals with historical events, 'The True Story of Pirates' remains a commendable choice for those seeking an immersive and informative dive into pirate history on Curiosity Stream.

I found myself on the fence between a 6 or 7 when assessing Netflix's The Lost Pirate Kingdom. Despite its relentless pace and visually enticing portrayal of pirate life, the series falls short in terms of historical authenticity. Questionable reflections from certain experts and the occasional application of modern concepts on historical aspects raise concerns about accuracy.

The series at times appears like a low-budget CGI bluescreen drama, featuring moments of cringe-worthy acting. However, the redeeming quality lies in the general narrative, which remains faithful to historical events. Despite the flaws, The Lost Pirate Kingdom earns a 7 for offering a surprisingly informative piece on Caribbean pirates, delving deep into their intriguing history.