shawnbairefoot

The idea of the crew getting first hand of another species psychology and point of view is novel. However, I do think the episode focused too much on the comedy and did not sufficiently address the struggles.

The acting took away from the story as well. Pike (Anson Mount) reminded me more of a Conehead than a Vulcan. La'an (Christina Chong) could have embrace more of the Romulanesque cold, paranoid, and calculating nature. Chapel (Jess Bush) did a better job of addressing the task centered natured of the Vulcans. Uhura (Celia Gooding) did a superb job of demonstrating the Vulcan arrogance in their beliefs being superior to otheirs.

While it was not a bad episode, there was a lot of potential story left on the table.

This episode tackles current issues in a thought provoking but non-threatening manner. Ortega and her brother deal with her PTSD. It addresses bias in media. There is also the struggle between personal values and orders in hierarchical leadership structures.

The format is a refreshing change and compelling.

Many will needlessly pan this episode after only a superficial look; however, this is a classic Star Trek. Something that should be straightforward and harmless goes haywire. The 'bad' acting was over-the-top and takes a self-deprecating look at the franchise while reaffirming Gene Roddenberry's original intention for Star Trek. It also delves into the crews self-awareness and emotional ties to each other. Also, there were so many Easter eggs to find.