mlatapie-1

This is a great show mainly because of Poppy Montgomery. I loved her earlier show, "Without a Trace", and found her to be an interesting actress with a very expressive and sensitive face which displays many emotions. She is also very soft spoken,not shrill, which is a great change from so many women police in the shows today. It's a good show and Poppy makes it a good show!! I'm not so sure I like the red hair though, I think I preferred the blonde which she was for "Without a Trace"! Keep the show. I'm sure the stories will get better; and Poppy's character will grow and grow with her abilities and mannerisms. This is a winner!!

I was disappointed in this film mainly because I love James Elroy's books and found that this film did not do it justice. The characters in the film became stereotypes or cardboard 40's characters. Scarlett Johannsen looked like a young Lana Turner on tranquilizers.........very little emotion, so much mumbling.............poor Hilary Swank was just too distracting in her black wig trying to be a 40's vamp ...........I guess we are not accustomed to seeing her that way and she evidently does not do well in sexy, seductive roles............Josh Hartnett did pretty well.........although the constant taking off of clothing of his different ladies seemed a bit tiresome......if I would have had this on video I would have fast forwarded the constant "clothes removal" scenes. James Ellroy also wrote LA Confidential and that was a masterpiece on film.........but of course, the actors were Russell Crowe, Kevin Spacey, Danny Divito, and many very well seasoned actors with a far above average script. Sorry to say that this film is not academy award material as LA Confidential was................Ellroy's stories can be told on film with good writing, competent acting, good casting, good screenplay and continuity. This was not present in The Black Dahlia. Actually, the girl who played The Black Dahlia was the most sensitive and sympathetic and portrayed her character excellently.