0 ratings0% found this document useful (0 votes) 200 views8 pagesDetermining Contamination PDF
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
Determining Contamination
Levels
in Hydraulic Systems °
JOHN A. BRIGGS, ASLE
Denly Mechine Corporation, Cler,
Most sumercally controlled machine tals wsing
lectohydautc serwovalees and moore require clean
hydraulic stone if thee acrracy onl relay po
ental are to be waz
‘lushing proetures, fd sampling teciniqus, and
methods of determining predate contamination are
fiscal. Facor infleicing the contamination lve,
limitations of the carows methods of detemining the
particulate contamination ee, ae mons of contamina
ton contol ae ols considered.
rom Mater Goose, we learned about the ltl gi
who “when se was goo she was Very, Hey good, Bat
tren ae as bad She was Roe” The he gi an
‘nonerically controlled machinery have someting in
‘common, for while most af the time the machines are
very. very good” sometimes they eam be "hor
However dee thir inception some Bites years af,
INC machines ae icrensng in ane and thelr FQ i
bright. Controls for NC machioory are. generally all
tlectonie or tome combination of hycrlice and le
Tronics Recent developments Indicate Gat foi
inet ite a al NC cot
‘This paper wil concern lf with one of the problems
rscocated with mcs that-are coutolled by one
Combination of elections andl hydrasies, anda part
fut, with the Bydauie Bul and fe cation tte
tloctohydrlicservovalves, the servovalve boing the
interface between the electronics and te hydaslice
Gerhardt wiete tn connection with problems om NC
snachineryasngelctrohydauliservo that “the problem
‘vasa fol wit the servovalve (1)
"acpi, may 59,1909
{THE BLECTROHYORAULIC SERVOVALVE
“Theva of filtration of bya an Ibrieating ols
Ins been known for some Une. With ore lity and
more precon being demanded of machine tok, the
fnachite ool baler mist build tol with adequate
Tubveation and hydale systems, ad readily serie
thle means af keeping these Buds cee. Tho ast, fhe
‘rants performance a nto the nachines, mt low
1 preventive maintenance program Including such ems
ti changing fiers monitoring the cil condtion, and
‘shen conor warant, changing the ol
‘Because of the many advantages of Bud poser, the
evelopment of the electobydrelicservovaves Was
Dioner by the aerospace indy. The high eliblty
te performance demanded of srra, rockets ard as
‘Gata equip required clean fuids andthe means to
Keep the fds clean wheter the fds are for ue,
for lirication, or for power tsnision. Government
tgencies SAE, ASTM, and eer group have doveloped
povedes for determining the amount of patcuate
Enetamination in fi fr aesoypce we AS the Servo
Salve wat serial composont in many contol tens,
the fle of contamination om servovaves wa vent
fated by many persone (2 oh 4,5. Procedures forthe
{esting of servovalve Sa contaminated ds were Hsed
by SAE Committe A ar part af ts Aerospace Recon
send Prete (87
As the technology developed by aeropace bocame
avalble tothe machine too bh, NC machines
tere developed and the requirements fo ean hydraulic
tne heaton stems betame «part of the machine
‘Unb enany of the toes with ear model NC
Inachies could be traced to 1) low dit tolerance of
‘rly types urvoralves 2 margin Brain equipment
Trtatled on the machines and 2) poor maintenance
proredhes by the ust, Fortunately, throug evoltion
el Beller appreciation of the "nage black bor’,
improvements ave been ade ty all areas and better
petfocning systems ate now common (3).a. tintaon of 6 pa eye Sven
A typeat NC machine receives is comand from 4
punched tape, The tape reader teafrs the commands to
sletrical signals: Those signals energize a torque motor
inthe serovuve and'» apper moved to conta the
Mow of uid in proportion to the stength of the signa.
“This How sampled in one or more stages to dive the
Now of oll oud motor a elie Agu tho sigal
1s proportional tothe lsd motor or einer responses,
‘Tho servovalve signal + very low power—ehnos "en
power" They are made to be sensitive so dat thelr
Sponse to the input signal © rapid, proportional, and
tcurte,Diametral letrances of the pool i the valve
body re on the order of 001/0.002 dm. of Tass. This
seats tha the elenrance per sde is then 12 to 25 x. Tt
‘would seem reasnable tht if the taxinnm sae of
‘ontanination particles in the hycale ld were kept
Ilo the mickmum side clearance, the servovalve will
perform properly. Most manotaturers of servovalve for
‘machine Yoo! use recommend 410 meron filter ist
ee of he servovalve: Fg Han al ev
‘ave mounted on ane ofthe aes of an NC skin mil
fing machine. Note the ite that i mowed js aed
ofthe servovalve,
THE CONTAMINATION PROBLEM
‘The mechan by which s contaminant partie af
fect the performance of servovalve was investigated
by Oxgond (8) and hecussed in more detail by Wher
(in), A contamination parte night case spool to
sein, allow movement in one diestion only, ase
Felctional dag. When the trgue moter fevered, @
Valve faire sil asl i my of the conditions exit
within the servo. As applied to «machine tool namie
Jamming would caee the servovalve spool overeat #0
lag the torque ator sige and rel for example, 1 &
machine movement hut forthe commande postion
‘When any of the above malfunctions occur, servovalve
carina tthe prime siopect and if thie Ir the
‘step ae taken tp render the valve operable gas
td ta prevent the recurrence of particle contamination.
“Rerogprce sina serwovaver operating today where
the spotbore clearance per side ron the onder of 25
ft Gearances this sal are required not only of the
ervovalves but abo of the other components the
Iryeule rstem so as to reduce leakage and come
uel to Inerease syst efeteney, relly, ad re
‘pone. I canbe expected thit when the machine toot
Fads can take advantage ofthis techaology, the mn
chine fool builder andl weer wil be forced it cleaner
td cleaner hydraulic sstoms,
REDUCTION OF PARTICULATE CONTAMINATION
The filers recommended by some servovalve sane
Factores for machine tool we ae surface type 10 micron
nomial rating without « bypass valve (20, 12) Ie
uo recomended thatthe iter be placed ahead of and
ts clove to the servovalve as practical. Ax a prec
onary sesire, must servovalve manutactuets hive
‘oe ornare Alters built within the valve body. rir to
Installing servovalve is hydeulie sytem, the system
‘ate purged s ato clean contaminant spite
tthe cleaning precios taken ding the eeston of
"new machi, any contaminants are present and mst
te removed. Atypical hydrate ystern wil ave ase
tio ine kor abou ofthe hyde pump a 10 igh
presire filler after the pump, and 10 p Str jst
then of enh servovalve ted. Hijdraulie reservoirs with,
pats of 00 lof ell more are wot uncommon.
‘One procedare requires thatthe hydrant oll must
cone fon rlnry sealed 5 gal drums. Ax moon as
machine oretion reaches the point vthere il can be
Pt inthe reser, of pumped from the drums into
tho simp through a 2» iter. The creating pump on
the Hydrate ol heat eacnger Is tated Co tthe
Inet exchanger. An aulsry pomp draws ol ot of the
‘mp and pomp through 02 ter and then retwms
{he wot up. Tt wy saya ow
amplet sytem purge tine can bo saved by pre-cesning
the hydaie othe reservoir, ad the heat exchanger
TAs the hydrate syst Is bolng stalled, bypasses
ave pol around each of the ervovaves to temporally
Alscomect then fromm the cielry. The 10 ples ust
head of servovales are left im the chew When the
oi eontamination level in the reservoir with allow
‘le limits, the main hydraulic pump ts started and most
Of the hoes, tings, and Hud lines are Hushed A shat
‘of valve fs paced fn each servovalve circuit ahead of
"he filter to provide # means of changing ltr elements
withotshating the machine of, During the prolitinary
Th, all hutllYaler are open so tht the hydrateFi cutng in exch servovalve erent oop. With
he al veloty in this fish
Tone Tes Fon that
present inthe new oi, the reervou, an the heat
"hanger was mah larger than the csntantaton fa the
‘ain pump aul servovalve erat loops. By ing the
lay Gerng epspment and paging the yen ol
Sump, and beat exchanger fist, eboidrable time could
he aed and tatroduction of new contamination re
deed, The 1 ieronhydeuali sytem Bers would elo,
rapidly diving the Thabing operation. By pre-esning
‘simuch as posse efor thing the complete tem.
the filters ahead of the servovalves id not require
‘hanging. Each filter change trace contaation by
the opening ofthe flier housing and even more conta
nation die tothe filter element isl eng contained
‘Ale about two hours of the pear’ ishing, sl
servovalve sta valves except one are closed. With
nly ome lop fo accep the ofl volume and by ng,
the pump presare to atleast 1000 pal high velaty
fll # ciedated throng the dd lines io further east
any seal it, et. tat aores tothe ier sr lees
Under these conditions ease mat bo taken that the
‘eran tance to give a appoiation of the drgree
‘of partite contanintion preset in «Bud Ode seh
feample i ASTAE22TS67T (20) In this est 2 100 ml
Hid sunple divide nto to 80 ml samples, pheed
fn centre tubes ated with salvent and sp. It
tmewsrable amounts of precipitable conaniation oF
Sciment can be fod, the contamination lve the
hid sap exprened as 0 many lies of con
tamination per TAD wl of fi. Unfortstey, though
{he test rsp, the acumey in meaning the vl
‘contamination fond nthe Rui through the conte
‘method fs too low to give bt rough gue as to the
Contamination level. Rebert (21) describes how the
patie count method of ARP 538 ean be related tothe
flected particle vole and sggeste Bowe eeainess
Teves of fds canbe related to the parte volun,
‘Anoter tet, moti ead the "patch ts ters
1 olme of Hid through itera sae or depth type
fier. The color of the Ber allowing the ferig k
somewhat related to the level of contamination ong.
finaly present te Hid. The more discolored the ter
cones the higher the contamination lve: ARP-575
(22) a pate test procadae is wed to evaluat ellbity
fof puripe. By using plotodeustometer to determine
the des of discoloration, the sett of He path
{eae fcreaed Lt the difrnce fn eel of cota
tation between fd that are satiactry ad ati
{actory for wwe kn NC machine tools iso sight fo be
Vitaly undetectable
butlers of NC rachis tls ba to chose a txt
to determine the level of contamination In lyeeaie
fa st would probably be the particle connt method
of AID 58,
FLUID SAMPLING AND ANALYSIS
Long fore machine's hdl hid fread to be
analyrd, prisons net be made t obtain the samples
Gnd to minimize the chance of aio coatannntiongeting foto the sample, A sampling valve 6 stale in
tach servo lop jst after the filter and elre the sev
{Gee Fig) as eath servo Toop shouldbe checked. Four
‘ouce map plate cap las tar were found toe the
‘ost stefatory i which to collet the hid samples
Asservovalesare usually not cated where good working
space exits, the sample bottle size becomes portant
When it time to-stple the hydra dad in 2
machin, sample bots an the tet eqn reqed
{or ARP-598 are thoroughly cleaned flowing the te
Commend) procedures. The bots are marie or
entiation purposes
‘When eich of the srvordve lps has been ped,
sit rma tll valor aro open and Had ees
‘rough the entre machine, THe ol tempore as noe
reached equim To make sure that contuinants
‘do eot re-cllet So previo purged Toop, the ere
system i vena inal purge for about two hours, fer
which tie Bid sumpling ean begin. Jost porto
rctual taking of «sample, the sping valve ot
plug is removed snd the valve dacharge port ands
Fouting mirlaces ae washed vith sen of Bred
Freon TP. The sampling valve 6 ful) opened. After
spproninatly one gallon offi ows out of thesamping
‘ale, the simple botle ea removed, the bot filed
with o owing directly oot ofthe sample vale, and
{hen sealed” An al stmple from each lop i taken In
the manwer deeribed above, A additonal oi sample i
ftracted from the simp so tat the cotton of the
bulk oil can be determined, The procede a: rosa
‘ended by ARP.S98 followed in proesing te samples
‘Upon completion ofthe test, theft isremavel from
the appaati end stored bn a covered pet sh Each
‘di is marked withthe test date, job mamber and serv
loop cod. In this way the misosepie examination of
the Biter can be made at stane later Une An exp
once tciniian can scan the iter sila with, ef 4
0X and IOGX mcroscope and soon tel the approx!
imate condition of each lop witht acta! patie
counting. It regres sbout 15 min to wash the exp
tent, proces the sample, and examine the iter Each
Joop requiring an adetional purging is gven another
too how purge When the cntannation level fn all
ofthe loop are within an scceptable rane, the sere
‘aves ca be installed. Cleaves in ey the sample
bottles, taking the sample, and proces are very
ant Beer contention ofthe Bt ony nd
tate that lop rains farther peri when in
‘he citer within acceptable contamination at,
‘When conditions require that a particle coont be
btsine for partils in various ie ranges the micro.
‘copie counting procedore ef ARES is we. AMonal
techniques and apparatus to obtain samples plas pete
Sequence of mrascopie counting techaiques can he
found inthe Milipore Corp. ADMES. (2)
‘CONTAMINATION LEVELS
‘Table 1 shows several attempts to catagorie degrees
‘of contamination fn Akl The chart tthe top, labeled
cy
{CONTAMINATION BY PARTICLE COUNT
‘STANDARDS FOR HYDRAULIC FLUIDS.
PARTICLES PERIOD ML SAMPLE
‘Sytem Casper Tentative SAE-A-SD" ie probly the
most widely Known. When technical papers dealing
‘vith the contamination problem discuss the stem eas
‘of contarination without defining las, dhe cass as
ley" the SAE-ASD system lass SAB subcommittee
‘ASD ‘esd this clasieation a “Recommended Com
tamination Levels", dated Apu 1961, but the SAE has
tot yt formally fad the claneation as am Aerospace
Recommended Practice.
‘The lower chart, NAS-16%8 (20, shows part of the
teuifcation ystems sued ly the National Aerospace
Standards Commitee, System cases are numbered fom
(0 through 12. From the geometile progression used in
tetbling the sytem elas, the ven munbered system
thus can be easly determined. A fequenty” wed
hyde Mi io aerospace work i MIL-H-S006 B and
{he pute contamination lnits fr new fais is shown
far eomparstive purposes. No new distal hydraulic
tal checked by the author even approaches that level of
eles
ts important to note tt in each patie size ange,
the clas determined by the number of particles oad
Jn that range, Ths, if Bias 2 petite cout in
the 25-50 range, that would place i inthe NAS-1638
‘Chas fa apatite count in Ue 15-25 grange of an
INAS-1638 Clas tho lad mst he considered Clas 5.
Sone NC machine too builders follow the SAE-A-6D
contamination lite for 5-10 and 10-25 4 partie
‘counts to determine the system cls. The stem cas
is better than the particle count the 10-25 p ange
‘determined bythe SAE-A.BD clas limits and is down
igrded if the 3-10 p particle count exceeds the cass
Tims by nore than fw clases
“Table 2 shows NAS-1638 standard nits for particle
se by wight) MIL-S60SB id has, in addon to
Date ie range count lis, roquremet that the
{otal reside Weight shall nt exceed 0.3 mn per 100mof Bid, As NAS-1008 sates, “A contelaton between
‘Tale ¥ and Table 2 is neither expend or imped
‘The densty of contamination particles varies co widely
that it hs not been possible, us ft, to velate particle
simu and particle weight forthe many ston involved
‘with contamination of lig
gues 2-5 are photomicrgrapte of contamination
found in hydraulic cle under diferent circumstances as
deposited on the membrane fiter following, ARP-5I8
”
‘shunubdomlantSaitaacou ey
on
Tasue NAS 1098 STANDARD FOR PARTICULATE
PARTICLES PE TOD ML SAMPLE
procedures, Figure 2 (50X magnifation) shows «large
‘umber of particles in the 10-95 see range, A particle
sunt revetled that over 5,000 10-25 x see prtices
fe present and Sndiats that the loop from which the
sample was taken is badly contaminated. The picture
Sates the reals of poor sampling procedures forthe
‘contamination war traced to a les carrying enteral
pipe contaminants ito the sample bot, A. recheck
fof the Bud made ft evideat that the loop was setualy
(Case or better
Figure isa typical picture ofthe contamination found
‘when testing new hyUrauie oi. Each divion on the
sale is 20 Figure 4 shows & representative sample
taken from a loop following the recommended paring
ie ee See
feeroioaaababiatesitontaofanitayand sampling procedares. Each dvision is 10 mirons
{Sethe cae ws tabled ob better than Clas 9
re 9, each dvson represents 10 and very large
‘mamber of pats les than 10 mean be sect This at
‘ipl was taken froma machin hat had been operating
for several! monks, No parties over 25 pcould be oud
From the ema rier of 5-10 y_ partes, he
syste clas beyoa an yo particles over 25 nero
ound, the sytem cast cold be considered 0
‘Upon examination of the Scope of NASB,
‘lealnes restements ate for as recelved yale
hid or for the Tis when placed Ito a ese
“The Sop us thi to do with the id after in
the sub und ht been operating. The SAEAD
recommened contanination tins alo apis to ew
fic "When the machine tel aller puts lan
yee Mi nto a machine for the fst tie, the
Ail ats ara solvent an earl forthe conten
tants tht are preset inthe lateral pats. Afr afew
frases throughm newly avembled machine tht bas 0
Firion quinn, clean fd wonld son become
sey. cntamiated With Hering and following
Drging proce, the builder can rece the particulate
‘Satan present inthe lt some predetermine
level that content with the lvl of filtration wed
stalled mot NC chine tol bilder recommen
to tor caomers that before a machine Is mae ready
{0 nn, the hydric ld be fered ni the partie
late contamination levels at leat SAE-A-6D Clas
love or euivaent
"An NC machine tol in production generates partie:
tte comaization in the fic Mt the rest of
swear avalon, erson, fd breakdown, et. Pate
Ite contaminants enter the hydric system through
Uathers and sea As cootamionnts ae aed tothe
‘yaa fi, the filters are ating to remove the par
cles to the extent of their expaiity while Deskdown
lng pti foto sal piles acento
the shearing action of pun, valves, ahd other moving
‘components igre 6 taken from the work of Fitch
£25 an stows the resus of 25 lter coupled with
the efecto partie breakdown on hye ld of &
SAE-AGD Cla 8 contamination fvel Note tat as the
her pleks up contamination from the ithe fer
set fever i wer re paises 0p ay
{ie dri noma operation, the hyrai ud parte
Contamination dtrttion eave il be somewhat"
shaped
As noted, the photomicrograph in Fig 5 was obi
{oom hye il sample that fad been eulating
ina machin for several mouths, Filtering of te oi
sample through a 047 pier as vequied by ARP-S8
took any hos 1 i apparent then that atu
‘Wut a prt avenge mabe of particles
1 hydanlie Bid from operating equlpment not the
“ame athe dttion fond inthe cleanliness level
‘ues of SAE or NAS ad tht the SAE aed NAS con
tamination lovee donot apy i thi sitaton
“The eb of partite contamination fits based
on gravimeter preicament Wear
1
particles that sppear only after & machine In se are
‘owl ion. Estates of the weight of ron preset in
the partite contamination on new off saps for
gravimetric analysis vary Dt so toe about IO, AS
the ir content of the contaminants erases due to
the ation of wear particles, gravimetric anabsi
proces show a iceease in the weight of contam
fants preent In 4 smple even Dough the manber of
large partiles decreases (26,
MAINTENANCE OF SYSTEM CLEANLINESS
"The yee ia at et mac, bc ep
‘lean by the mechanical scion of fers and by the
‘hemical aston ofthe additive package placed the
fui. The types of ltrs wed in mos instances remove
sol or ylantinossparles to the lit of the hes.
"These ttersdo nat generally remove toil r gaseous
contaminants Most servovalve manufactures and
{machine tool builders recomend that the hydralc
Abi ler be rated at 10 nomial particle ize. Note
that in Fig, 6 the na Hint of uation in sytem
protected with 1 potnnal 25 ler i about 18 p. A
‘ominal 1 je Blter shold ive etter than 10. firstion
Stor many” pases Urowgh the filter, Saver ines
ve backed aay from alraine Slzation not because
ood filtration i. tant at that's stern wl
‘loan Hl with high-quality kes somewhat coarser
han ial not disturbed (27).
“Alubrcation engineer might thenask whether efectve
contamination contol of hydraulic ful Is posible
se fo, what Tits of contamination should be placed.
‘on Rois for we in electrchyralle servovalve controled
INC machine tol fective contamination contol snot
Just a mater of ler as Walthall 28) esr. Stem
planning ostion of iter, heat exchanger capacity, te
fre uta few of the tems that have been considered
ina machine's design to redce the generation of pat
{slate contamination.
Servovalves isle ten years ayo are probably df
{ere than servovalve wed tday—even from the be
manufacturer, Because of diferences indesign, the
4 ston ot coma gie sie dion 6tolerance of servovalve operating in contaminated Buide
‘avis from menulecwer to macufacirer, In general,
nos servovelves made today will operat tn Fu with
high amounts of particulate contamination. The nomial
11 icon tation requested by met sanufactrer of
indus servovalve will, vader novel wage, Keep
servvalves wear toa tolerable minima,
‘Ara general rule, no mean of the degree of conta
nation allowable, ether by particle cout o by gravi-
tis i apecfed by the manulactarer. William (2)
Contes that with today’s servovalves and Matin,
‘ontannation i no longer a pralem. When considering
the warranty Mf of «servovalve, Wallan sys farther
{Oat the soamioaton level rater than the degen of
Silraton ie the deiding factor,
Inaerapucesvovalver operate at higher prewar and
under wide range of environment. Ashman ile may
Alepend spo the prompk and accurate response of s¥o-
wales, the needs forthe est practice in hydra Bl
Clesalines are necoary. In Fejard to machine took,
‘lurablity tthe major consideration, Ae mentioned pre
‘iosy, when machine Is operation, prtelatecon-
{amination generated asthe esl of Wear, cavitation,
‘rosin, ete, These particles are generally of fon com
postion adhere arenbresive. Abrasive particles cried
Ing velocity ll ean generate more abrasive particles.
High veloty oll would be ound in pumps and valves
‘Within serves, lan, clearances, and nozzles are par
lav subject to high velocity ofan erosion ean cme
«problem in time. An approximation of the eflets of
‘wear by ersion as fant of partie size canbe made
the particles ae asmved spherial. A 10 1 portile
vill have elght mes more hong effect than 5 x par
ce, Noemally the high capital cost of a NC machine
tol rete thatthe utiation of tho machine be at a
tion Ht hus be ettate! that the normal wea
find tear on an NC machine tol fs tome three times
Higher than onthe stme type of conventional machine
tool In terms of elapsed te, the wear on hydraulic
sgstem components of NC machine tools seems high i
‘Compara to the conventional sachin)
‘CONTAMINATION LIMITS
Barring lated instances, itis generally recogized that
sorvovales will erate in Suds with «high particulate
‘contnintion lel (20 31) 1 abn grand that
‘loan Bly servovaves will give liter, prformance
fd more relat than a contaninated Mea at
“hanging ler elements at rela time Sterva sot
‘esiable nor vequted. iter elements shuld ho changed
‘whenever the diferent] presire arom thee exceeds
the syste maxinun diferent. Opinions begin to
Aller when & demarcation line mst Be drawe the
Aogree of iva.
‘The absve partie generation cycle can he reduced
by ving Be fran. It ean be Inoken Dy caging
the hydealie hid. Many other bene wil occur by
changing the hyiaulie td Por ove thing, water Wat
fay have entered trough the reervoie eather or
though leakage in water! heat exchanger can be
renoved. Fld contaminants resting fom ossdation
‘an be Bed Sr the sso, Ondation products Lead
to varaish and shade depots (2). The adtve package
placed in many Bde chs eal deartiatrs, st
{ahitr, foun soir, oiaten into at-wear
yen, te can ecome depleted tough se la shor,
‘any contin cannot be removed by zation al
tod so, dhe Mad elf mst epic
“The lbrieston engineers plant sig NC mache
took, mst operate within the managements alte
toward maintenance. If nasagamat sys fx It when
it breaks" then the best tat ean be hoped fr eo
Change Bltee when the dileenial sere the Alter
‘exceeds recommended ints 1 mmagerent looks 3t
total cos and not fs sintenanes, then the Iabviaton
‘engineer shold procure the equipment to meanare the
“mount of prelate contamination by the particle count
method inter the of condtion ever Si of machine
tee apply a wary clvo-yp pump-ier with 2p
‘ements to the Hd the reserva when the patie
‘at forthe 510 range xed the SAE- AD Clase
Teves an change the 10 fers whenever the diene
Ail pres encede the axinen working ifereta
Monitoring the ol edition aso shou inh checking
the water content, which should be less than 0.9%, the
nso, and the neatalization number any of these
eae fadiate thatthe Boi i becoming contaminated
swith gus, the Bid should be changed iri nother
‘outaniant that usally cannot be removed with Hes.
“Anion agents are added to hyale lds to get «
‘api separation of si, While the efecto air are beyoe
the intent ofthis dcson, should bo noted ato
trained ae tn May, when compres fe, 2000 ps
‘or more, can bocome very hat local. This generated
Treat causes the fd surzounding the bubble to burs. As
the products of combustion ate both Aud ad solid
ontaminants, more contamination can be generated
‘CONCLUSION
“The tate ofthe ti ch that wo conchsive fad
‘ontasination loves canbe ves a Hew of standart
the author fas presented a stuation 10 a Ibviaton
fngincer with a minions and dale approach
derstanding the partelste contamination problem.
‘The paper replete wih relevenes to enable the
lubrication engingor to decide what best for his own
lation and to make him aware of the prblens ad
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
“The author whes to thask the Ons. Machine
Divison of Danly Machine Corporation for the we of
{scien au infonmtion io preparing > paper
J. Corrigan and W. Prange fr photography assistance:
CAT Anderson for artwork, and hs we Mary for
-reparng the manentGator J.
fa at ve
eer Eom ee
USES ian tl Pt
int, Wel SA ty ee
Timi eve Wren ean Rn 2
‘Mie tb Sh A, “Cotati dS
Valetta” Mya ecmae
Ca and Sher EA “Cantatin ad
{ten Cesnation” iy on Prame
SSL, ace «cnt ere
Shs Sue ocean at oa
certs ome roa ars
Eat tc ses pss
Sere tr
ean ee aa
cites
SE rR renemea
tee ey ee
2 Guage pea ena
@
o
sey ack ro SA
seu Tl Te Meo Sd Ree Nd
15 “Pre fr the eter
sikh a
(U9 “Mate Te fo Patente Cantino inn
Fenster
eee cng ta
(in Sogn Appt Pipl. a Opie Ini
wpe erp lS
cE a a Tad eas
“a at in aig Of" 4ST RTT.
Gna ht Pm
Hever ik, fee
ey rr Mie al bi
29 "i a i Cam
(2h “Chalo Rents of Part id Hye Sysos™
eS Naat" Colonne “td” Pos
aca a
99 Soe et ae Som” Mae Di
‘en yr aod Prat 11-0
et
a9 Mins Uf tain Ea Src
Fe stn? Hats and Raat HI
09 DLR, “nye ty ed Rese Ga of
Fine fon fda a Pr, t
(re 8
can Ramah “Hegde Sao Yen” aes and
Presto 18)
‘ert ron Cig © Spee
@