0 ratings0% found this document useful (0 votes) 754 views25 pagesLincoln Djang
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
“A a
EDDY COUNTY,
‘SIA JUDICIAL(DIS
FILED IN MY iE
99SEP-7 ANU: 02
FIFTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT
Coun or iN oN
STATE OF NEW MEXICO ee
STATE OF NEW MEXICO,
Plaintiff,
¥s. No. CR-99-.251-JLS
LINCOLN D'JANG,
Ld
as
Defendant,
CRIMINAL INFORMATION
‘The Assistant District Attorney in and for the Fifth Judicial District, State of New Mexico,
states that the above defendant did commit the crimes of,
COUNTI: CRIMINAL SEXUAL CONTACT OF A MINOR, contrary to Section
30-9-13 B, NMSA 1978, and alleges that said defendant did unlawfully and intentionally touch or
apply force to the intimate parts of Jessica Maples, a child thirteen to eighteen years of age, and was
perpetrated with foree or coercion, that this did happen on or about May 11, 1999, in Eddy County,
New Mexico,
COUNT2: CRIMINAL SEXUAL CONTACT OF A MINOR, contrary to Section
30-9-13 B, NMSA 1978, and alleges that said defendant did unlawfully and intentionally touch or
apply force to the intimate parts of Jessica Maples, a child thirteen to eighteen years of age, and was
perpetrated with force or coercion, that this did happen on or about May 11, 1999, in Eddy County,
‘New Mexico.
COUNTS: CRIMINAL SEXUAL CONTACT OF A MINOR, contrary to Section
30-9-13 B, NMSA 1978, and alleges that said defendant did unlawfully and intentionally touch or
apply force to the intimate parts of Jessica Maples, a child thrtoon to eighteen years of age, an wes
perpetrated with force or coercion, that this did happen ut May 11, 1999, in Eddy County,
New Mexico.
ASSISTANT DISTRICT ATTORNEYCRIMINAL INFORMATION
STATE v. LINCOLN D’JANG
PAGE2
WITNESSES:
Jessica Maples
Patti Janes.
Michael Carriaga
Marcus Safar
Sill Dennis
PENALTY:
Counts 1, 2 and 3 - 4ti: Degree Felonies,
EACH COUNT
F Thereby cortity that a true copy
4 the foresois
Georgia Goad
Jade Janes
Gary Wu
Brad Nesser
Det. David Edmondson16-703, 7-703, 8-703] os Cc A&
INTY, NM.
IN THE MAGISTRATE COURT sie UDI aisraler COUNTY OF EDDY
State of New Mexico No, M-17-FR-99-00216 MLO
SOSEP-7 AMIN: 02 District Court No. (8-49-25 (-ULS
ELEANOR SARA
LINCOLN DIANG, Defendant DISTRICT COUR’
v.
‘TITLE PAGE OF TRANSCRIPY OF CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AND CERTIFICATE
DEFENDANT represented by DENISE A. MADRID,
Attomey at Law ‘Public Defender’s Office.
[1 Appointed [X) Retained
Address of Attomey
P.O. BOX 1718
CARLSBAD, NM 88220
(STATE OF NEW MEXICO ) reselved
(COUNTY OF EDDY ds.
(CITY OF Carlsbad)
Ido hereby certify that the attached is a complete transcript of Criminal Proceedings and is a true and correct
representation of the entries in the Docket of the above-styled cause.
Dated: August 27, 199°.
c COURT CLERK
CRIMINAL COMPLAINT; WARRANT FOR ARREST; RELEASE ORDER AND BOND; APPEARANCE
BOND; HIRE OWN ATTORNEY FORM; ENTRY OF APPEARANCE; NOTICE OF PRELIMINARY
E*MINATION; PRAECIPE FOR SUBPOENA; MOTION TO CONTINUE PRELIMINARY HEARING;
‘ORI-ER VACATING PRELIMINARY HEARING AND RESETTING FOR ANOTHER DATE; MOTION FOR,
CS TINUANCE; ORDER FOR CONTINUANCE; FINAL DISPOSITION REPORT; TAPE LOG; AND BIND-
“OVES. ORDER,
PIPER IG-COM
mo
Q tape
Anca Ropes,
1 copy - Court 1 copy - Defendant 1 copy - Prosecutor
le Criminal Forta 9-608
xX-c OASTATE OF NEW MEX’
IN THE MAGISTRATE couRT
CRIMINAL COMPLAINT
M-19-FA-99- 00a! Co
No. MmLo
CRIME(e): CRIMINAL SEXUAL CONTACT
OF A MINOR (FOUR COUNTS)
STATE OF NEW MEXICO
va.
‘LINCOLN DJANG _
A0L5_ALAMOSA STREET
ee DEF. APPEARED, WITH/WITHOUT COUNSEL a
. PENALTI
Defendant ADVISED OF RIGHTS, CHARGES & ES is
PLEA: GUILTY. NOT GUILTY_oc.
COUNSEL APPT. will MTom
TRIAL/HEARING DATE_fpq_3, 197 1 oP My
The undersigned, under penalty of perjury complains and says on information
and belief taat on or about the ITH day of MAY, 1999, in Eddy County, New
Mexico, the above-named defendant did:
STATE OF NEW MEXICO
COUNTY OF EDDY
The defendant did commit the offense of CRIMINAL SBXUAL CONTACT OF A MINOR
(Four Counts) in that; The defendant touched or applied force to the buttocks
of Jessica Maples on four separate incidents; The defendant used physical
force each time; Jessica Naples was at least 13 but less than 18 years old;
All four incidents happened at 3000 w.
Mexico on or about the 11th day of May,
Church, Carlsbad, Bddy County, New
1999.
Contrary to Section(s) _20-9-13 (B) NMSA 1978
I swear and affirm under penalty of
perjury that the facts set forth above
are true to the best of my information and belief:
District Attorney's Office
‘Approved
pa
Disapproved
Title
Gr)
Bed) WDrere dhe’
Complainant
DETECTIVE SE —________
Title (if any)CRIMINAL COMPLAINT Page Two
State of New Mexico
ve
08 6-08-99 T, Sergeant Edmondson met with Candace Maples and her
Gaughter, Jessica ‘Maples at The Safehouse to conduct an interview with
jessica in reference to allegations that Lincoln Djang, che defendant
anapptopriately touched the buttocks of Jessica Maples. Sectice ts 16 year
old temale and a member to The Carlsbad High School swim team The defendant
Playing. a game of water polo at The Carlsbad High School Matatoriin, seo ¥.
Shurch, Carlsbad, Eddy County, New Mexico. The defendant was in the capacity
SFampconch and in the pool with the team, Jessica said ‘tha: the demnaet
grqkbed her butt on four different occasiona during this session meee
Seid that she was guarding the defendant's son, boug Djang and men Che ee
Rinand wetrieve the ball, the defendant grabbed her butt. She back ranges
Bim and he replied, *oh, spank me some more". Jessica stated that ake glared
aati and went on with the game of water polo. Jessica said that she netees
that every time she would turn around, the defendant was in hey vicinity.
ihe next incident happened when she went to get the ball after it went
Sree gPounaS and the defendant grabbed her butt again. Jessica turned Co
glare at him and the defendant just smiled at her. Jessica sald that cate
time this happened the defendant would just "smirk" at her and she wach
glare" at hin. Jessica said that she made it known to him by the way che
jooked at him that this was unwanted. The third time she aloo eas retrieving
the ball when he crabbed her butt, she again glared at him. The fouch ving
opened while she was swimming'to guard Doug Djang. Lincoln Djang, the
Aggendant, gzabbed her around the waist as she was swimming and then Slaced
his opposite hand on her butt in a caressing type motion. Jessica states chon
she exited the pool and turned to glare at the defendant. The defendant just
emiled at her.
J spoke with several of the awim team members and they did not witness
any Of the events as stated by Jessica. The menbers often stated that the
defendant told jokes that are inappropriate and flirte with the older giris
{around 16 years cf age). They also state that thay believe thie incident aia
occur as stated by Jessica Maples due to Jessica being an honest and teathias
person.
Due to the above listed facts, this affiant believes that the defendant
did commit the crime of Criminal Sexual Contact of a Minor (four counts)”Jessica Maples
Georgia Goad
Patti Janes
Jade Janes
Michael Carriaga
Gary Wu
Marcus Safar
Brad Nesser
dill Dennis
Det. Sgt. David Edmondson
WITNESSES
ADDRESS.
2108 Calledecorniz
1306 Bryan Circle
502 W. Riverside
502 W. Riverside
5102 La Placita
1508 Jefferson
1306 Bryan Circle
1019 N. Guadalupe
405 Corbett
Tor c, NM
cepi
ij
|
i
|
i a
*008N20 by 596
Coun of apy TCT COURT oStRPR oc
STATE OF NEW MEXICO
STATE OF NEW MEXICO, )
Plaintiff, }
vs. } No. CR-99-251-JLS
LINCOLN D’JANG, }
— }
Deft )
IUDGMENT AND SENTENCE
THIS MATTER came before the Court on January 6, 2000, for a Sentencing Hearing, the
Battery (misdemeanor), committed on or about May 11, 1999, The Court made the following
findings:
Defendants hereby found and adjudged guilty and convicted of sid crimes and is committed
{0 the custody ofthe Eddy County Detention Center, Carlsbad, New Mexico, for a Period of ThreeJUDGMENT AND SENTENCE
STATE v. LINCOLN D'JANG
PAGE2
Execution of Defendant's semence shall be suspended and Defendant shall be placed on
supervised probation for the term of his sentence.
‘The following are conditions of Lefendant’s probation:
1
Defendant shall attend no less than four (4) meetings with Alcoholic Anonymous per
calendar week during the entire term of his supervised probation;
Defendant shall provide written reports every three (3) months to the Office of the
District Attorney, Attn: Raymond L. Romero, Assistant District Attomey, 101 S.
Canal Street, Carlsbad, New Mexico. Said reports shall verify Defendant's attendance
at the Alcoholic Anonymous meetings. At each meeting, Defendant shall have the
chairman of the meeting sign a form, verifying the date, time, place and the
Defendant's presence at the meeting, Defendant is to submit such written proof that
he has attended no less than four (4) meetings per calendar week with his quarterly
report; and,
Defendant is to hold a meeting at the Carlsbad High School Natatorium with all
members of the swim team, to include the Carlsbad High School Swim Team, the
Carlsbad USA Swim Club team, as well as selected Carlsbad High School faculty. At
said meeting, Defendant is required to inform attending students and faculty of theJUDGMENT AND SENTENCE
STATE v. LINCOLN D'JANG
PAGES
facts of his case (that he did in fact intentionally grab the buttocks of Jessica Maples
‘on three separate occasions during a water polo game which took place in the Carlsbad
High School Natatorium on May 11, 1999), that Jessica Maples had in fact told the
truth when she reported his actions to authorities, and that Defendant lied to them
‘when he claimed he had not committed the acts of which he had been accused. This
meeting will be tape (audio) recorded.
Defendant shall pay probation costs not to exceed $25,00 per month.
During his period of probation the Defendant shall obey all regulations and orders of the Adult
Probation and Parole Department and observe all Federal, State and City laws or ordinances,
TTIS FURTHER ORDERED that the Deferviant shall be photographed and fingerprinted, and
‘that fingerprint card, along with the photos and an attestation and certificate thatthe fingerprints and
photos are of this Defendant, shall be made a permanent part of the Court record in this matter.
i SHULER
DISfRICT JUDGEFIFTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
COUNTY OF EDDY
STATE OF NEW MEXICO
GARY MAPLES and CANDACE MAPLES,
As Parents and Next Friends of
Jessica Maples, a minor,
rec cN
Plaintiffs,
if No, C¥-2000-_ 290.
JAMES L.
LINCOLN DJANG, SHEA DJANG, S L. SHULER
CHARLOTTE NEILL,
USA SWIMMING, INC, and S Summons clssud
BOARD OF EDUCATION OF
CARLSBAD MUNICIPAL SCHOOLS,
Defendants.
COMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURIES
AND FOR PUNITIVE DAMAGES
COUNT
COME NOW Plittfs Gary Maples and Candace Maples, as patents and next frends of
Jessica Maples, a minor, and for a cause of action against Defendant Lincoln Djang, state:
1. Plaintis are resients of Crisbed, Eddy County, New Mexico; the tortious conduct
which is the subject-matter hereof occurred in Carlsbad. Eddy County, New ‘Mexico.
2 Omand before May 11, 1999, Defendant Lincols Djang intentionally or recklessly
engaged in extreme and outrageous conduct against Plaintiffs” minor daughter, touching and groping
the minor’s body in an indecent manner, making indecent and sexual comments and overtures, and
this atrocious and intolerable conduct caused the Plait
” minor daughter to experience and suffer
severe emotional distress, all as will be shown upon trial of this eause
3. By reason of the foregoing, Plaimiffs are entitled to recover for and on bekalf of their
minor daughter, an amount of compensatory damages as will be shown upon trial of this cause.A, Theaforessid conduct was wilful, malicious, wanton and/or reckless, and by reason
theteof, Plaimitfs are entitled to reeover punitive damages, all as will be shown upon trial of this
cause.
WHEREFORE, Pleintifs pray for judgment against Defendant Lincoln Djang for
compensatory damages, for puritive damages, for costs of sit, fr prejudgment interes, and for such
other relief as may be just.
COUNT I
COME NOW Plsintfts Gary Maples and Candace Maples, as parents and next fiends of
Jessica Maples, a minor, ad for a separate cause of action agrint Defendant Lincoln Djan, state
1. Paragraph 1 of Count {is incorporated by reference and made a part hereof
2, Onor about May 11, 1999, Defendant Lincoln Djang, without consent or any right
todo o, indecently and intentionally touched, battered and/or asaulted Plaintiffs” minor daveb,
thereby causing harm and emotional distress ll as will be shown upon tial ofthis onuse
3, By reason of the battery and assault aforesid, Plaintiffs, for and on behalf of heir
rrinor daughter, are entitled wo recover a: amount of compensatory damages a will be shown upon
tial of this cause.
“4, Theaforesad battery and assault was wilful, malicious, wanton and/or recklessly done,
anu by reason thereof, Pints are entitled to recover punitive damages all as willbe shown upon
trial ofthis cause.
WHEREFORE, Plaintfs pray for judgment against Defendant Lincoln Djang for
compensatory damages for puitve damages, fr eos of et, for prejudgment interest, and for suck
other relief as may be just.
COUNT HT
COME NOW Plaictifs Gary Maples and Candace Mapios, as parents and next fiends of
Jessioa Maples, a minor, and fora separate cause of action aginst Defendant Lincoln Djans, sate
Saat Fe Fa at ad Fr ne Da
“Gaya Mas Lito Dn1. Paragraph 1 of Count 1s incorporated herein by reference and made apart hereot
2 Atal times material hereto, Defendant Lincoln Djang was acting as coach andor
supervisor of a youth wim cub, Plaintiff” minor daughter was a member ofthe said club
3. Onand before May 11, 1999, Defendant Lincoln Djang, in neues and careless
breach of his duty to exercise ordinary cate, conducted himelfin an offensive and indecent manner
toward Plaintiffs’ minor daughter, thereby proximately causing emotional harm and damage, all as
vill be shown upon til ofthis cause.
4, By reason of the aforesaid negligent and careless conduct, Plintiff, for and on behalf
of their minor daughter, are entitled to recover an amount of compensatory damages, 28 will be
shown upon trial ofthis cause.
5, ‘The aforessia conduct was wanton and/or reckless, and Plaintifs are entitled to
recover punitive damages, all as will be shown upon tral of this cause
WHEREFORE, Plaitits pray for judgment aysinst Defendant Lincoln Djang for
‘compensatory damages, for puitive damages, for costs of sit, for prejudgment interest, and for such
other relief as may be just.
count iv
COME NOW Plistifts Gary Maples and Candace Maples, os parents and next fiends of
Jessica Maples, a minor, and for a cause of action against Defendant USA Swimming, In. state
1. Paragraphs 1 & 2 of Count, paragraphs 1 & 2 of Count Hy, and paragraphs 1-3 of
Count II are incorporated herein by reference and made a pat hereof.
2, Defendant USA Swimming, Ine. is a forsign corporation transacting corporate
activities within the State of New Mexico.
3. The swim club aforesaid was created and existed under the auspices of Defendant
USA Swimming, Inc, and/or through its local divisions and/or subdivisions.
Cag Fe ats wd For aii De4, Defendant USA Swimming, Ine. sponsored, authorized and/or empowered Defendant
Lincoln Djang and Defendant Shea Djang,as coaches and/or safety marshals in regard to the swim
club aforesaid.
5, ‘The aforesaid acts and conduct of Defendant Lincoln Djang were done and committed
in the course snd scope of the actual or apparent authority of Defendant USA Swimming, Ine. and
Defendant USA Swimming, Ino. is, therefore, liable for the harm resulting from Defendant Lincoln
Djang’s tortious conduct
6, By reason of the foregoing, Plaintiffs, for and on behalf of their minor daughter, are
entitied to recover compensatory damages of and from Defendant USA Swimming, Inc, all as will
bbe shown upon trial ofthis cause.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs pray judgment against Defendant USA Swimming, Ine, for
compensatory damages, for costs of suit, for prejudgment interest, and for such other relief as mey
be jus.
counTy
COME NOW Plaintiffs Gary Maples and Candace Maples, as parents and next fiends
of Jessica Maples, a minor, and for a cause of action against Defendant Shea Djang and Defindant
USA Swimming, Inc, state:
1. Pa-agraphs 1 & 2 of Count I, paragraphs I & 2 of Count If, paragraphs 1-3 of Count
TH, and paragraphs 1-5 of Count IV are incorporated by reference and made a part hereof,
2, Atal times material hereto, Defendant Shea Djang was acting in a capacity of coach
and/or safety marshall in regard to the aforesaid swim club.
3. On and before May 11, 1999, Defendant Shea Djang negligently and carelessly
allowed and permitted Defendant Lincoln Djang to participate with and to coach and otherwise be
associated with the members of the youth swim club, including Plaintiffs” minor daughter, when she
‘Sa Pel i wa or Pas Da
‘ary aa Gace Map ¥en Da ea
Peetknew or shoul have known that Defendant Lincoln Djang’s presence and participation ereated risk
of harm to young girls, including Plaintiffs” minor daughter
4, Atal times material hereto, Defendant Shea Djang was acting
he course and
scope of the actual or apparent authority of Defendant USA Swimming, Inc,, and Defendant USA
Swit
ing, Inc. is, therefore, liable for Defendant Shea Djang’s aforesaid negligence.
5. Asadirect and proximate result of the negligence aforesaid, Plaintiffs? minor daughter
‘was harmed and has and will suffer emotional injury and damage, all as will be shown upon trial of
this causé,
6, By reason of the foregoing, Plaintiffs, for an on behalf of their minor daughter, are
entitled to recover compensatory damages of and from Defendant Shea Djang and Defendant USA
‘Swimming, Inc. in an amount to be shown upon trial of this cause,
7. The aforesaid conduct was wilful, wanton and/or reckless, and by reason thereof,
ffs are entitled to recover punitive damages, all as will be shown upon tral ofthis cause
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs pray for judgment against Defendant Shea Djang and Defendant
USA Swimming, Inc, for compensatory damages, for punitive damages, for costs of suit, for
prejudgment interest, and for such other relief as may be just,
COUNT ¥I
COME NOW Plaintiffs Gary Maples and Candace Maples, as parents and next fiiends of
Jessica Maples, a minor, and for a separate cause of action against Defendant USA Swimming, Inc.,
state
1, Peragraphs 1 & 2 of Count I, paragraphs 1 & 2 of Count Il, paragraphs 1-3 of Count
LU, paragraphs 1-4 of Count IV, and paragraphs 1-5 of Count V are incorporated by reference and
made a part hereof.
2. Defendant USA Swimming, Inc. was negligent, and such negligence includes, but is
‘not limited to, the following
a ‘Coat or Pomel pars wa Far ni
Grands Naps ol Dea(@) A failure to adequately screen and/or select coaches and safety marshalls;
(b) A failure to adequately train coaches and safety marshalls,
(©) A failure to property supervise coaches and safety marshalls involved with
Tocat swim clubs; and/or
(@ A failure to promulgate proper and adequate rules and regulations in regard
‘10 who shall be allowed to participate with local swim clubs,
3. Asa proximate result ofthe aforesaid negligence, Plaintiffs” minor daughter sustained
injury and damage and has and will suffer emotional harm, all as will be shown upon arial of this
‘cause,
4. By reason of the foregoing, Plaintiffs, for and on behalf of their minor daughter, are
‘entitled to recover compensatory damages in an amcunt to be shown upon trial ofthis eause,
5. ‘The acts and omissions of Defendant USA Swimming, Ine, were wanton, wilful and/or
reckless, and by reason thereof, Plaintiffs are entitled to rczover punitive damages, all as will be
shown upon trial of this cause,
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs pray for judgment against Defendant USA Swimming, inc. for
‘compensatory damages, for punitive damages, for costs of sit, for prejudgment interest, and for such
other relief as may be just
COUNT VE
COME NOW Plaintiff Gary Maples and Candace Maples, and for a cause of action against
Defendant Board of Education of Carlsbad Municipal Schools, Defendant Shea Djang, and Defendant
Charlotte Neil, state:
1, Paragraphs 1 & 2 of Count J, and paragraphs 1 & 2 of Count I
herein by reference.
incorporated
2. At all times material hereto, Defendant Shea Djang and Defendant Charlotte Neill
‘were public employees within the meaning of NMSA 1978, §41-4-1 et seq, and were acting within
Cae Pa pate a Far Ts DG
Ghee Cae na Dg athe course and scope of their duties with Defendant Board of Education of Carlsbad Municipal
Schools,
3. Atal times matcrial hereto, Defendant Board of Education of Carlsbed Municipal
Schools was a governmental entity within the meaning of NMSA 978, §41-4-1 et. seq.; owned,
operated and maintained premises and buildings known as Carlsbad High School, including what is
known as the Natatorium; and acted through its public employees.
4, These Defendants, in a breach of their duty to exercise ordinary care in the operation
‘and maintenance of the aforesaid premises, including the Natatorium, permitted and allowed
Defendant Lincoln Djang to enter and come upon the said premises and to then and there be in close,
contact and association with young git
including Plaintiffs’ minor daughter, when they knew, or
should have known, that doing so would create a dangerous condition on said premises and erate
arisk of harm,
SS *> Asa direct and proximate result of the negligent operation and maintenance of a public
building and facilities as aforesaid, Plaintiffs" minor daughter sustained injury and damage, and bas
‘and will suffer emotional harm, all as will be shown upon trial of this cause.
6. There is no immunity fiom suit a8 to these Defendants, pursuant to the waiver
provisions of NMSA 1978, §41-4-6.
7. Nonotice of claim pursuant to NMSA 1978, §41-4-16 is required as to Defendants
Shea Djang and Charlotte Neill all ofthese Defendants had sufficient actual notice of the claim herein
asserted; and written notice was sent on behalf of Plaintiffs? minor daughter on February 9, 2000.
8. By reason of the foregoing, Plaintiffs, for and on behalf of their mino. daughter, are
‘entitled to recover compensatory damages in an amount to be shown upon trial of this cause.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs pray for judgment against Defendant Board of Education of
‘Carlsbad Municipal Schools, Defencant Shea Djang and Defendant Charlotte Neill for compensatory
damages, for costs of suit, and for such other relic as may be just
jaar Fa tn Dama
‘Gry nd ands Mais. ina Dt ok
PapeCOUNT Vi
COME NOW Plaintiffs Gary Maples and! Candace Maples, as parents and next friends of
Jessica Maples, a minor, and for a separste cause of action against Defendant Board of Education of
Carlsbad Municipal Schools, state:
1. >. Paragraphs 1 & 2 of Count land paragraphs 1 & 2 of Count If are incorporated herein
by reference and made a part hereof.
2 This Court has jurisdiction of this cause of action based upon 42 U.S.C §1983.
3, Defendant Board of Education of Carlsbad Municipal Schools is a political division
ot subdivision created and existing under the laws of the State of New Mexico.
4, Atal times material hereto, Defendant Board of Education of Carlsbad Municipal
‘Schools was acting, under color of law, in a manner of acts and omissions which deprived Plaintifi”
minor daughter of the rights, privileges and immunities secured to her by the Fourth, Bighth and/or
Fourteenth Amendments to the Constitution of the United States of America,
5. Ataall times material hereto, Defendant Board of Education of Carlsbad Municipal
‘Schools filed to supervise its teachers, coaches snd other school personne! at Carlsbad High School,
‘and had no effective or enforced policy regarding protecting female students from indecent abuse
and/or assault, and thus failed to prevent cénstitutional deprivations of the civil rights of female
students, such as that which occurred with Plaintiffs’ minor daughter on and before May 11, 1999.
6. ‘The omissions of Defendant Board of Education of Carlsbad Municipal Schools as
aforesaid were a
trary, reckless, and shocking to the conscience,
7. The omissions of Defendant Board of Education of Carlsbad Municipal Schools as
aforesaid amounted to a deliberate and reckless inference to the rights of female students, including
Plaintfs? minor daughter, and worked to deprive Plaintiffs’ minor daughter, and others, of civil and
‘personal rights and freedoms,
Sag Fel Epa od ar ne Das
‘hey nd Canes Malar cos Dig a
Pees8 ‘The aforesaid omissions further created danger and the risk of harm to Plaintiffs”
‘minor daughter, and others, at the said schoo! facility.
9. Asadirect and proximate result of the aforesaid omissions of Defendant Board of
Education of Carlsbad Municipal Schools, and in violation of Jessica Maples’ civil rights, the said
minor was indecently abused and assaulted by Defendant Lincoln Djang, al! to her physical and
emotional harm. :
10. The damages sustained by Plaintiff” minor daughter as aforesaid, including the
violation of and injury to her body and personal integrity, and her emotional suffering, all as will be
shown upon trial ofthis cause
11. The egregious and reckless conduct of Defendant Board of Education of Carlsbad
“Municipal Schools gives rise to punitive damages, as will be shown upon tral of this cause,
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs pray for judgment against Defendant Board of Education of
Carlsbad Municipal Schools for compensatory demages, for punitive damages, for costs of suit, for
attorney fees (42. U.S.C. §1988), and for such other relief as may be just.
Ralph ef
Attorney for Plaintif?
Post Office Box 2447
Roswell, New Mexico 88202-2447
(505) 623-2670
‘Sag Reis Fr Pn Ds
Gayestbis}
OFFICE
OO AUG IS PM 4:03
FIFTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
COUNTY OF EDDY ELEANOR JARNAGIN
STATE OF NEW MEXICO DISTRICT COURT CLERK
GARY MAPLES and CANDACE MAPLES,
‘As Parents and Next Friends of Jessica
‘Maples, a minor,
Plaintifis,
‘No. CV 2000-290
LINCOLN DIANG, SHEA DJANG,
CHARLOTTE NEILL, USA SWIMMING,
INC, and BOARD OF EDUCATION OF
CARLSBAD MUNICIPAL SCHOOLS,
Defendants.
NOTICE OF FILING OF NOTICE OF REMOVAL
Please take notice that on the _L¢{ day of August 2000, Defendants, Board of
Eiiucation of Carlsbad Municipal Schools, Charlotte Neill, and Shea DJang filed a Notice of
Removal, a copy of whichis attached hereto, in the Office of the Clerk of the United States
istict Court for the District of New Mexico.
MAREK, FRANCIS & BYERS P.A.
i B y am
i am Marek
110 W. Shaw
P.O, Drawer AA,
Carlsbad, NM 88221-7520
i Phone: (505) 885-6615
Fax: (505) 885-1701
E-Mail: tom@iawyersnm.com
Attomeys for Defendants, Board of Education of
Carisbad Municipal Schools, Charlotte Neill, and
‘Shea Dang,
ay"The undersigned certifies that a true copy of the foregoing was mailed to the following
counsel of record this £44 day of August, 2000:
Dick A. Blenden, Esq.
Blenden Law Firm
P.O. Box 1446
Carlsbad, NM 88221
Denise Madrid-Boyea, Esq
MeCormick Law Firm
P. 0, Box 1718
Carlsbad, NM 88221
Rudolph A. Lucero, Esq.
Miller Law Firm
P.O. Box 25687
‘Albuquerque, NM 87125-0687
Relph Shamus, Esq.
Polen 2a7
‘Roswell, NM 88202-2447
Hessel E. Yntema, Esq.
P.O. Box 1748
Albuquerque, NM 87103-1748GARY MAPLES and CANDACE MAPLES,
As Parents and Next Friends of Jessica
Maples, a minor,
vs.
LINCOLN DJANG, SHEA DIANG,
CHARLOTTE NEILL, USA SWIMMING,
INC, and BOARD OF EDUCATION OF
CARLSBAD MUNICIPAL SCHOOLS.
Defendants,
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW MEXICO
Plaintiffs,
No.
)
)
)
)
)
2
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
NOTICE OF REMOVAL
Defendants, Board of Education of Carlsbad Municipal Schools, Charlotte Neill,
‘and Shea Dang, in the above-styled matter state:
‘This civil action has been commenced and is now pending in the Fifth Judicial
District, County of Eddy, State of New Mexico as cause No. CV 2000-290 , wherein Gary
‘Maples and Candace Maples, as parents and Next Friends of Jessica Maples, @ minor, are
Plaintiffs and Lincoln Djang, Shea Djang, Charlotte Neill, USA Swimming, Inc, and Boat
‘of Education of Carisbad Municipal Schools are Defendants.
2
‘The nature of this suit is as follows:
Count 1 against Lincoln Djang: Indecent sexual comments and overtures
Count 2 against Lincoln Djang: Battery and/or assault
Count 3 against Lincoln Djang: Negligence
Count 4 against USA Swimming, Inc.: Respondeat superior because of Lincoln
Djang and Shea Djang
‘Count 5 against Shea Djang and USA Swimming, Inc.: Negligence
Count 6 against USA Swimming, Inc.: NegligenceCount 7 against Board of Education of Carlsbad Municipal Schools, Charlotte Neill
and Shea Djang - operation ane maintenance of premises
Count 8 against Board of Education of Carlsbad Municipal Schools - civil rights
3. This action in Count 8 involves a federal question arising under the constitution and
laws of the United States pursuant to 28 U.S.C.§1331.
4. This court has removal jurisdiction over this action pursuant to 28 U.S.C.§1441(b),
and this petition i timely filed pursuant to 28 U.S.C.§1446(6).
5. ‘These Defendants allege service of the other Defendants as follows:
‘A. Plaintiff's Complaint filed 21 June 2000,
B, Lincoln Djang - has not been served,
C. Shea Djang - served 27 June 2000, but she has not answered the Complaint,
* A Limited Entry of Appearance was filed on her behalf as to Count 7 on 17
Joly 2000,
U.S.A. Swimming, Inc. - served 29 June 2000 and answered the Complaint
in State Court on 21 July 2000.
E, _ Board of Education for Carlsbad Municipal Schools and Charlotte Neill -
served 17 July 2000.
6. Copies of all process, pleadings and orders served upon this Defendant are attached
hereto as Exhibit A and made a part hereof.
7. A-copy of Plaintiffs’ Complaint was served upon this Defendant, Charlotte Neill
‘and Board of Education of Carlsbad Municipal Schools, on 17 July 2000.
8. Defendants, immediately upon filing this notice, have given written notice of the
filing thereof to all parties as required by 28 U.S.C.§1446(d) and has filed a copy of this,
Notice with the Clerk of the Court from which this action was removed as required by 28
US.C.§1446(d).‘The co-defendants’ position concerning this removal:
A
B.
Lincoln Djang - objects to the removal:
‘Shea Djang - does not object to the removal to the extent of the Limited
Entry of Appearance on her behalf;
Charlotte Neill - concurs in the cemoval; and
U.S.A. Swimminig, In. objects to the removal.
MAREK, FRANCIS & BYERS P.A.
P.O. Drawer AA,
Carlsbad, NM 88221-7520
Phone: (505) 885-6615
Fax: (505) 885-1701
E-Mail: tom@lawyersam.com
Attorneys for Defendants, Board of
Education for the Carlsbad Municipal
‘Schools, Charlotte Neill, and Shea DJangFIFTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT
COUNTY OF EDDY
STATE OF NEW MEXICO
GARY MAPLES and CANDACE MAPLES,
As Parents and Next Friends of
Jessica Maples, a minor,
Plaintitts,
%
LINCOLN DIANG, SHEA DJANG,
CHARLOTTE NEILL,
USA SWIMMING, INC, and
BOARD OF EDUCATION OF
CARLSBAD MUNICIPAL SCHOOLS,
Defendants.
VU
Q) cean27 PH
ini
sfRICT COURT HER
No. CV-2000-290
Judge Jay W. Forbes
MOTION TO DISMISS WITH PREJUDICE
a NN A
COME NOW tbe Plaintifis herein, throughi counsel, and move for a dismissal o%any and all
remaining causes of action in this case as to all Defendants, including Defendant Lincoln Djang, and
as grounds therefor state that all matters in controversy have bern settled and resolved.
Thecy ly tht copy of he eng
‘esto aypsng ouster is
i arta, 208
Ageef-—$
napledptotictooniss
ae
Ralph D. Shamas
“Attorn for Plaintifis
Post Guice Box 2447
Roswell, New Mexico 88202-2447
(505) 623-2670FIFTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT
COUNTY OF EDDY
STATE OF NEW MEXICO
GARY MAPLES and CANDACE MAPLES,
As Parents and Next Friends of Jessica Maples, a minor,
Plaintitts,
¥ No. CV-2000-290
LINCOLN DIANG, SHEA DIANG,
CHARLOTTE NEILL, USA SWIMMING, INC.,
and BOARD OF EDUCATION OF CARLSBAD
MUNICIPAL SCHOOLS,
Defendants.
ORDER OF DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE,
THIS MATTER bavicig come on to be heard by the Court upon the Motion to Dismiss with
Prejudice, and the Court being fuliv sdvised in the premises, finds that said Motion should be granted.
IT IS, THEREFORE, ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that any and all
‘remaining causes of action in this case, including those against Defendant |.incoln Djang, are hereby
dismissed with prejudice, each party to bear their own costs.
oa a pee
Ralph D. Shamas
Attorney for Plaintis
wed by;
ie Blk
Dick Blenden
Attorney for Defendant Lincoln Djang
epi ptereatnsa