Motor Electrical
Fluting
Using Vibration Analysis to Detect
& Prevent
Outline
Introduction
Cause & Effect
Identifying the Problem
Bearing life
Bearing examples
Protection Methods
Janelle Hammes
Electric Motor and
Repair, Inc
West Columbia, SC
Originally from
Rockford, IL
In the motor
business for 2 years
Vibration Description
Cause & Effect
VFD Induced Shaft Bearing Damage
Voltage
Higher Carrier Insulation & Bearing
Frequency Damage
Constant Speed Bearing Damage
Operation
Inadequate Bearing Damage
Grounding
Excessive
Bearing Damage
Loads/Over Heating
Identifying the Problems cont.
Identifying the Problems
Vibration Analysis
helpful in confirming
bearing fluting
(damage)
Continuous
monitoring/testing
from installation on is
recommended
P.M is key
Identifying the Problems cont.
Here are some examples of what to look for
when you are performing a vibration analysis.
Identifying the Problems cont.
Here is a good comparison of the good bearing
vs the bad bearing. The difference is quite
obvious.
Identifying the Problems cont.
Identifying the Problems cont.
Voltage Analysis can
be used to determine
the likelihood of
damage
This method is not
an exact science,
however it is helpful
Identifying the Problem cont.
SKF Electrical
Discharge Detector
Pen
Does not tell you
what the problem is
only a tool to assist
in detection
Bearing life
Bearing Life
New Bearing Race
New bearing race will
be smooth
Track will eventually
form
Bearing Damage
Pitting
Early damage
Bearing Damage Cont.
Birnelling
Bearing Damage cont.
Fluting: “washboard” pattern.
Vibration
Noise
Bearing Damage cont.
Rust damage /
corrosion
Bearing Damage Cont.
Excessive load /
Overheating
Brinelling and
Discoloration
Protection Methods
Shaft grounding
Protection Methods cont.
Insulated/ceramic bearings or insulating the bearings
Protection Methods cont.
Faraday Shield
Protection Methods cont.
Sine wave filter
Or DV/DT filter
Protection Methods cont.
Conductive grease
Can interfere with the
performance of the
shaft protector
Protection Methods cont.
Bearing Protection
Ring (SGR)
Bearing Installation Tips
Handle with care Verify bearing ring &
Inspect shaft & bearing seat
housing Don’t clean new
Avoid overheating bearings
Use the same Proper lubrication
bearing that is Rotate idle bearings
replaced Look for danger
Use correct tools signs
Pay attention Find the cause of
failure
Thank you