Transformer Surge Control Analysis
Transformer Surge Control Analysis
1, 2010, 11–19
The paper deals with simulating the circumstances of switching surge and trigger current at switching-in of the T402
autotransformer recently installed in Križovany, with the tests conducted by means of ATP (Alternative Transient Program)
simulation software for simulating transient electromagnetic phenomena. The target has been to determine temporal curves
for the most critical surge instances against earth and between the phases and the curves for trigger current with and without
surge limiters connected, and to determine by means of simulations the size and statistical frequency of switching surges and
based on a controlled switching simulation, to describe the elimination of transient phenomena during the process and in
reference to the simulations and to operating manual for the PSD02 Siemens control unit, suggest the required configuration
settings for the unit.
K e y w o r d s: switching surge, trigger current, substation, transformer, T402 transformer, EMTP - ATP, Križovany,
surge current
∗
Faculty of Electrical Engineering and Information Technology of the Slovak University of Technology in Bratislava, Ilkovičova 3,
812 19 Bratislava, frantisek.janicek@stuba.sk, martin.mucha@stuba.sk;
∗∗
VÚJE, a. s., Okružná 5, 918 64 Trnava, cesnek@vuje.sk, kovacik@vuje.sk,
3 SWITCHING ON OF IDLE TRANSFORMER In Fig. 2, the frequency curve is shown for emergent
WITHOUT SURGE LIMITER switching surges under non-controlled switching of idle
TR402 over the entire period.
The following Chapter provides the results for theoret- The peak phase-to-phase closing surge reached a value
ical surge voltages in switching on idle transformer with- 2.5 times higher than nominal voltage — 815.9 kV and
out attached surge limiter. In order to determine statisti- 1150 kV respectively between phases, ie, two times the
cal frequency distribution for switching surges in switch-
value but less than nominal proof voltage for switching
ing on idle T402 transformer, simulations by means of
impulse against earth — 1050 kV and 1500 kV respec-
ATP software have been conducted employing a special
tively between phases.
STATISTICAL SWITCH. Over the period of a network
voltage cycle (T = 0.02 s) for 20 evenly distributed points Temporal curves for maximum emergent surge volt-
in the cycle in ∆t = 1 ms intervals, 600 closing instances ages are shown in Figs. 3 and 4. Peak value for closing
have been simulated for an identical mean closing time current in the initial period was 556.77 A, switch recovery
value; in total in each period for 20 selected points in the voltage was 538 kV as shown in Figs. 5 and 6. The closing
cycle, 12000 transformer switching on instances have been current peak value caused by charging residual capacities
conducted with three switch contacts featuring Gaussian did not occur this time as the most unfavourable circum-
statistical distribution curve for each contact closing with stances in inductivity switching are the most favourable
Journal of ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING 61, NO. 1, 2010 13
Fig. 3. Maximum phase-to-neutral surge voltage for primary con- Fig. 4. Maximum interphase surge voltage for primary connectors
nectors for TR402 Križovany for switching o idle TR402 without for TR402 Križovany for switching on idle TR402 without surge
surge limiter limiter
Fig. 6. Closing current curve for non-controlled switching of idle TR402 Križovany without surge limiter: (a) — overall curve, (b) —
detail for the initial phase, (c) — FFT for the initial period, (d) — detail after 10 seconds, (e) — FFT for the last period
Fig. 8. Peak phase-to-neutral surge voltage curve for primary con- Fig. 9. Peak interphase surge voltage curve for primary connectors
nectors of TR 402 Križovany for switching on idle TR402 Križovany of TR402 Križovany for switching on idle TR402 with connected
with connected 336/367 surge limiter 336/367 surge limiter
Fig. 10. Recovery voltage curve for the QM TR402 Križovany Fig. 11. Closing current curve for non-controlled switching on of
switch in switching on idle TR402 with connected 336/367 surge idle transformer TR402 Križovany with connected 336/367 surge
limiter limiter
Fig. 12. Phase-to-neutral voltage curve for primary connectors of Fig. 13. Phase-to-phase voltage curve for primary connectors of
TR402 Križovany in controlled switching TR402 Križovany in controlled switching
phase by one third of the period. However, due to mag- increases to nominal value. The current is separated by
netic coupling between the different phases, the closing se- the remaining part of the core in which magnetic current
quence would not prevent switching surge from emerging. is not generated by the remaining windings. If the remain-
For switching idle three-phase transformers with earthed ing two phases are applied simultaneously one fourth of a
neutral, one phase is applied at the peak of its supply period of 5ms (peak point of phase-to-phase voltage be-
voltage (with acceptable tolerance of 2 ms from the peak tween the two phases) after the first phase as their values
credit to fair gradient of the sine curve in the area). For are equal in nominal terms yet of opposite polarity (mag-
sudden changes, voltage affects inductivity immediately, netic current generated by the first winding voltage being
ie, one phase remains at nominal voltage and magnetic zero at the point, zero voltage exposure time), magnetic
current in the respective part of the transformer core also current for the remaining two windings remain separated
16 F. Janı́ček — M. Mucha — K. Česnek — J. Kováčik: CONTROLLED SWITCHING OF THE T402 TRANSFORMER IN . . .
Fig. 15. Phase-to-neutral voltage curve for primary connectors of 7 DETERMINING CONTROLLED SWITCHING
TR402 Križovany in controlled switching with early phase switching PARAMETERS FOR SIEMENS PSD02 UNIT
by 2 ms against peak values
Fig. 16. Closing current curve for three phases for TR 402 Fig. 18. Closing current curve for three phases for TR 402
Križovany in controlled switching (a) — with early phase switching Križovany in controlled switching with delayed phase switching
by 2ms against peak value, (b) — detail (a) by 2 ms against peak value, (b) — detail
Fig. 17. Phase-to-neutral voltage curve for primary connectors Fig. 19. Phase-to-neutral voltage curve for primary connectors
of TR402 Križovany in controlled switching with delayed phase of TR402 Križovany in controlled switching without considering
switching by 2 ms against peak value residual capacities of windings
in standard operation. In the following sections, ideal • In-switch arc pre-ignition time at half the maxi-
parameter calculation for the PSD02 unit is described. mum
√
value of momentary phase-to-phase voltage value
2 2
Data provided by the manufacturer of the switch em- 2 U n tprearc ;
Where Un is network nominal phase-to-phase voltage.
ployed (best measured and for each pole):
In compiling the study, it has not been possible to ob-
• Mechanical operating time for the switch — tbreaker ± tain the data from the switch manufacturer which is why
0.1 ms; the following text may serve as a theoretical guide for cal-
culating controlled switching parameters. After obtaining
• In-switch arc pre-ignition time at maximum momen-
q the required times, the formulas may be easily populated
2 1
tary phase-to-neutral voltage value 3 Un − tprearc ; with the values.
18 F. Janı́ček — M. Mucha — K. Česnek — J. Kováčik: CONTROLLED SWITCHING OF THE T402 TRANSFORMER IN . . .
Fig. 20. Phase-to-neutral voltage curve for primary connectors of Fig. 21. Phase-to-phase voltage for primary connectors of TR402
TR402 Križovany in switching off idle transformer Križovany in switching off idle transformer
Set parameter (phase shift/pole) in degrees separately voltage and 2.65 times the value of phase-to-phase volt-
for each phase to age, with installed surge limiter a maximum of 1.75 times
the nominal value of phase-to-neutral voltage and 1.54
A = 90◦ , B = 180◦, C = 180◦ . times phase-to phase voltage and closing current may
reach several times the value of idle current. The val-
Set parameter (adjusting time – closing, or arcing time ues are lower than nominal proof voltage against earth
– opening ) in ms separately for each phase at negative at closing impulse — 1050 kV and 1500 kV respectively
value between phases but with automated switching control,
transient phenomena are eliminated, thus protecting the
A = −t1prearc , B = −t2prearc , C = −t2prearc . transformer as a preventive measure but also the trans-
former switch and other equipment exposed to the effects.
Set parameter (closing time/opening time) – if not set Based on the simulations, parameters are specified at
initially – to the end automated controls on the Siemens PSD02 unit
tbreaker . need to be set for in controlled switching of transform-
ers with earthed neutral on the switched side. It has not
Should it prove impossible to obtain the required been possible to obtain exact arc preignition times for
switch data from the switch manufacturer, we recom- specific switches and voltages and mechanical switch clos-
mend to initiate the ing times, hence only variables are indicated for the val-
q closing test with a preignition time √
t1prearc = 3 ms at 2
and t2prearc = 2.5 ms at 2 ues to which the particular parameters need to be set in
3 Un 2 Un
follow-up to obtaining the data from the manufacturer.
and mechanical operating time for the switch of tbreaker = Should it prove impossible to obtain the data, we pro-
40 ms. vide reference values that shall be used for setting up
The results of the oscillographic record of closing cur- test assemblies and further elaborated in more detail in
rent at closing test (but also if initial setting is left reference to obtained results as is the standard procedure
on), we recommend to check the closing current oscil- in some cases for setting up controlled switching.
logram. Ideal closing times can be derived from cal-
culated times: closing time, make time, command delay Acknowledgements
and closing time difference for the last closing instance
recorded by the equipment, by changing values of the pa- The paper has been compiled under grant provided by
rameters, adjusting time – closing, or arcing time – open- scientific research grant agency with the Ministry of Edu-
ing — based on recorded curves towards reaching mini- cation of the Slovak Republic and the Slovak Academy of
mum closing current. Sciences 1/3092/06 and of the Slovak Agency for Research
and Development under Ref. No. APVV - 20-023505.
CONCLUSION
References
In the article, simulation results are indicated of simu-
lating closing surge voltage for the Križovany substations [1] JANÍČEK, F.—MARTON, K.—BELÁŇ, A.—DOLNÍK, B.—
ELESCHOVÁ, Ž.—SZATHMÁRY, P.—MUCHA, M. : Deter-
in switching on newly installed idle transformers.
mination of the overvoltage–limiter parameters in Slovak trans-
The simulation results imply that in non-controlled mission system, FEI STU, Bratislava, 2006. (in Slovak)
switching of idle transformers, closing surge voltage may [2] VEVERKA, A. : High Voltage Technology, Státnı́ nakladatelstvı́
reach theoretically 2.5 times the value of phase-to-neutral technické literatury ŠVTL, Praha-Bratislava, 1979. (in Czech)
Journal of ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING 61, NO. 1, 2010 19
[3] MARTON, K. : High Voltage Technology, Vydavatestvo ALFA, in 1979 and took the position of assistant lecturer with the
Bratislava, 1983. (in Slovak) Department of Electrical Power Engineering of EF SVT. In
[4] HUDEC, J. : Overvoltage and Electromagnetic Compatibility, 1984 received his PhD in the field of Electrical Power Engi-
HAKEL, Praha, 1996. (in Czech) neering, in 1989, was appointed Associate Professor from 1999
[5] MARTON, K. : Surge protection of electricity and computer he is a Full Professor. He was the Dean of the Faculty of Elec-
networks, Seminar: ”Počı́tačová bezpečnost’”, collection of ab- trical Engineering and Informatics of STU in Bratislava (2000
stracts, Banská Bystrica, pp. 23–34. (in Slovak) – 2007), and the Vice rector for development of the Slovak
[6] MARTON, K. : Placement of surge protection in computer University of Technology since (2007). He is a leading expert
networks, Seminar: ”Počı́tačová bezpečnost’”, collection of ab-
in the area of electrical power engineering. He authored or co-
stracts, Agentúra SH Banská Bystrica, 1997, pp. 4-12. (in Slo-
vak)
authored university textbooks and lecture books, four expert
[7] MARTON, K. : Overvoltage protection HV VHV and UVH
monographs, more than 50 articles in periodicals, and more
devices, ELMAX - collection of abstracts, Bratislava, 2002. (in than 100 lectures at international scientific conferences (in-
Slovak) cluding invited lectures). He has solved more than 80 projects
[8] MARTON, K. et al : Theoretical analysis of overvoltage for technical practice. One of the co-founders of the Internet
switchgear protection respecting the EMC, ”20. Konferen- based information and education project INFELEN (informa-
cia elektrotechnikov Slovenska”, collection, Bratislava, 2004, tion on electrical power engineering), founder of EE Magazine
pp. 16–28. (in Slovak) and a member of the editorial board with the same. He is
[9] MARTON, K. : Surge phenomena in power engineering and a member of the Slovak board of WEC SR, statutory officer
their elimination, CD Presentation, Fakulta elektrotechnická ŽU of the EE Association (8 participating organisations) and a
v Žiline,, 2005. (in Slovak) member of several scientific boards of SR universities. He was
[10] MARTON, K. : Protection of computer networks against over- a reviewer of several major projects relating to the liberal-
voltages, Vydavatestvo MERCURY Smékal, Košice, 2001. (in ization of electricity markets and a member of the team that
Slovak) developed the SR Energy Policy. As of 2006, he has been the
[11] Raychem Matters: ZnO limiter choice and usage atHV lines chairman of the board for technical sciences with the Slovak
Energy Division Raychen 1996.
Research and Development Agency.
[12] STN EN 99-5 Surge voltage protector, recommendations for the
selection and use.
Martin Mucha graduated from the Faculty of Electrical
Engineering and information technology at the Slovak Uni-
[13] BIEKFORD, J. P. et al : Computation of Power System Tran-
sients, Peter Peregrinus Ltd., England, 1976. versity of Technology in 2004, in the same year he took the
[14] ABB Wettingen, User guide, overvoltage protection. position of assistant lecturer with the Department of Electri-
cal Power Engineering of FEI STU. In 2007, he received his
[15] TICHÝ, V. : ZnO overvoltage limiters, CD nosič, TYCO, RAY-
CHEN, Energy Division, Bratislava, 2004. (in Slovak)
PhD in the field of Electrical Power Engineering at EI STU.
At present is working on power system protection research.
[16] HASMAN, T. : Surge in power engineering networks, Vydava-
telstvı́ ČVUT, Praha, 1997. (in Czech) Karol Česnek graduated from the Faculty of SED VD
[17] ŠANDRIK, P. : High voltage technology, STU v Bratislave, in 1970. He started with the Department of Maintenance of
2004. (in Slovak) Power Transformers in ZSE Bratislava. In 1981 he became
[18] MAYER, D. : Electrodynamics in power engineering, BEN Head of Department for maintenance and prophylactic mea-
Technická literatura, Praha, 2005. (in Czech) surements in electric distribution with a nationwide scope.
[19] KUTÁČ, J. : SPBI Praha, Dehn u. Söhne Neumarkt 2006, New Since 1984 he worked as Deputy Director of Operations and
proposals for EU standards in theory and practice, EN IEC Technology ZSE Bratislava. Since 1990, he worked as Deputy
62305 Lightning protection. (in Czech) Director General SEP Bratislava, where later in the trans-
[20] GERT, R. : Operating surges in power systems, SNTL, Praha, formation to the SE and Bratislava tenure as the director
1964 pages142. (in Czech) and Chairman of the directorate. worked as project manager
[21] JIRKŮ, J.—POPOLANSKÝ, F. : Overvoltage on in-air power of reconstruction Tr Kriovany . He cooperated and led the
network, SNTL, Praha, 1966, pp. 256. (in Czech) working group to develop operating rules for distribution and
[22] DUGAN, R. C.—McCRANAGHAN, M. F.—BEATY, H. W. : power transformers. The international symposia and confer-
Electrcal Power Systems Quality, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1996, ences within the group Interelektro had 10 technical contribu-
pp. 265. tions.
[23] GREENWOOD, A. : Electrical Transients in Power Systems, Jozef Kováčik graduated from the Faculty of Electri-
John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1991 pages751. cal Engineering (EF) at the Slovak University of Technology
[24] STN EN 6099-4 surge voltage protection - non arrester gap surge (SVT, later STU) in 1981 and started with the Department of
voltage protection.
Maintenance of Power Transformers in ZSE Bratislava. In that
[25] STN EN 60071-1 Insulation coordination - definitions, princi-
position he was involved on Operational Diagnostics of power
ples, rules.
devices within power substations. Regarding of technical fo-
[26] STN EN 60071-2 Insulation coordination - users guide.
cus of that Department one was dealing within whole terri-
[27] ABB Surge Arresters – Buyer’s Guide Edition 5, 2004-10. Cat-
tory of Slovakia. It was done in connection with SE Bratislava
alog Publ: 1HSM 9543 12-00en.
and SEPS Bratislava. Nowadays these technical activities are
[28] TRIDELTA Metal Oxide Surge Arrester for High Voltage Sys-
tems.
doing in connection with company VUJE, a.s. Trnava. He au-
thored or co-authored 15 articles in periodicals, and 10 lectures
Received 8 September 2009 at international scientific conferences. In area of Diagnostics
of Power Transformers the technical works were done within
František Janı́ček graduated from the Faculty of Electri- Power Grid of Slovakia as well with partners from abroad in
cal Engineering (EF) at the Slovak University of Technology Europe.