RESTRICTED
PRESENTATION SCRIPT– OPERATION OVERLORD
1. COMDT, CDS, DS BODY AND FELLOW COURSE MEMBERS. TODAY MY SUB
SYNDICATE GROUP 8 WILL PRESENT OPERATION OVERLORD IN 1944. BEFORE
WE GO ANY FURTHER I SHALL INTRODUCE THE MEMBERS OF MY SUB
SYNDICATE GROUP (SLIDE SHOWING NAMES OF SSG).
A. MEJ ZAINUDIN BIN BAHARI.
B. LT KDR JAMALUDIN BIN SAIRI.
C. MEJ IBRAHIM BIN MD YUSOFF TUDM.
D. MAJ ZUBACA AHMED.
AIM
2. THE AIM OF THIS PRESENTATION IS TO STUDY AND ANALYSE THE
OPERATION OVERLORD AND DERIVE THE LESSONS LEARNT FROM THAT
OPERATION.
SCOPE
3. THIS PRESENTATION WILL COVER THE FOLLOWING SCOPE:
a. BACKGROUND OF THE BATTLE.
b. ANALYSIS OF THE BATTLE.
c. LESSON LEARNT.
d. CONCLUSION.
e. QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS.
1
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
BACKGROUD OF THE BATTLE
ORIENTATION
BEFORE EXPLAINING THE BATTLE LET US HAVE A LOOK AT THE
GEOGRAPHY OF THE OPERATION OVERLORD.
TOWARDS TO THE NORTH IS GREAT BRITAIN. TO THE SOUTH IS FRANCE,
SEPARATED BY THE ENGLISH CHANNEL. THE SHORTEST DISTANCE FROM
ENGLAND TO FRANCE IS FROM DOVER TO CALAIS. THE BLUE ARROW
INDICATED THE ASSAULT APPROACH OF THE ALLIED FORCES TO NORMANDY.
DESCRIPTION
IN 1940 THE BRITISH PRIME MINISTER, SIR WINSTON CHURCHILL
ORDERED THE CREATION OF A JOINT PLANNING GROUP TO START WORK ON
THE BRITISH RETURN TO THE CONTINENT OF EUROPE.
ON JULY 1941, THE US ARMY’S PLANNERS PRESENTED TO PRESIDENT
ROOSEVELT A PLAN KNOWN AS THE ‘VICTORY PROGRAM’. IN APRIL 1942, THE
US ARMY CHIEF OF STAFF, GENERAL GEORGE MARSHALL ARRIVED IN LONDON
TO DISCUSS JOINT ACTION AGAINST THE GERMAN.
AFTER LENGTHY DISCUSSION WITH THE BRITISH AND THE SOVIET
UNION, FULL UNDERSTANDING WAS REACHED WITH REGARD TO THE URGENT
TASKS OF CREATING A SECOND FRONT IN EUROPE. HOWEVER, THE FIRST
CONCRETE STEP WAS NOT TAKEN UNTIL MARCH 1943, WHEN MAJOR GENERAL
FREDERICK MORGAN WAS APPOINTED AS CHIEF OF STAFF TO THE SUPREME
2
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
ALLIED COMMANDER. ON JUNE 1943, THE BRITISH AND AMERICAN CHIEF OF
STAFF IN WASHINGTON TOOK THE SECOND STEP WHEREBY, FIRST MAY 1944
WAS NAMED AS THE TARGET DATE FOR THE INVASION WHICH IS TO BE
CALLED OPERATION OVERLORD.
THE COSSAC PLAN FOR FIRST MAY 1944 LANDING WAS PRESENTED TO
ROOSEVELT AND CHURCHILL IN AUGUST 1943 AT THE QUEBEC CONFERENCE.
ON 30th NOVEMBER 1943, THE BRITISH AND THE US HIGH COMMAND ISSUED
THE DIRECTIVE FOR OPERATION OVERLORD. ROOSEVELT APPOINTED
GENERAL DWIGHT DAVID EISENHOWER AS THE SUPREME COMMANDER FOR
THE OPERATION. THE OPERATION OVERLORD ASSAULT STARTED ON 6 JUNE
1944.
THE ALLIED LAND FORCES COMPRISED OF US FIRST ARMY AND BRITISH
SECOND ARMY, WHICH WAS HEADED BY FIELD MARSHALL BERNARD
MONTGOMERY. THE NAVAL FORCES WERE COMPRISED OF SIX HUNDRED
WARSHIPS AND 4,000 VESSELS, WHILE THE ALLIED AIR FORCES WERE
CONSISTED OF 331 US SQUADRONS AND 220 BRITISH SQUADRONS.
D-DAY DIARY OF EVENT. THE SIGNIFICAN TIMING ON 6 JUNE ARE AS FOLLOW:
0016 – CAEN CANAL: 6 BRITISH ARMY GLIDERS LAND TO SECURE VITAL
BRIDGES
• 0130 – NORMANDY: THE GERMAN ARMY RAISES THE INVASION ALERT
• 0240 – FRANCE: BRITISH PARA DROP EAST OF THE ORNE RIVER & US
FLOATING HQ ANCHOR OF UTAH & OMAHA BEACHES.
3
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
• 0500 – BERCHTESGADEN: NEWS OF THE ALLIED INVASION REACHES
HITLER HQ.
• 0530 – NORMANDY: BRITISH NAVAL BOMBARDMENT BEGIN.
• 0631 – NORMANDY: US INF LAND ON UTAH BEACH.
• 0725 – NORMANDY: BRITISH FORCE LAND ON SWORD & GOLD
BEACHES.
• 0735 – NORMANDY: CANADIAN INF LAND ON JUNO BEACH.
• 1200 – KLESSHEIM: HITLER HOLDS A CONFERENCE.
• 1600 - LA ROCHE GUYON: ROMMEL ARRIVED FROM GERMANY.
• 1655– BERCHTESGADEN: HITLER ORDERED THE ALLIED BRIDGEHEAD
ANNIHILATED BY EVENING 6 JUNE.
• 1850 – BLETCHLEY PARK: BRITISH CODE BREAKER’S DISCOVER
GERMAN UNCERTAINTY OF THE PLACE OF ALLIED INVASION.
• 2055 – NORMANDY: FIGTHING DIES DOWN ALONG THE ENTIRE FRONT
• 2300 – HITLER HOLDS 2ND CONFERENCE.
VCD SHOW. BEFORE WE PRESENT THE ANALYSIS OF THE BATTLE, WE WILL
SHOW A SHORT VIDEO CLIP ON THE ASSAULT AT NORMANDY.
ANALYSIS OF THE BATTLE.
4
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
ORBAT OF THE BATTLE
ALLIED FORCES. HEADED BY GEN EISENHOWER AND THE ORBAT ARE
AS SHOWN ON THE SLIDE.
GERMAN FORCES. HEADED BY FIELD MARSHAL VON RUNSTEDT AND
THE ORBAT ARE AS SHOWN ON THE SLIDE.
OPERATIONS LEVEL PLANNING
ALLIED FORCES
A. GROUND FORCES PLAN. THE GROUND FORCES WERE TASKED TO
ASSAULT SIMULTANEOUSLY ON THE BEACHES OF NORMANDY
IMMEDIATELY NORTH OF CARENTAN STREAM UNTIL RIVER ORNE. THE
OBJECTIVE WAS TO SECURE A BASE FOR FURTHER OPERATION AND TO
INCLUDE AIRFIELD SITES AT THE PORT OF CHERBOURG AND BRITTANY.
ONCE ASHORE AND FIRMLY ESTABLISHED, THEY WERE TO BREAK OUT
ON THE EASTERN FLANK TO CAPTURE THE CITY OF CAEN.
B. NAVAL FORCES PLAN. THE NAVAL TASK FORCES WERE
RESPONSIBLE IN SUPPORTING THE LAND FORCES. THE WESTERN TASK
FORCE WAS TO SUPPORT THE US 1 ST ARMY WHILE THE EASTERN
TASKFORCE WAS TO SUPPORT THE BRITISH 2ND ARMY.
5
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
C. AIR FORCES PLAN. AS A DECEPTION PLAN, CRITICAL RATES AND
HEAVY BOMBING OF THE TARGETS IN THE PAS DE CALAIS AREA WERE
CARRIED OUT. THE AIR FORCES WERE ALSO TO ENGAGE THE
LUFTWAFFE TO WEAR DOWN ITS STRENGTH BEFORE THE LAND BATTLE
DEVELOPED. FOR THE D-DAY TASK, THE AIR FORCES WAS TO DEMOLISH
SELECTED TARGET WITHIN THE ENEMY COASTAL DEFENSES AND
SUPPORT THE TROOPS PROGRESSING INLAND.
D. THE AIRBORNE ASSAULT PLAN.
(1) TO THE WEST, THE 101ST US AIRBORNE DIVISION WAS TO
SECURE THE ROADS THAT LED OFF TO THE UTAH BEACH. THE 82 ND
US AIRBORNE DIVISION TO OCCUPY THE CROSSROADS OF SAINTE
MERE EGLISE AND CAPTURE TWO BRIDGES ACROSS THE
MERDERET RIVER.
(2) THE BRITISH 6TH AIRBORNE DIVISION WAS TO BE DROPPED
BETWEEN THE ORNE AND DIVES RIVER TO PROTECT THE LEFT
FLANK OF THE BRITISH FORCES LANDING ON SWORD BEACH.
E. ARMOR SUPPORT. THE NEED FOR ARMOURED SUPPORT WAS
VITAL AS SOON AS THE INFANTRY HAD LANDED. ON MARCH 1943,
GENERAL BROOKE TURNED THE 79 TH BRITISH ARMOUR DIVISION INTO
AN EXPERIMENTAL FORMATION WITH THE TASK OF DEVELOPING
ARMOURED TACTICS FOR THE INVASION.
6
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
F. CLOSE FIRE SUPPORT. STRONGER AND CLOSE FIRE SUPPORT
WAS NEEDED FOR THE FIRST WAVE OF ASSAULT. IT WAS ESSENTIAL
THAT THE GAP BETWEEN FORMATION COVERED BY ARTILLERY-GUNS,
MORTAR AND ROCKET BATTERIES, WHICH MOUNTED ON LANDING
CRAFTS AND GUN BOATS. TANKS ON LANDING CRAFTS WERE
FOLLOWING CLOSE BEHIND THE LEADING INFANTRY FOR PROVIDING
FIRE SUPPORT WHILE LANDING.
G. ASSAULT AREA. THE AREA FOR LANDING BASED ON THE THREE
SERVICES REQUIREMENT. NORMANDY THAT COVERS A DISTANCE OF 50
MILES OF THE COASTAL AREA WERE SUITABLE FOR ITS. THIS AREA WAS
THEN DIVIDED INTO TWO SECTORS FOR THE US 1 ST ARMY AND THE
BRITISH 2ND ARMY. THE AMERICANS WERE ALLOCATED THE WESTERN
SECTOR NAMED UTAH AND OMAHA. THE BRITISH AT THE EASTERN
SECTOR NAMED GOLG, JUNO AND SWORD.
H. THE NEED FOR HARBOUR. THE ALLIED ASSUMMED THAT ANY
PORT CAPTURED WOULD BE MINED OR DESTROYED BY THE GERMANS
DURING THEIR RETREAT. THEREFORE, THEY BUILT TWO ARTIFICIAL
HARBORS, TO ACCOMMODATE THE FLOW OF LOGISTIC SUPPORTS FOR
EACH FORMATION.
I. LANDING CRAFT. ON THE FIRST MAY 1944, THE LANDING
CRAFTS REQUIREMENT WAS NOT FULFILLED. THEREFORE THE DATE OF
7
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
THE LANDING HAVE BEEN POSTPONED TO THE FIRST WEEK OF JUNE
1944 TO ALLOW THE PRODUCTION OF LANDING CRAFT BY THE BRITISH
SHIPYARD.
K. TRAINING. THROUGHOUT THE EARLY PART OF 1944, ALL UNITS
WHICH INVOLVED IN THE BATTLE HAD STUDIED AND PRACTICED THE
HIGHLY SPECIALIZED SKILLS OF THEIR TRADE. AS INVASION
PREPARATIONS SPEED UP IN THE AUTUMN OF 1943, ONE AREA WAS
CHOSEN IN SOUTHERN ENGLAND FOR A SERIES OF CRUCIAL
MANOEUVRE. THIS TRAINING PRACTICE WAS SIMILAR TO THE GROUND
WHERE THE BATTLE WOULD TAKE PLACE.
GERMAN FORCES
A. CONCEPT OF DEFENSE IN THE YEARS THAT FOLLOWED THE
FALL OF FRANCE, THE GERMANS PUBLICIZED THE BUILDING OF AN
ATLANTIC WALL AGAINST ANY INVASION. BY THE END OF MARCH 1944,
GERMAN AGENTS IN BRITAIN CONFIRMED THAT THE ALLIED PLANNED
AN INVASION FROM SOUTHERN ENGLAND. TO MEET THE ALLIES
ASSAULT, THE COASTAL DEFENCE WAS PLANNED, WHICH WERE
CONCENTRATED AT THE BEACHES AND WERE NOT DEVELOPED ANY IN
DEPTH. THE BEACH DEFENSES WERE DESIGNATED TO STOP THE
ATTACKING FORCE BY OBSTACLES, MINES, AND EVERY TYPE OF
DEFENSIVE WEAPONS.
8
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
C. OBSTACLE PLAN. IN 1944, THE GERMANS HAD CONSTRUCTED A
SYSTEM OF OBSTACLES TO COUNTER ANY MASSIVE LANDINGS. THESE
OBSTACLES WERE ARMED WITH MINES OR IMPROVISED CHARGES. THE
POSTS WERE ANGLED SEAWARDS TO IMPEDE INCOMING CRAFT AND
THE EXPLOSIVES WERE ARMED WITH IMPACT DETONATOR. APART
FROM THAT, ANTI LANDING DEVICES WAS PLACED ON POTENTIAL
DROPPING AND LANDING AREAS.
THE CONDUCT OF OPERATION
ALLIED FORCES.
A. THE AIRBORNE ASSAULT - WESTERN FLANK. THE 101 US
AIRBORNE DIVISION COMMENCED LANDING AT 0130 HOURS D-DAY AT
THE CHERBOURG PENINSULA AND ADVANCED TO THE RIVER DOUVE
AND CAPTURED CARENTAN. THE 82 US DIVISION LANDED AT
CHERBOURG AT 0230 D-DAY AND CAPTURED SAINTE MERE EGLISE AT
0400 HOURS D-DAY WHILE 101 DIVISION CAPTURED CARENTAN AT 0600
HOURS.
B. THE AIRBORNE ASSAULT - EASTERN FLANK. THE FIRST AIR
OFFENSIVE INVOLVING 1,056 AIRCRAFTS OF RAF BOMBER COMMAND
WAS DIRECTED AGAINST THE TEN STRONGEST COASTAL BATTERIES ON
THE INVASION FRONTAGE, WHICH HAD BEEN DEALT BEFORE THE
ARRIVAL OF FIRST ELEMENT OF THE AIRBORNE DIVISION. AT 2000
9
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
HOURS D–1, 6 BRITISH AIRBORNE DIVISION PATHFINDERS TOOK OFF
FROM BRITAIN TO MARK OUT THE DROPPING ZONE AND LANDING AREA
FOR THE MAIN FORCE. THE GLIDER GROUP OF THE COUP DE MAIN
PARTY OF 6 AIRBORNE DIVISION LANDED AT BENOURVILLE AND
RANVILLE AT 0016 HOURS D-DAY AND CAPTURED THE STRUCTURE
INTACT. THE MAIN BODY OF THE 3 AND 5 BRIGADE THEN ARRIVED AT
0500 HOURS D-DAY TO TAKE HOLD ALL THE BRIDGES OVER THE CAEN
CANAL, RIVER ORNE AND RIVER DIVES FOLLOWED BY CAPTURING AND
NEUTRALIZING THE POWERFUL BATTERY AT MARVILLE.
C. PRE ASSAULT BOMBARDMENT.
(1) AIR BOMBING. THE ASSAULT LANDINGS WERE TO BE
PRECEEDED BY INTENSIVE AIR AND NAVAL BOMBARDMENT IN
THE HALF-HOUR BEFORE TOUCHDOWN. THE RAF WAS TO
CONCLUDE THE EFFORT AGAINST COASTAL BATTERIES WITH A
CONCENTRATED ATTACK FROM H-30 TO H-5.
(2) NAVAL BOMBARDMENT. NAVAL GUNFIRE COMMENCED AT
H-40 TO H-3. THE BATTLESHIPS FIRED FROM 18,000 YARDS
OFFSHORE, AND THREE CRUISERS FIRED ON THE ENEMY
DEFENCES NEAR PORT-EN-BASSIN. GUNS FROM THE LANDING
CRAFTS WERE FIRED TO ACCOMPANY THE LEADING ASSAULT
WAVE ON SELECTED STRONG POINTS BEGINNING AT H-20. TEN
LCT CARRIED THE 105-MM HOWITZERS (SELF-PROPELLED), FIRED
10
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
AT H-30 AT A RANGE OF 8,000 YARDS AND STOP FIRING AT A RANGE
OF 3700 YARDS BY H-5. THE TANK FIRED OVER THE RAMP,
BEGINNING FROM A RANGE OF 3,000 YARDS AT H–15. AT H
HOUR, NAVAL FIRES SHIFTED TO INLAND TARGETS.
D. THE SEABORNE ASSAULT.
(1) THE WESTERN SECTOR ASSAULT (US 1ST ARMY).
(A) THE H HOUR AT UTAH WAS AT 0630 HOUR AND 0725
HOUR AT OMAHA. THE FIRST UNIT TO TOUCH ON UTAH
BEACH WAS 8 REGT OF 4TH DIVISION AND FOLLOWED BY
THE DIVISION IN SUPPORT. AFTER CONFRONTED WITH
SOME POCKET OF GERMAN TROOPS, THEY MANAGED TO
SECURE THE BEACHHEAD AND AFTERWARD ADVANCED
INLAND TO LINK UP WITH 101 AIRBORNE DIVISION NEAR
VIERVILLE.
(B) AT OMAHA BEACH, FIRST DIVISION RECEIVED HEAVY
RESISTANCE, WHERE THEY HAD LOST MOST OF THEIR
SUPPORTING ARMOUR AND COMBAT ENGINEERS BEFORE
THEY REACHED THE SHORELINE. THE BEACH WAS
DOMINATED BY THE GERMANS WHO HAD TAKEN UP THE
POSITION ON THE HIGH GROUND. FINALLY, THEY MANAGED
11
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
TO MOVE OFF THE BEACHES AND BY NIGHTFALL ASSAULT A
MILE INLAND.
(2) THE EASTERN SECTOR ASSAULT (BRITISH).
(A) THE H HOUR AT GOLD AND SWORD WAS AT 0725
HOUR. HOWEVER, H HOUR AT JUNO WAS AT 0735 HOUR DUE
TO THE NAVIGATIONAL PROBLEM IN CROSSING OVER THE
OUTER OFFSHORE BEFORE REACHING THE BEACH.
(B) AT H HOUR, THE BRITISH 50TH DIVISION UNDER 30TH
CORPS CAME ASHORE GOLD BEACH. AFTER GOING
THROUGH A HARD WAY DUE TO ROUGH SEA AND BEACH
OBSTACLES, THEY SECURED THE BEACH HEAD AND
SUBSEQUENTLY ADVANCED INLAND TO CAPTURE BAYEUX
AT ABOUT 2100 HOURS D-DAY.
(C) ON THE RIGHT OF 1ST CORPS, THREE CANADIAN
DIVISIONS LANDED IN JUNO BEACH. DUE TO THE ROUGH
SEA AND WIND CONDITIONS, THE LANDING CRAFTS WERE
DELAYED AND ONLY SURVIVED UP TO 25 MINUTES LATER.
HOWEVER WITH THE SUPPORT OF 4 SPECIAL SERVICE
BRIGADE THEY CLEARED THE OBSTACLES OPPOSED BY THE
GERMAN AND CAPTURED CAEN.
12
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
(D) ON SWORD BEACH, 8 BRIGADE GROUP OF 3 BRITISH
DIVISIONS, SUPPORTED BY THE 1ST SPECIAL SERVICE
BRIGADE MANAGED TO SECURE THE BEACHHEAD
WITHOUT BEING CONFRONTED BY GERMAN TROOPS.
HAVING STARTED WITH RAPID CAPTURE OF HERMANVILLE,
THEY CONTINUED TO ADVANCE TO CAPTURE CAEN.
E. DECEPTION PLAN. THE ALLIED DECEPTION PLAN HAD LED
UNCERTAINTY TO THE GERMANS AND THE MOST EFFECTIVE
DECEPTIONS WERE THE THREE FORTITUDE SCHEMES.
FORTITUDE NORTH. A FICTITIOUS BRITISH FOURTH ARMY WAS
ESTABLISHED IN EDINBURGH FOR A PLANNED INVASION OF NORWAY.
DUMMY AIRCRAFTS WERE ALSO CONSTRUCTED, AND THE SHIPS THAT
WOULD TAKE PART FOR THE INVASION FORCE TO NORMANDY WERE
BASED IN SCOTLAND AS DECOY TO SUGGEST A NORWAY ATTACK.
FORTITUDE SOUTH. PLAYED ON THE EXPECTATIONS OF THE
GERMAN HIGH COMMAND, BY CREATING THE SO-CALLED 'FIRST US
ARMY GROUP', INTENDED TO ASSAULT ACROSS THE PAS DE CALAIS.
FORTITUDE SOUTH II. TOOK PLACE AFTER THE LANDINGS IN
NORMANDY HAD ACTUALLY HAPPENED. IT AGAIN USED FALSE
COMMUNICATIONS, AND OFFERED A FAKE SCENARIO THAT THE
NORMANDY INVASION WAS A DIVERSION, AND THAT THE 'FIRST US
13
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
ARMY GROUP' WOULD SOON COME STORMING ACROSS THE CHANNEL
TO STRIKE SOMEWHERE NEAR CALAIS.
16. GERMAN FORCES.
A. COMMAND AND CONTROL. HITLER’S HAD SUSPICION OF HIS
GENERALS AND DIVIDED AUTHORITY AMONG THEM TO DENY OVERALL
POWER TO ANYONE. IN PARIS, FIELD MARSHAL VON RUNDSTEDT
PRESIDED AS COMMANDER IN CHIEF. AT ARMY GROUP B’S
HEADQUARTERS AT LA ROCHE GUYON, FIELD MARSHAL ERWIN
ROMMEL WAS TO BE RESPONSIBLE FOR DIRECTING THE BATTLE
AGAINST THE INVADERS. YET ROMMEL WAS DENIED DIRECT CONTROL
OF THE PANZER DIVISION WHICH HE WANTED TO MAKE THE RESERVE
AVAILABLE IN THE WEST TO POSITION CLOSE BEHIND THE INVASION
BEACHES. VON RUNDSTEDT OVERRULED HIM, PREFERRING TO KEEP A
CENTRAL STRATEGIC RESERVE. THIS DISPUTE WAS RESOLVED BY
HITLER HALF OF THE PANZER DIVISIONS WERE PLACED IN THE
CONTROL OF ROMMEL’S ARMY GROUP B AND THE REMAINDER WAS
DIRECTLY UNDER THE GERMAN HIGH COMMAND. THE PLANS OF THE
TWO FIELD MARSHALS WERE NEVER REALLY RECONCILED. VON
RUNDSTEDT CONTINUED TO SIT ON HIS MOBILE RESERVES, WHILE
ROMMEL SPED UP DOWN THE COAST, INSPECTING UNITS AND
FORTRESSES, SITING GUN, INVENTING OBSTACLES AND GINGERING UP
THE DEFENDERS WITH HIS CONSIDERABLE POWERS OF LEADERSHIP.
14
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
B. BAD WEATHER. ROMMEL’S ASSUMPTION THAT THE ALLIES
WOULD NOT LAUNCH ITS ASSAULT ON STORMY WEATHER HAD LED HIM
TO CHOOSE TO SEE HITLER THUS, LEAVING THE POST COMMAND UNDER
GENERAL ERICH MARCKS, COMMANDING THE 84 CORPS. AS ROMMEL
WAS DRIVING BACK TO GERMANY, THE ALLIES INVASION FLEET WAS
ASSEMBLING AT ITS CONCENTRATION POINT IN THE MIDDLE OF THE
CHANNEL. HAD THE GERMAN U-BOATS OR PATROL PLANES BEEN ON
NORMAL ROUTINE, THEY WOULD HAVE SPOTTED THE CONVOY. THE
ANTICIPATED BAD WEATHER, HOWEVER, KEPT THEM IN PORT OR ON
THE GROUND.
D. SLOW REACTION TO THE LANDINGS. GERMANS WERE
UNCERTAIN OVER THE ALLIED INTENTIONS FOR 1944 INVASION. HITLER
BELIEVED THAT THE INVASION WOULD BE AT NORMANDY; WHILE FM
VON RUNSTEDT AND GEN ROMMEL BELIEVED THAT THE ALLIES WOULD
LAND AT PAS DE CALAIS. THE CONFUSION WAS COMPOUNDED BY THE
ALLIED DROP OF THOUSANDS OF DUMMIES WHICH DOUBLED THE
GERMAN’S UNCERTAINTY. THE ABSENCE OF MANY VITAL SENIOR
GERMAN COMMANDERS RESULTED IN A SLOW REACTION TO THE
LENDINGS. THE SEVENTH ARMY WAS ALERTED AT 0135 HOUR. HALF AN
HOUR EARLIER, GENERAL MARCKS HAD CALLED OUT HIS OWN 84
CORPS.
AT 0600 HOUR, VON RUNDSTEDT’S HEADQUARTERS TOLD THE
GERMAN HIGH COMMAND THAT A MAJOR INVASION APPEARED TO BE
TAKING PLACE, AND ASKED FOR THE RELEASE OF THE ARMOURED
15
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
RESERVE. HOWEVER, THE GERMAN OFFICERS WERE HESITATED TO
WAKE HITLER UP, KNOWINGLY OF HIS DISLIKE TO BE AWAKENED. THUS,
THE REQUEST WAS DENIED. IT WAS NOT FINALLY GRANTED UNTIL TEN
HOURS LATER.
E. DENIAL OF TRAINING FOR THE GERMAN FORCES.
COMMANDERS COMPLAINED THAT THEY WERE BEING DENIED TIME TO
CARRY OUT ESSENTIAL TRAINING BECAUSE THEIR MEN WERE
CONTINUOUSLY EMPLOYED ON BUILDING FORTIFICATIONS. THE
MAJORITY OF THE ARMY WERE FORMATIONS SHATTERED IN THE EAST,
WHICH WOULD NEED MASSIVE REINFORCEMENT AND RE-EQUIPMENT IF
THEY WERE EVER TO REGAIN THEIR OLD FIGHTING POWER.
DOCTRINE
ALLIED FORCES. ALLIED FORCES ADOPTED THE CONCEPT OF JOINT
OPERATION COMBINING MASSIVE FORCES FROM THE ARMY, NAVY AND AIR
FORCES.
GERMAN FORCES. GERMAN CONDUCTED DEFENSIVE OPERATION AND
ADOPTED LINER DEFENCE, WHICH CONCENTRATES MORE FORCES TOWARD
DEFENDING THE BEACH LINE. DUE TO THAT REASON, ALL THE TROOPS HAVE
BEEN UTILIZED AND THERE WERE NO BACKUP FORCES TO DEFENCE THE
DEPTH POSITION. THERE WERE ALSO NO SUFFICIENT RESERVED FORCES.
LOGISTIC SYSTEM
16
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
ALLIED FORCES. THE LOGISTIC BUILDUP IN BRITAIN BEGAN IN 1942.
WITH 39 DIVISIONS TO PARTICIPATE IN THE INVASION, THERE WAS LITTLE TIME
TO WASTE. THE NUMBER OF US FIGHTING MEN BASED IN GREAT BRITAIN
ALONE, DOUBLED IN THE FIRST SIX MONTHS OF 1944, RISING TO 1,537,000.
MORE THAN 16 MILLION TONS OF SUPPLIES WERE NEEDED, AS WELL AS 137,000
JEEPS, TRUCKS AND HALF-TRACK; 4,217 TANKS AND FULLY TRACKED
VEHICLES; 3,500 ARTILLERY PIECES; 12,000 AIRCRAFT; AND HUGE STORES OF
SUNDRIES. TO MEET THIS REQUIREMENT, THE SEABORNE TRANSIT SYSTEM, A
BUILD-UP CONTROL ORGANIZATION WAS FORMED TO HANDLE THE SEA
TRANSIT OF PERSONNEL AND STORES DURING THE LANDING PERIOD.
COMMAND AND CONTROL
GENERAL DWIGHT EISENHOWER WAS APPOINTED AS THE SUPREME
COMMANDER ALLIED EXPEDITIONARY FORCE. AIR CHIEF MARSHAL SIR
ARTHUR W. TEDDER WAS THE DEPUTY COMMANDER. ADMIRAL SIR BERTRAM
RAMSAY WAS ALLIED NAVAL FORCES COMMANDER, WHILE THE US AND
BRITISH TACTICAL AIR FORCES WERE UNDER THE COMMAND OF AIR CHIEF
MARSHAL TRAFFORD LEIGH-MALLORY. LIEUTENANT GENERAL OMAR NELSON
BRADLEY COMMANDED US ARMY GROUP AND GENERAL SIR BERNARD
MONTGOMERY COMMANDED BRITISH ARMY GROUPS RESPECTIVELY.
LIEUTENANT GENERAL WALTER BEDELL SMITH, WAS CHIEF OF STAFF
SUPREME HEADQUARTERS. THIS ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE RESULTED IN
17
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
THE DIRECT INTEGRATION OF THE COALITION FORCES AND CONTRIBUTED
SIGNIFICANTLY TO THEIR OVERALL COMBAT EFFECTIVENESS.
APPLICATION OF PRINCIPLES OF WAR
SELECTIONS AND MAINTENANCE OF THE AIM. THE ALLIES HAD MADE
NO SECRET OF THEIR INTENTION TO INVADE EUROPE AND FOR ITS
LIBERATION FROM THE CLENCH OF HITLER. GEN GENERAL’S AIM WAS TO
DESTRUCT GERMAN ARMED FORCES. AS EARLY AS JULY 1941, PLANS AFTER
PLANS HAD BEEN DISCUSSED AND REVISED UNTIL THE ALLIES ARRIVED AT
THE DECISION TO LAUNCH THE ASSAULT AROUND THE FIRST WEEK OF JUNE
1944, WHICH THEY NAMED IT OPERATION OVERLORD. THE SELECTION AND
THE MAINTENANCE OF THE AIM HAD BEEN FOCUSED WHICH LED TO THE
DEFEAT OF GERMANY.
CONCENTRATION OF FORCE. THE PLAN IN OPERATION OVERLORD IS
BASED ON TWO MAIN PRINCIPLES THAT IS CONCENTRATION OF FORCE AND
TACTICAL SURPRISE. CONCENTRATION OF THE ASSAULT IS CONSIDERED
ESSENTIAL IF WE ARE TO ENSURE ADEQUATE AIR SUPPORT AND IF OUR
LIMITED ASSAULT FORCES ARE TO AVOID DEFEAT IN DETAIL. FIRE POWER
PLAYED A KEY ROLE IN THE SUCCESS OF OVERLORD. THE APPLICATION OF
FIREPOWER HAD DEFINITELY A DECISIVE IMPACT ON THE CONDUCT OF THE
CAMPAIGN OR MAJOR OPERATION.
18
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
COOPERATION. BENEATH THE TENSION BETWEEN GOVERNMENTS AND
ARMY HEADQUARTERS ON MATTERS OF HIGH POLICY, OFFICERS OF THE
AMERICAN AND BRITISH WORKED SIDE BY SIDE WITH EXTRAORDINARY
AMITY IN THE PREPARATIONS FOR OPERATION OVERLORD.
OFFENSIVE ACTIONS. FIRE POWER PLAYED A KEY ROLE IN THE
SUCCESS OF OPERATION OVERLORD. ON THE BEACHES OF UTAH, OMAHA,
GOLD, JUNO AND SWORD BECAME A LIVING HELL FOR THE GERMAN
DEFENDERS. THE AIR AND NAVAL PRE-INVASION BOMBARDMENT HAD OPENED
FIRE. SHELL WAS FIRED FROM THE THOUSANDS OF BATTLESHIPS, CRUISERS
AND DESTROYERS LYING OFF THE COAST AND BOMB AFTER BOMBS FELL
INLAND, LEAVING THE BEACHES NON-CRATERED, BUT EVENTUALLY MAKING
THE ASSAULT INLAND EASIER.
SURPRISE. THE GERMANS WERE CAUGHT BY SURPRISE WHEN THE
ALLIES LAUNCHED THE ASSAULT ON 6 JUNE 1944. THE LAST GERMAN AERIAL
RECONNAISSANCE ON 24 MAY BEFORE D-DAY REVEALED NO SUDDEN
CONCENTRATION OF SHIPPING IN THE PORTS OF DOVER, FOLK STONE AND
ALONG THE THEMES. THE WEATHER APPARENTLY ALONG THE CHANNEL WAS
GOING TO WORSEN ON 2 JUNE 1944.
FLEXIBILITY. THE PLAN IN OPERATION OVERLORD WAS SIMPLE.
HENCE, THAT OPERATION WAS CONDUCTED SMOOTHLY, EFFICIENTLY AND
PROVEN EFFECTIVE DUE TO THE PLAN WHICH WAS MADE SIMPLE THROUGH
DELIBERATE. IN THE OPERATION OVERLORD, THE ALLIES FORCES WERE
19
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
DEPLOYED BY SECTORS. THE PRESENT COMMANDERS ARE LAUDABLE TO
EXERCISE CLEAR AND SIMPLE PLANS FOR THE SUCCESS OF ANY OPERATION
OR BATTLE. ITS ACCOMPLISHMENT REMAINS THE GREATEST ORGANIZATION
ACHIEVEMENT OF THE SECOND WORLD WAR.
MAINTENANCE OF MORALE. MORALE OF MEN HAS TO BE
MAINTAINED AT ALL TIMES. GEN MONTGOMERY WENT AROUND TO VISITS
THE BRITISH AND AMERICAN TROOPS ASSIGNED TO THE NORMANDY ASSAULT
TWO WEEKS BEFORE THE INVASION. EVEN KING GEORGE V, THE BRITISH
MONARCH THEN, VISITED THE TROOPS.
LESSON LEARNT
ALLIED FORCES
PLANNING. PROPER PLANNING AND INTENSIVE TRAINING WERE
CRUCIAL FACTORS WHICH MUST BE GIVEN HIGH PRIORITY FOR THE
SUCCESSFUL OPERATIONS AS SHOWN IN OPERATION OVERLORD . THE ALLIED
TOOK ALMOST FOUR YEARS IN PLANNING THIS OPERATION, WHICH INCLUDE
THE MANAGEMENT OF RESOURCES AND TRAINING OF THE SOLDIERS.
THEREFORE ALTHOUGH MALAYSIA HAVE NO IMMINENT THREATS, MAF MUST
CONTINUE THE PLANNING AND CONDUCTING TRAINING IN ORDER TO FACE
UNFORSEEN SITUATION.
20
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
TECHNOLOGY. EXPLOITATION OF TECHNOLOGY BY ALLIED FORCES
HAD ACCENTUATED THE MASSIVE STRENGTH OF THE COMBINED COALITION
FORCES WHICH WAS FULLY CAPABLE OF SUPPORTING THE COALITION EFFORT.
AS AN EXAMPLE, THE AMERICAN P-51 MUSTANG FIGHTER MADE ITS GREATEST
CONTRIBUTION TO THE ALLIED, VICTORY BY WINNING THE BATTLE FOR AIR
SUPREMACY OVER GERMANY BEFORE D- DAY. THIS SCENARIO ALSO
OCCURRED IN THE GULF WAR, WHEREBY THE COUNTRY WHICH POSSESSED
ADVANCE TECHNOLOGY WEAPONS GAIN CONTROL OVER THEIR OPPONENT.
THEREFORE, NEITHER THE MALAYSIAN GOVERNMENT NOR MAF MUST
CONSIDER THIS FACTORS SERIOUSLY AND CONTINUOUSLY EQUIPPED THE MAF
WITH THE LATEST TECHNOLOGY EQUIPMENTS.
AIR POWER. DURING THE CAMPAIGN, THE CONTROL OF THE AIR HAS
SHOWN A GREAT IMPACT ON THE RESULT OF THE WAR. WITH MORE THAN
12,000 AIRCRAFTS CONDUCTING STRATEGIC BOMBING OVER GERMAN
FRONTLINE HAS LEAD TO THE SUCCESSFUL LANDING OF THE ALLIED TROOPS
IN NORMANDY BEACHES. IN RECENT WAR, AIR POWER WAS USED
INTENSIVELY TO NUETRALISE ENEMY STRENGTH AND WIN THE WAR IN SHORT
PERIODS. THEREFORE IT IS VITAL FOR THE MAF TO HAVE SUFFICIENT
NUMBERS OF ADVANCE AIRCRAFT
COMMAND AND CONTROL
21
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
THE LEADERS OF THE ALLIED FORCES HAS BEEN GIVEN THE FREEDOM
OF EXUCUTING THEIR COMMAND AND CONTROL IN ACHIEVING THE ALLIED
OBJECTIVE. THEY WORK VERY CLOSELY AND PUT ASIDE THEIR NATIONAL AIM
AND FOCUS FOR WINNING THE BATTLE.
GERMAN FORCES.
LINEAR DEFENCE. DUE TO THE LONG STRETCH OF THE NORMANDY
COASTLINE, THE GERMAN HAS NO OTHER MEANS AND ADOPTING A SINGLE
LAYER DEFENCE AND RESULTED LESS CONCENTRATION ON THE REAR AREA.
THE ALLIED FORCES TOOK THESE ADVANTAGES BY DEPLOYING THE
AIRBORNE DIVISIONS PENETRATING DEEP INTO GERMAN TERRITORY AND
CONTROLLING THE STRATEGIC AREA. MALAYSIA SURROUNDED BY SEA WITH
OVER 2,000 KM COASTLINE. IF THE GERMANS NEED 48 DIVISIONS TO LAY HER
DEFENCE FROM CALAIS TO SAINTE MERE EGLISE, MALAYSIA NEED MORE
DIVISIONS TO COVER-UP HER COASTLINE. BUT LINEAR DEFENCE IS NOT THE
ANSWER, BECAUSE IT NOT IN LINE WITH THE DEFENCE PRINCIPLES.
COMMAND AND CONTROL. THE HITLER ADOPTED THE AUTOCRATIC
STYLE OF LEADERSHIP WHEREBY THE GERMAN COMMANDERS HAD NO VOICE
IN MAKING ANY PLANS OR DECISION. DUE TO THIS REASON, THE GERMAN
FORCES ARE SLOW IN TAKING ANY ACTIONS AGAINST THE ALLIED INVASION.
THEREFORE COMANDERS IN MAF SHOULD NOT PRACTISED AUTOCRATIC
SYSTEM AND ONE MAN DECISION MAKING.
CONCLUSION
22
RESTRICTED
RESTRICTED
ON THE D-DAY OF OPERATION OVERLORD, ALL ELEMENTS OF A
COMBINED ALLIED FORCES HAD BEEN BROUGHT TOGETHER AND USED IN
HARMONY WHEREBY THE AIR FORCES TO WEAKEN THE ENEMY RESPONSE,
WARSHIPS TO PROTECT THE TRANSPORT FLEET, AIRBORNE DIVISIONS TO
SECURE THE FLANKS AND STRIKE DEEP INTO ENEMY TERRITORY, INFANTRY
AND AMOUR TO CARVE OUT THE FOOT HOLD FROM WHICH THE LIBERATION
OF WESTERN EUROPE WOULD BEGIN. THE FACT THAT IT ALL WORKED IS A
LASTING TRIBUTE TO ALL THE PEOPLE INVOLVED.
23
RESTRICTED